Quote:
Originally Posted by DARKMITE8 
Howbout THE ZOMBIE DIARIES? How does it compare to DIARY OF THE DEAD (and is that one worth checking out?)?
|
It's not all that bad. There are some great moments of verisimilitude that hit the same dread-filled chords that the best of the BBC faux-docs like SMALLPOX and DIRTY WAR did.
They got the "shambles" down pretty well, opting for the traditional slow lurking dead thankfully. The fx work is pretty good and goes probably much farther for them thanks to the shaky, improperly aimed camera technique.
Maybe not surprisingly, it also suffers
and benefits from the same inherent issues as with any "Diary" film. The acting has moments of sheer amateurism, and while in the best of these types of narratives that can be offset by the idea that these are supposed to be your average garden-variety folks, in this film it breaks the quality chain.
My largest gripes with ZOMBIE DIARIES actually cover almost all the "diary" types. Distinct lack of older folks. Too often, these films are populated with almost exclusively under 30 types. I get that in a world collapsing under a zombie apocalypse, the older people might not stand that great a chance, but the insistance on having it peopled entirely by fresh out of collegers is pretty damn preposterous. Also, though Romero's DIARY doesn't suffer from this as much(and DIARIES only a small bit), I can't escape the impression that often these zombie flicks are designed to be little more than a gun nut wank fest. From the most amateur tripe on YouTube to the ones that actually get released, too many of these zombie films(and they are legion!) don't have much going on beyond some young twits running around in a SWAT fantasy masturbating high-powered weaponry. Sounds harsh, I know, but frankly that's what I'm getting from alot of these.
(I won't even get into the "Put the fuckin' camera down" disorder that almost all films of this type-DIARY, DIARIES, CLOVERFIELD-suffer from. It's an unfortunately required factor in these particular kinds of films...problem is, they still haven't found a a truly clever way to make it work logically. Romero came close in DIARY with the mansion security camera sequence, something that played perfectly to one of his strengths going all the way back to his commercial days...brilliant editing of static shots.)
Folks were rough on Romero for DIARY and in alot of areas they had valid issues. Despite doing a fine job for it's genre(low-budget undead flick)ZOMBIE DIARIES will help to show just how well Romero actually did with his film.
If you're a zombie film fan particularly, you should check it out. Every unseen dead film diminishes you.