CHUD.com Community › Forums › MUSIC › Music › Favorite Concept Album?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Favorite Concept Album?

post #1 of 92
Thread Starter 
This phenomenon was a bigger deal in the late 60's - early 70's than at any other time, but specimens have cropped up at other times. There's plenty of them out there: "Tommy" and "Quadrophenia" by The Who, arguably every Pink Floyd album from Dark Side thru "The Final Cut", "Operation: Mindcrime" by Queensryche, "2112" by Rush, to name a few.

I'm speaking of course about concept albums. A collection of songs all relating to a central theme. usually, they're supposed to tell a story.

Personally, I like this idea a lot. There's a lot work involved in writing songs that work as individual pieces of music yet still relate to the central theme, and tell a coherent story. It takes balls to undertake such a project, and a massive amount of creative chops to pull it off. I admire that. And as a constant reader and frequent film watcher, I have an appreciation for the narrative, and love finding one threaded thru what you may often consider an unusual place for one: the entire contents of an album.

If you consider Pink Floyd's "Dark Side of the Moon" to be a concept album (and there's evidence on both sides to suggest it is and isn't), then that wins hands down, as Floyd is my favorite band & Dark Side my favorite album of all time. BUt if you remove Dark Side from the equation, I think I'd give the nod the the album I was listening to on the drive in this morning that got me thinking about this: "The Turn of a Friendly Card" by the Alan Parsons Project.

There's only two modest hits to come from this album, "Games People Play" and "Time", but I think every song on it is at least kind of cool, and the title track (Parts I & II) are very cool indeed. The story, as the title implies, is about a degenerate gambler who basically loses everything in Vegas. It's a bit looser and less obvious than some other concept albums, and if I hadn't known before I bought it (after hearing from a freind, who turned me on to it) what it was about, I may not have picked up on it until after I had listened to it multiple times. I gues that's a flaw in the execution, because you may not get the concept they were going for (which is the whole point) without outside confirmation. But there's other concept albums that suffer from this problem to a much, much greater degree. And I just dig the music so much, that this one still gets my vote, and I'll overlook it.

What about the rest of you? Do any of you like concept albums? And which one(s) is your favorite & why?
post #2 of 92
I have to think a little before offering up my all-time favorite, but "The Hazards of Love" by The Decemberists has been pretty much playing on constant rotation on my iPod lately. The story is great, and the music is even greater. I absolutely love this album.

I'll get back to you on all-time favorite (though I'm sort of leaning toward Pink Floyd's "The Wall" right now).
post #3 of 92
Do you count Sgt. Pepper?
post #4 of 92
"Scenes from a Memory" by Dream Theater. It was the album that got me into the band in the first place, and I've been a fan ever since.

The concept is kind of a murder mystery, the twist being that the murder is of the main character's previous life - a woman from the early 1900s. Each song of the album takes you through his journey (from his perspective) as he starts out undergoing hypnosis to release more hidden memories of his previous life, as well as his research into the murder through old newspapers and any remaining eyewitnesses who are still alive.

The final twist at the end is clever and brings the listener out of the album on an incredible note.
post #5 of 92
Dream Theater: 'Metropolis Part 2: Scenes From a Memory'.

DT had a song called 'Metropolis Part 1' on their second album, 'Images and Words'. At one point, they were just going to make the sequel to it into just a single song, but they ended up expanding it to encompass an entire album.

The story of the album is pretty much a direct lift from the movie 'Dead Again': the main character goes through a regression to discover that he had a past life as a female in 1928 named Victoria. Victoria was involved in a love triangle between 2 brothers, resulting in a violent murder.

Most of the tracks are fully realized songs that can stand on their own quite well, but some don't really make any sense outside of the concept album. There are also 2 outstanding instrumental-only tracks.

This was their first album with their new keyboard player, Jordan Rudess. He was encouraged by Mike Portnoy (the drummer and de facto band leader) to really stretch out and try to bring some Zappa influences to his playing; several songs benefit from this approach.

This is pretty much considered to be the best album from DT. The music is fantastic, and it all translates well into a very dynamic live show. I saw them live for this tour twice (and I even met the band once), and they played the album in its entirety both times.

