CHUD.com Community › Forums › ARTS & LITERATURE › Comics & Anime › Must Reads?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Must Reads?

post #1 of 35
Thread Starter 
Just recently I've begun buying and collecting comic books (yes I know, I suck, to my defense I've read much before but mostly at friends and never really owned ones) and because there's so much out there, I'd love to know which ones are the best you'd recommend. I began buying the following stuff as I knew them before or read of them, but I'm sure there's tons more that a true geek needs to own on his shelves.

So far I have:

Watchmen

Batman - Dark Victory
Batman - The Killing Joke
Batman - The Long Halloween

Hulk - Planet Hulk
Wolverine - Weapon X
Black Hole
Marvel Zombies
Wanted

Uncanny X-Men: Dark Phoenix Saga
Uncanny X-Men: Days of Future Past
post #2 of 35
Starman by James Robinson and Tony Harris (along with Peter Snejbjerg and others). They just released a nice hardcover edition (which I'm drooling over) that can be had on Amazon.com for around $32 or so. Also, Y the Last Man, Ex Machina, The Exterminators, and Fables.
post #3 of 35
Might not be the most popular/cool choice in the world, but I've always thought Judge Dredd: Apocalypse Wars is about as awesome as comics get (outside of Watchmen) and is about all you need to know about Dredd, as well as being an epic read.
post #4 of 35
Transmetropolitan. Preacher. At least check them out. People have their criticisms of both, but overall they're pretty solid and entertaining.

Also seconding Y The Last Man
post #5 of 35
Grant Morrison's run on Animal Man.
post #6 of 35
Tales From the Crypt, The Vault of Horror, and The Haunt of Fear, newly reprinted (albeit pricey). Avoid the "remakes" currently being published like the motherfucking plague.
post #7 of 35
Any of the Eisner stuff. "A Contract with God", "The Spirit" and etc.

Also, try to grab "The Pride of Baghdad" and any of the B.R.P.D. stuff.
post #8 of 35
Yeah, BPRD is greatness. For as much as I love Hellboy, BPRD seems much more cohesive.
post #9 of 35
I second all the Brian K. Vaughan love.

Also:
The New Frontier (stay away from the ass-tastic movie)
Marvels
post #10 of 35
Sandman.
post #11 of 35
Concrete. I recommend starting with Fragile Creature.

Love and Rockets. Chester Square and Love and Rockets X are amazing.

As for superhero stuff, you can't go wrong with Mark Waid. Birthright may just be the ultimate Superman origin story, and I loved his run on Fantastic Four.

If you're stocking up on Batman, you can't leave out The Dark Knight Returns.

Alan Moore's run on Swamp Thing was pretty great.

(edit) Speaking of Brian K. Vaughan, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Season Eight is currently the only comic I buy unread.
post #12 of 35
Ah, Hammerhead! What's a good jumping-off point for someone who's a Love and Rockets virgin? (the name of the collection, if you will)
post #13 of 35
PLANETARY.
Criminal
League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
100 Bullets
Superman: RED SON

These are my favorites.
post #14 of 35
Maus
The Invisibles
Anything by writer / artist "Jason" (The Left Bank Gang, I Killed Adolf Hitler), or Joe Matt (Spent, Peepshow)
Any Wally Wood stuff you can find
Anything by Joe Sacco (Palestine, Notes From A Defeatist)
The Fletcher Hanks collection: I Shall Destroy All The Civilzed Planets (although, I think you posted in my thread about it from a while back, so you may already have that)
post #15 of 35
Also, Jeff Smith's "Bone". I re-acquainted myself with it over the weekend, and it's still pretty great.
post #16 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
Ah, Hammerhead! What's a good jumping-off point for someone who's a Love and Rockets virgin? (the name of the collection, if you will)
Chester Square for Jaime (slick art, lady wrestlers), X for Gilbert (L.A. punk scene, occasional psychedelia). That's an extremely reductive description and once you get hooked you'll probably want to start from the beginning so you can follow all the characters' histories.
post #17 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by JacknifeJohnny View Post
The Fletcher Hanks collection: I Shall Destroy All The Civilized Planets!
Yes. Breathtakingly weird stuff.
post #18 of 35
Y The Last Man is overrated schlock.

Sounds like you dig on the superheroes.
Dig on this:

Astro City
Marvels
Nextwave
And you'll probably like anything Hellboy and The Goon
post #19 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by BobClark View Post
Y The Last Man is overrated schlock.
...
post #20 of 35
Check out Frank Miller's entire Daredevil run, but especially Born Again, which might be my all-time favorite comic run. Then check out the Daredevil TPB Underboss, which made me fall in love with comics all over again after a few years of separation. It's the most unconventional, modern, and original few issues we've gotten from Marvel in more than a decade. I can't stress the amazingness of Underboss enough.
post #21 of 35
Usagi Yojimbo
Elfquest
Walter Simonson's Thor run from the '80s
post #22 of 35
Top 10
post #23 of 35
In the pulp and superhero vein, Hellboy, BPRD and Invincible are probably the best ongoing series, although Runaways had some excellent storylines. The first volume of League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Grant Morrison's Arkham Asylum, Alan Moore's The Killing Joke, Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns and Batman: Year One and Neil Gaiman's Marvel 1602 are an excellent set of trades and minis. Out of the ongoing stuff that the two big publishers (Marvel and DC) have going on, my own pick of the current lot would be Fables.

