Quote:
Originally Posted by alfalfa 
Omar is simply a horrible executive. He used to be the GM for the Expos, and he completely destroyed the franchise (it wasn't just the low revenues, trust me). He let Pedro Martinez and Vlad Guerrero go and somehow had one of the worst farms in the league by the time he left the team and they moved to Washington. He can't even take credit for David Wright or Jose Reyes as they were acquired before he became GM I believe.
|
Erm, I may be late to the party, but this post is just ridiculous. First, Omar Minaya wasn't the GM of the Expos when they "let go" of Pedro Martinez, that was Jim Beattie. Then again, the very idea that the Expos ever had a choice when it came to keeping prospective free agents is absurd, as they were never in a position, financially, to retain them (the one caveat being Vladimir Guerrero's first contract, but that exists as nothing more than the exception that proves the rule).
But yeah, you're fucking right about Minaya letting Guerrero go. I mean, sure, Guerrero was a free agent, and the Montreal Expos were being run by MLB, but I'm sure Minaya could have convinced ownership – a collective consisting of opposing owners – to come up with the resources necessary to beat Anaheim's $85 million dollar offer, with contraction looming no less.
If you want to attack Minaya's tenure with the Expos, you go after the Bartolo Colon trade, which, if you completely ignore context, looks ridiculously awful.
How the fuck can you possibly excuse trading Grady Sizemore, Brandon Philips (the centerpiece at the time) and Cliff Lee for Bartolo Colon you deranged Mets fan? Well, when managing the resources of a team that was to be contracted at any moment, chits like A ball prospects are practically meaningless. The Expos were looking to win now, as tomorrow was hardly a guarantee.
As far as his run with the Mets is concerned, Minaya's worst move to date was exposing Jesus Flores to the Rule V draft. One of the better Mets prospects at the time, and seemingly unaware of the rules in place, the Mets thought the chances of a team keeping an A ball catcher on their Major League roster for an entire season were minimal. But, apparently, they never met the Washington Nationals.
His next blunder was the Lastings Milledge trade, which, even in it's current state, I'm
still firmly against. Beyond that, you're picking nits. Minaya convinced the Wilpons to open their wallets, traded Kris Benson for John Maine, and, for the most part, have yet to sign a single debilitating contract. Coming from where they've come from, Minaya's run is easily their best since Frank Cashen's (God, what an awful organization).