I think there are 3 distinct things going on here that make the PUMA phenomenon look biigger than it is:
1. There is a big chunk of white, working class, mostly rural democrats who aren't yet won over to Obama. That much is fact, born out by the poll numbers.
2. There is a small but very loud group of people that could best be described as "Hillary Fanboys," who over-identify on a personal level with Hillary, and who are claiming to represent the constituency of item 1.
3. Republican operatives are providing a megaphone for the PUMA people, trying to make them a bigger deal than they are. Which makes sense, they're going after a perceived weakness in their opponent.
But I don't believe that this big block that's keeping Obama's numbers from being what they should be are specifically about Hillary. They would vote for Hillary, they'd vote for Biden, they'd vote for Edwards, but they're not sure about Obama. Race may be a big part of it, or class prejudice (he looks like the kind of guy that lives in the city and went to a fancy school and bla bla bla). For whatever reason, they just don't feel comfortable with him YET.
1. There is a big chunk of white, working class, mostly rural democrats who aren't yet won over to Obama. That much is fact, born out by the poll numbers.
2. There is a small but very loud group of people that could best be described as "Hillary Fanboys," who over-identify on a personal level with Hillary, and who are claiming to represent the constituency of item 1.
3. Republican operatives are providing a megaphone for the PUMA people, trying to make them a bigger deal than they are. Which makes sense, they're going after a perceived weakness in their opponent.
But I don't believe that this big block that's keeping Obama's numbers from being what they should be are specifically about Hillary. They would vote for Hillary, they'd vote for Biden, they'd vote for Edwards, but they're not sure about Obama. Race may be a big part of it, or class prejudice (he looks like the kind of guy that lives in the city and went to a fancy school and bla bla bla). For whatever reason, they just don't feel comfortable with him YET.