If you're into trying more than just superheroes, Sandman is essential. Preacher and Transmetropolitan are well worth your time. V for Vendetta and From Hell are pretty major single graphic novels, and The Invisibles is fairly interesting.

If you want to go even further out of the mainstream, start with Bone. I then recommend anything by Posy Simmonds, some of Rick Veitch's work, Gary Spencer Milledge's Strangehaven, Linda Medley's Castle Waiting, Tove Janson's Moomin strips, and anything at all by Bryan Talbot. Maus is a possible, too.

Generally, I'd add that most of the really good writing in comics is not found within the superhero genre. Whether you want to pursue that specturm of things depends more whether you're looking for entertainment or anything more.
post #24 of 35
Any of Dark Horse's collections of Savage Sword of Conan or the Chronicles of Conan - great, old school art, great adaptions by Roy Thomas of Howard's original stories.

Also, Dark Horse's digest-sized run of the original Lone Wolf and Cub is highly recommended.
post #25 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
Ah, Hammerhead! What's a good jumping-off point for someone who's a Love and Rockets virgin? (the name of the collection, if you will)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hammerhead View Post
Chester Square for Jaime (slick art, lady wrestlers), X for Gilbert (L.A. punk scene, occasional psychedelia). That's an extremely reductive description and once you get hooked you'll probably want to start from the beginning so you can follow all the characters' histories.
I dunno. I'd recommend going earlier with Jaime's work. Chester Square is undoubtedly great but the events therein are very much a reflection of events that occur earlier. With no history the reader may be left to wonder exactly who Maggie is and what is her fixation with Hopey. There is also referential stuff that I imagine will fall flat with lesser knowledge of character history. Chester Square finds Maggie after the Speedy saga and her romance with Ray D. which are two story lines that, in my opinion, are integral to understanding her at that juncture.

Fantagraphics has put out some pretty new collections of Los Bros. work that is good looking and very affordable. I'd say pick up The Girl From HOPPERS and Perla La Loca which you can get from Amazon for less than 20 bucks for both. The Girl From HOPPERS has The Speedy Ortiz story and Perla La Loca contains the Chester Square storyline.

http://www.amazon.com/Girl-HOPPERS-S...3922845&sr=1-3

http://www.amazon.com/Perla-Loca-Roc...3922845&sr=1-5

As for Gilbert, Love And Rockets X is fine but I'd start at the very beginning with Heartbreak Soup as the Palomar epic is pretty interwoven with the Love And Rockets X storyline. After that is Human Diastrophism and then Beyond Palomar which contains Love And Rockets X and what many believe to be Gilbert's magnum opus, Poison River. These are available in the same type of collections from Fantagraphics as the Jaime collections. I am not a shill for Fantagraphics nor am I trying to make you broke, I just think that Love And Rockets is so rich it deserves to be absorbed from the start.
post #26 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Odd Creature View Post
Elfquest
Does Elfquest hold up? I was really into it in high school, but I liked Piers Anthony then too. Rude awakening, that.

Quote:
Walter Simonson's Thor run from the '80s
When was the Giant Frog storyline?

Regarding Love and Rockets, the main reason I don't suggest starting at the beginning is because it took Los Bros (especially Jaime) a while to find their style. The early sci-fi stuff, while still canon, doesn't appeal to me as much as the later slice-of-life material.
post #27 of 35
Yeah, I dig that's why I left out the Maggie The Mechanic collection. And since Amazon has them so cheap those interested should just go for it. I do think that Chester Square is enrichened by the events of previous storylines. Speedy Ortiz in particular. Gilbert, however, was pretty great from the start.
post #28 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xagarath Ankor View Post
In the pulp and superhero vein, Hellboy, BPRD and Invincible are probably the best ongoing series, although Runaways had some excellent storylines. The first volume of League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Grant Morrison's Arkham Asylum, Alan Moore's The Killing Joke, Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns and Batman: Year One and Neil Gaiman's Marvel 1602 are an excellent set of trades and minis. Out of the ongoing stuff that the two big publishers (Marvel and DC) have going on, my own pick of the current lot would be Fables.

If you're into trying more than just superheroes, Sandman is essential. Preacher and Transmetropolitan are well worth your time. V for Vendetta and From Hell are pretty major single graphic novels, and The Invisibles is fairly interesting.

If you want to go even further out of the mainstream, start with Bone. I then recommend anything by Posy Simmonds, some of Rick Veitch's work, Gary Spencer Milledge's Strangehaven, Linda Medley's Castle Waiting, Tove Janson's Moomin strips, and anything at all by Bryan Talbot. Maus is a possible, too.

Generally, I'd add that most of the really good writing in comics is not found within the superhero genre. Whether you want to pursue that specturm of things depends more whether you're looking for entertainment or anything more.
1602 aside, you really can't go wrong with ANY of this. Nice recommendations (especially Strangehaven, which is still criminally underread).

