CHUD.com Community › Forums › MUSIC › Music › Richard Thompson - 1000 Years of Popular Music
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Richard Thompson - 1000 Years of Popular Music

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I picked this up on a whim last week while I was going through the clearance section at Megatunes. It's been one of the best blind buys I've made in years.

Apparently Playboy asked Thompson and other musicians to list the best songs of the last Millenium and Thompson, being the smart ass bugger that he is, sent them a list of songs from the last thousand years. They never published his list but never one to stop a good joke from going too far Thompson put together a band to record said songs.

The first disc is filled with tunes you'll most likely never hear on the radio in any form. He starts with a rowdy version of Summer Is Icumen In from the thirteenth century. It turns into an amazing round with Thompson being joined on vocals by Judith Owen and Debra Dobkin.

The first disc just kind of takes off from there. Whether it's a haunting rendition of O Shenandoah or a passing nod to Fairport Convention with I Live in Trafalger Square Thompson and his band never let up. Filled with fancy noodling on guitar (Blackleg Miner is particularly great) and vocals the first disc makes the package a must have.

Sadly, the second disc isn't quite as good. It starts out fun (his version of Orange Colored Sky is a blast) but it seems to fall apart in the middle starting with See My Friends. I love the Kinks original but it just doesn't seem to fit with the rest of the songs. Then he follows it up with a laid back version of Friday on My Mind and a wholly unsatisfying version of Tempted by Squeeze. I'll admit that I'm not a huge fan of the original but Thompson doesn't seem to add anything new to it other than some nicely growled lyrics.

He ends the disc with a novelty song (a decent version of Oops...I Did It Again) and two pretty cool songs. Cry Me a River is schmaltz of the highest order but it comes out sounding great here. And his version of 1985 by Bowling For Soup is just about the perfect way to end this bizarre time tripping CD set.

So, while it lags in the middle of disc two, it's well worth the pick up. I haven't watched the DVD yet but I'm planning on putting it on the big screen at work on the weekend so I'll let you know how that goes.
post #2 of 6
Odd. Maybe I'll pick this up.
post #3 of 6
A friend told me about this a while ago and I've never had the chance to listen to it. Richard Thompson is definitely one of the most skilled and unique guitar players around, though.
post #4 of 6
I really like Thompson's version of "Tempted," actually, but I love the original. Confusingly enough, there are two identically-named live albums that Thomson released for these shows. The one you have (the double-disc with the DVD) is the second release. The first one - a lengthy single disc deal - is from an earlier show with Michael Jerome on drums. There are a number of repeated songs, but they didn't play some of the best stuff at the show on the more widely-released version you have:

Purcell's "When I Am Laid in Earth" (aka "Dido's Lament") - sung by Judith Owen (whom I really don't like as a vocalist, generally,* but she sounds good on this)
The Who's "A Legal Matter"
ABBA's "Money, Money, Money"
and, best of all...
Prince's "Kiss"

The Wiki entry has the full tracklist for both. I'm not sure if the early one is still available. I think you could only get it on his site or at his shows.

* In fact, Owen is one of the things that negatively colors the last few Thompson studio albums for me, too. She's no Linda Thompson. Or Teddy Thompson, for that matter - he did a stellar, strangely (but not so strangely) Linda-like job singing with his dad on Mock Tudor and the subsequent tour. Their duet on "Persuasion" (a song Richard wrote with Neil Finn that showed up on a best of) was a highlight.
post #5 of 6
Oh, yeah - one other thing. I wish Thompson had decided to do at least some of these songs with a full band or electric. I'd love to hear him rip out an electric solo over something like "Blackleg Miner."
post #6 of 6
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveB
Purcell's "When I Am Laid in Earth" (aka "Dido's Lament") - sung by Judith Owen (whom I really don't like as a vocalist, generally,* but she sounds good on this)
The Who's "A Legal Matter"
ABBA's "Money, Money, Money"
and, best of all...
Prince's "Kiss"
Damn. I'm going to have to find the first disc now. Thompson has a way of interpreting pop songs that somehow manages to keep them fun while lending an air of gravitas to them. It's interesting.

I'm with you on Judith Owen. I haven't liked any of her stuff yet somehow her vocals really work on this album. She's always struck me as similar to Holly Cole. Strong vocal range but very little passion and her phrasing seems off.

Quote:
Oh, yeah - one other thing. I wish Thompson had decided to do at least some of these songs with a full band or electric. I'd love to hear him rip out an electric solo over something like "Blackleg Miner."
That would be tremendous. His acoustic version rips it up but an electric would peel wallpaper.
__________________
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Music
CHUD.com Community › Forums › MUSIC › Music › Richard Thompson - 1000 Years of Popular Music