Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveB 
I still think In Rainbows could have benefited from a slightly different track order and the integration of some of the bonus CD songs into the main album. But the whole thing seems to be improving with age. I like it more now than I did when I first heard it.
|
For me it was love at first listen, but I really do revisit it a lot and the track order has become instilled to the point that I usually expect to hear what's next when the songs come at me out of context. Plus I really do love some of those songs that appear on that bonus disc, Bangers + Mash in particular for the dueling drums.
Hail to the Thief doesn't do as much for me as it did when I first heard it, but I think 2 + 2 = 5 is one of their finer songs. I have a hard time placing that as anything
but an album opener though.
What's most interesting to me is what a different tone their songs, especially the Kid A/Amnesiac ditties, take when performed live. The I Might Be Wrong live EP is what I'm referring to specifically. Idioteque and I Might Be Wrong are just unabashed dance tunes, with the latter translating surprisingly well. It's really a great EP and the best official* live set you folks just getting into them would enjoy.
*Unofficially: their In Berlin bootleg.