I never quite got why people thought Playing The Angel was the best anything, either the best since this or that or the other thing. It's consistent, and immediate, but it doesn't quite cross the threshold into really good DM status. There's nothing on there I would put on a DM mix or rank among my favorites.
Exciter, now there is an underrated album. It's OK, I know, I'm the only one who thinks so. Bu noone can deny the power of Freelove. No hidden catch, no strings attached. Just Freelove.
Ultra, the first album of their post-death, "mature" period, annihilates Exciter and PTA, though. There are a few dull ones on the second half, but it has Barrel Of A Gun, Useless, Home (Gore giving himself one of the best ones for once), It's No Good, and Sister Of Night.
Songs of Faith and Devotion remains my #1, always. When a singer does exactly the right amount of drugs at exactly the right time, it's a beautiful thing. Dave even posed with a guitar in the booklet photos, when he's never played one as far as I know. You can't help but love that.It also helps that Martin Gore is one of the best pop songwriters in music history.
Violator is great too, maybe my #2 or #3. MftM has some classics, but I'd prefer just watching the 101 movie again to actually listening to the album. It's just slightly lacking. Black Celebration is their breakthrough as far as songwriting goes, I need to reevaluate that one. I also need to reevaluate the one before that, but I remember it having some slammin tunes. Construction, I wouldn't bother unless you are uber hardcore or interested in the history of early 80s sampling. Broken Frame, never heard it. The first one has like 2 good songs. They took a while to get going, didn't they?
This year will be my first time seeing them live, which is a big thing for me, since I have all 4 live DVDs. Boston, July 31st, be there!
I shall make my thoughts on the new songs known once I get home.