Yeah, I don't understand the "Dark City" hatred either. I agree with the criticism that it would have been a more interesting film removing Kiefer Sutherland's "Clarissa Explains It All" narration, but despite that and other flaws, it's a lavishly stylistic film with fantastic atmosphere. Plus, a non anorexic Jennifer Connelly is always appreciated.
I'm torn on a Scanner's remake, as while no one will be able to touch Michael Ironside's awe inspiring Revok, the complete vacuum of charisma one-two punch of Jennifer O'Neil and the appropriately named Stephen Lack has to come out better.