The album is horrible. Blah blah it's only my opinion blah blah. But it is indeed horrible. First time I actually laughed out loud at a song, and I mean an honest laugh. I figured most people that liked it were having a Crystal Skull Syndrome thing, but apparently there weren't that many.
Blame, though, is on not releasing Better as the lead single. Even though I think he overproduced it (by which I mean, I think I'll try to track down the demo that leaked a couple years ago because I think I prefer it), that track has the benefit of being "good", which the rest of the album does not. Blah blah only opinion blah blah blah.
Still, live Guns fills stadiums no? So I think Axl must find himself pretty liberated. His album crashed and burned, so he is probably realizing that not being perfect ain't the end of the world. Or, he is deluded and sees it as a success and feels invincible. Either way, he can release whatever he wants now and we have another Smashing Pumpkin-like comeback that amounts to quite a meh.