This morning the news blared out across the land that The Criterion Collection –the best friend of every cineaste– would be exclusively sharing their entire library on Hulu Plus. This means more than 800 of the best transfers of the best films of all time will soon be available to stream for a mere $7.99 a month (plus all the other benefits of the service, though they pale in comparison). This came as quite a shock, as Criterion has been slowly releasing more and more of their library onto Netflix’s Instant Watch service over the last year.
Many have speculated about what this means for Criterion titles that are already housed on Instant Watch, but we can now confirm that their titles will be down by the end of the year, and Criterion’s films will return to being available by disc only from Netflix. Our own Jeremy Butler was sharp enough to get quick word from Criterion’s own Jon Mulvaney on the subject…
Dear Jeremy,
Thanks for your email!
Hulu will have exclusive streaming rights to our films and so all of the films that are currently on Netflix streaming will be down by the end of the year.
We love Netflix, and they are still one of Criterion’s most important partners, but Hulu demonstrated a real commitment to the Criterion brand that persuaded us they would be the better home base for our streaming efforts. It has never been easy to find Criterion movies on Netflix — “Criterion” is not even a searchable term there. Compare that with Hulu’s willingness to develop a whole area of their site around us, brand the films associated with us, and develop the capability to show many of our supplements alongside our films. The energetic, independent, creative team at Hulu was willing to build their business around us in a way that just wasn’t in the cards anywhere else.
We will continue to support Netflix on the package goods side and continue to work with them to provide DVD and BD copies of the films we release.
I hope this information is helpful! Please let me know if you have any more questions and thanks for supporting Criterion!
Best,
Jon Mulvaney
So that seals it- Criterion has made the full migration and single-handedly made Hulu Plus a must-have service. The homepage for Criterion can be found here, which will lead you to the 150+ titles that have already been ported over, with the full catalog arriving within the coming months.
Already one can see what Jon means about a dedication to the brand- the homepage is quite convenient and much nicer than having to use third-party list sites to run-down which Criterion films are on Instant Watch. With the added bonus of accessible special features, this looks to be a delightful partnership- as long as picture quality stays as high as possible.
Hulu’s announcement can be read here.
Let us know what you think in this shift between services in the comments below, or on the boards. Is this enough to make you start with Hulu Plus? Is Netflix in any danger, now that they’ve lost a very important feather in their cap?









They’re not in any danger. Your everyday Joe Schmoe Moviegoer that has Netflix probably doesn’t even know what The Criterion Collection is. For us cinephiles, however; this blows. That said, I don’t believe I’ve ever streamed a Criterion disc to my XBOX 360 or Wii. I usually just buy ‘em.
Why will it blow to have every single one of their titles easily available, as opposed to the very limited amount on Netflix?
Oops, what I meant to say is that it blows for us Netflix users. That’s a fantastic deal for those with Hulu, however; I don’t use the service yet.
Nope, wait, never mind, I streamed “Gammorah” via Netflix, watched the first few minutes.
I find that the quality of streaming Netflix is pretty bad, so I don’t do it. If Hulu can do better, then I’m all for it. Especially with Criterion films.
I will miss this stuff on Netflix–I have watched a ton of Criterion stuff that way. The quality is usually adequate. I’ll be happy to have some of the other content available on HULU though so maybe it’ll just be time for a switch.
Boo. So that means someday soon, when Netflix stops sending out discs and goes streaming only, Netflix customers will not be able to watch Criterion films unless they either buy the discs or subscribe to Hulu. This sucks. Don’t want to sign on for another service.
I must admit, however, that I tried Hulu once and the video quality is immaculate.
Will this still have ads in it, like everything else in Hulu plus? If they’re gonna charge 8 bucks and then make you sit through ads in the middle of something like Salo, then they skip and go fuck themselves.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Renn Brown and Margarita Sophia, CHUD. CHUD said: CRITERION TELLS CHUD ABOUT THE NETFLIX-TO-HULU SHIFT http://bit.ly/gQ98f7 (via @chuddotcom) [...]
I hate this exclusivity crap. How long before you have to subscribe to a half dozen services to get a selection of most films/TV?
So this comes down to branding, not movies?
I’m grateful to Criterion for their good work in getting movies out to us. But I almost never search out movies by label. Maybe I’m rare that way. All I know is that this means I’ll be forced to pay another monthly bill if I want to see a movie that happens to wear the Criterion label.
I’d bitch less if this means ALL Criterion films will be streaming on Hulu, but I have a feeling this won’t be the case.
oh all 800 titles will be available on Hulu. Once the deals with Netflix expire, every thing Criterion will be on Hulu Plus. Seriously, it’s not Hulu but Hulu Plus, and that’s reason alone to be pissed at Criterion. Seriously, their brand is wonderful, but not to the point to sign up for a complete and utter bullshit service.
sell better internet TVs so i don’t need to switch between my shitty Digital receiver, Xbox/netflix, Hulu/laptop.. thank you.
I can wait for the DVD in the mail, picture quality will be better anyway, which is what I do most of the time with Netflix, even if it is available instantly. Not subscribing to Hulu…no thanks.
[...] they expect to remove all of their titles from Netflix instant streaming by the end of 2011. In a letter to CHUD.com, Criterion’s Jon Mulvaney provided a little bit more insight into their [...]
Fuck the fact that this is always exclusive to America. I want a Hulu or a Netflix! Somebody in Australia pay attention to me!