Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Overlord
So they go to slaughterhouses or ranches and kill animals bred for that purpose, rather than arbitrarily removing healthy males and females from natural populations. That makes sense.
|
First of all, I don't even know if that is possible because of slaughterhouse regulations. If it is, I would like to know. Second, and this is a point I didn't make earlier but addresses one which you mentioned, the deer population NEEDS to be thinned. I won't go into arguments that thinning is good for deer, because I don't have the resources to back that up, although I imagine the research is out there. However, if you would like, I
can send you peer-reviewed journal articles that show that an overabundance of deer and elk cause significant detrimental effects of surrounding ecosystems. In Yellowstone, once wolves became re-established, they affected the food chain dramatically, decreasing elk populations, which allowed young cottonwoods to grow, which allowed beaver populations to recover.
http://www.cof.orst.edu/leopold/papers/ripple.pdf
In most studied ecosystems, carnivores can cause top-down trophic cascades which enhance biodiversity.
Unfortunately, wolves and other large carnivores will never be allowed to persist in most of the US. I am a wildlife biologist in Wisconsin, and my areas of study are wolves and bears and their interaction with their ecosystem, people, and livestock. The wolf population here is probably well beyond the social carrying capacity, but it is still far short of what is needed to control deer populations and enhance biodiversity.
The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources is practically begging people to hunt. There is no other real control on deer (except for cars, which are the largest "predators").
Do I wish that predators were prevalent enough that they kept the deer population in check and enhanced healthy ecosystems? You betcha (not least because that would be great job security for me!). I would love for ecosystems to function without humans fucking it up. But it's just not going to happen.
So, there are many reasons to hunt. But I don't want to forget the whole point of this thread. That woman is an asshole, and that type of hunting is that which assholes do. Sure, my cold scientist heart says that killing an albino deer is actually exactly what would happen in a completely natural system (a predator would have a much greater chance of seeing that deer, and therefore killing it). But I'm not that much of a machine. People like that give me the creeps.
Most hunters I know enjoy being connected to their food, and are fully aware that they are taking a beautiful life when they kill. All of my friends feel profound regret when they do so, but they are meat eaters, and have made a conscious eyes-open decision to eat meat.
EDITED to fix punctuation.