I'd also suggest Grant Morrison's All-Star Superman, which is easily the best extended run on the character in over 30 years. Also any of Eddie Campbell's autobiographical Alec series, and the first 10-12 volumes of Dave Sim's Cerebus (as long as you don't mind being pissed off enough by the author's insane politics to never finish the series).

EDIT: Ooo, and Lone Wolf and Cub!
post #29 of 35
Akira.
Blade of the Immortal.
Stray Bullets (They stopped publishing TPB for this series ages ago which is a shame)
She-Hulk
post #30 of 35
Finding good writers is the key.

Brian K Vaughn (Y the Last Man, Ex Machina, Runaways, Pride of Baghdad)
Alan Moore (Watchmen, V for Vendetta, From Hell, Swamp Thing, Top Ten, Leauge of Extraordinary Gentlemen)
Frank Miller (Dark Knight Returns, Sin City, Daredevil)
Garth Ennis (Preacher, Constantine)
Mike Mignola (Hellboy, BPRD)
Kurt Busiek (Conan, Astro City, Marvels)
Doug TenNapel (Creature Tech, Iron West)

I can't promise you'll like all those writiers, but it's a good place to start.

Some other notable books:
- Maus
- Liberty Meadows
- Scott Pilgrim
- Black Hole
- Fables
- Bone
post #31 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by BobClark View Post
Y The Last Man is overrated schlock.
Last Man is not some brain blistering, redefinition of comics. It is however...
a) Not another superhero comic
b) An interesting premise
c) Mostly very well-written, fun series

Those elements make it an easy to recommend series.
post #32 of 35
But judging by Myers' list so far, it appears he wants superheroes.
And yes, it's an interesting premise. But the scope of execution feels cheap and shallow, like a made-for-TV movie. The dialogue is second rate Whedon material, the characters are unbelievable cyphers, and the art is too stilted for the material.
post #33 of 35
Most of my recomendations are my favorites though they aren't superheroes.

Ocean by Warren Ellis
Futuristic space thriller that just rocks, just one self contained story unlike most of my other recomendations.

Queen and Country by Greg Rucka
Spy story, might be my most re-read.

Whiteout by Greg Rucka
This was Rucka warming up to write Queen and Country, nice tight suspense story.

Invincible by Robert Kirkman
Currently my favorite superhero title, Kirkman is not afraid to send up the genre and show why he loves it at the same time.

Criminal, and Sleeper by Ed Brubaker
Both are great books by one of my favorite writers, guys in impossible situations.

Have to 4th the love for Y the Last Man and I just read Pride of Bagdad which I quite enjoyed.

Have to echo the endorsement of Fables, absolutely fantastic!
post #34 of 35
On the superhero track, if Myers is collecting back issues the late '70s run of Superboy and the Legion of Superheroes (Mike Grell redesign, Paul Levitz editorial) is great fun. No trade collection of these yet.
post #35 of 35
Not much left for me to suggest, as most of my faves have been mentioned. I might think of other stuff later, but with only a couple of minutes:

As far as superheroes go, I'd add Peter David's current run on X-Factor (and its predecessor, the Madrox miniseries). It's gotten a bit sidetracked by Civil War and such, but at its core it's a fun detective series that makes engaging use of mutant abilities.

I know no one likes Bendis anymore (well, apart from the people who buy his books), but I still get a kick out of Powers when it comes out. No question, though, its first couple of years were its strongest.

J. Michael Straczynski deservedly takes flack for his work on Spider-Man and the FF, but when he plays outside of that sandbox, he does some pretty gripping superhero stuff, though none of his series have really had satisfying conclusions. Rising Stars was drawn out by some legal battles, but even if the last few issues felt rushed, there is great reading in the first couple of trades. He then did a thoughtful, powerful reinvention of Marvel's Squadron Supreme called Supreme Power. Unfortunately, when Marvel moved it from their adults-only MAX line to the more PG-13 Marvel Knights imprint (renaming it Squadron Supreme), it lost a lot of its steam (and he seemed to lose interest), and kind of drifted away. Howard Chaykin's about to revive the title, so we'll see how that goes. JMS' latest project, The Twelve, is an outstanding Golden-Age-heroes-in-the-modern-world tale that's about halfway through at this point, so it's too early to say how it will turn out. Not only has it been very good so far, but the art by Chris Weston is absolutely off the charts. And JMS is also currently writing the best run that Thor has had since Walt Simonson.

Ed Brubaker's on a roll at Marvel right now, with Daredevil, Captain America (which hasn't featured Cap in the past year), and his revamp (with Jeff Parker) of Iron Fist, bringing a legacy of pulp adventure to the cheesy 70's hero.

For non-superhero reading, let me throw in Strangers in Paradise-- not only some of the best relationship writing that American comics has seen, but writer/artist Terry Moore's command of facial expression and body language is the equal of anyone working today.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Comics & Anime
CHUD.com Community › Forums › ARTS & LITERATURE › Comics & Anime › Must Reads?