Quote:
Originally Posted by felix natalya 
A pity if it was a flop though. I think Carpenter still has a good rep after all these years. Ghost of Mars notwithstanding, I actually liked Vampires. And I heard Cigarette Burns earned him rave reviews as well.
He's never endured a slump like Tobe Hooper (I still haven't forgiven him for directing that Crocodile movie).
|
I wouldn't consider
The Thing a true flop. It didn't do the numbers they wanted it to in the theaters but it's gone on to be one of the most popular films in Carpenter's filmography and continues to have a loyal fan base to this day, 25+ years after its release. It's generally always mentioned among the top horror films of all-time and the property is still valuable to Universal. It found its audience on video and cable. If they are talking about doing remakes and they've done a video game, chances are it's become profitable at this point.
I don't think it's fair to make the Carpenter-Hooper comparison as Carpenter has a far more established career. I'd say he has endured something of a slump. The last ten or so years have been him either overseeing remakes of his old stuff or working on projects that seem like retreads of it such as
Escape From L.A. and
Ghosts Of Mars. Sure, Hooper has been hit a lot harder but he also didn't have the kind of career as Carpenter. He did
Texas Chainsaw Massacre, which we could say was his Halloween but outside of the sequel which didn't go over as well as people had hoped and
Poltergeist which many view as a Steven Spielberg project, he really hasn't been staying as consistent.