Even though it's a concept album, it's very accessible. Indeed, this album is probably the ideal entry point for getting into the band's catalog.

eta: nice to see that DonS and I were thinking alike.
post #6 of 92
Hey! Other Dream Theater fans! Train of Thought is my favorite, but I was born after 1985, so grunge shaped my tastes...

The only thing I loathe about 'Scenes from a Memory' is... the keyboards!

Hurm...

The playing itself is awesome, but the carnival-esque moments (Zappa influence?) bug me. They fit the unified tone of the album, but it sounds a little too playful for my tastes.

As for concept albums: I used to listen to albums from start to finish, but the digital age makes mixtaping too easy. Downward Spiral has nice themes carried from beginning to end, but there's no real story. I'm also a Marilyn Manson fan, so of course love the Antichrist Superstar - Mechanical Animals - HolyWood triptych. I'm also the only person I've met who really really likes Machina: Machines of the Gods by Smashing Pumpkins.
post #7 of 92
SFaM would be a fantastic album on Rock Band.

Re: the keyboards - In general, I prefer it when the keyboards are more in the background, but I never really minded its presence in DT. All 3 of their keyboardists have been phenomenal musicians (although stylistically different), so I can appreciate the skill and musicianship that they can bring to a song. I'm also influenced by the fact that Jordan Rudess is probably the nicest guy that you could hope to meet, so I give his work a pass.
post #8 of 92
I'm a big fan of albums over singles generally, and that's probably why "concept albums" (in a broader sense) appeal to me.

My latest fave is probably The Hold Steady's "Separation Sunday." I love the individual songs to pieces, which helps, but I also like how the 'narrative' jumps around and almost ends at the beginning.

Nostalgia and all that, but you'll never convince me that "The Wall" isn't fantastic, too.
post #9 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by Judas Booth View Post
Dream Theater: 'Metropolis Part 2: Scenes From a Memory'.

DT had a song called 'Metropolis Part 1' on their second album, 'Images and Words'. At one point, they were just going to make the sequel to it into just a single song, but they ended up expanding it to encompass an entire album.

The story of the album is pretty much a direct lift from the movie 'Dead Again': the main character goes through a regression to discover that he had a past life as a female in 1928 named Victoria. Victoria was involved in a love triangle between 2 brothers, resulting in a violent murder.

Most of the tracks are fully realized songs that can stand on their own quite well, but some don't really make any sense outside of the concept album. There are also 2 outstanding instrumental-only tracks.

This was their first album with their new keyboard player, Jordan Rudess. He was encouraged by Mike Portnoy (the drummer and de facto band leader) to really stretch out and try to bring some Zappa influences to his playing; several songs benefit from this approach.

This is pretty much considered to be the best album from DT. The music is fantastic, and it all translates well into a very dynamic live show. I saw them live for this tour twice (and I even met the band once), and they played the album in its entirety both times.

Even though it's a concept album, it's very accessible. Indeed, this album is probably the ideal entry point for getting into the band's catalog.

eta: nice to see that DonS and I were thinking alike.
Indeed, it was nice to see both of us on the same page, though you explained it much better than I did.
post #10 of 92
Since everyone's going to rush to mention Who and Floyd (and rightly so), I'm gonna throw my two cents behind Green Day's American Idiot. The songwriting is infused with such passion and sense of purpose that it makes it easy to overlook some of the derivativeness present on the album. You can tell these three guys believe in every single thing they put down here, and that they put every bit of themselves into it. And I unapologetically love every glam-aping second of "Jesus of Suburbia".
post #11 of 92
In terms of matching music to narrative, I don't think anything trumps Quadrophenia, but the nerve that went into making Husker Du's Zen Arcade impresses me more and more as time goes on. A double-disc concept album with a narrative throughline that balances the amazing speed and ferocity of their early work with a newfound grasp of nuance and melody? And they made it in the space of a couple days? You can throw out the names of the belabored classic rock, prog, and metal studio creations all you want (and some of them are great - I'll say nothing against The Wall and even have to give some props to Operation: Mindcrime, even if it's not my cup of tea), but Zen Arcade was, bar-none, the ballsiest concept album ever made.

Drive-By Truckers' Southern Rock Opera is pretty terrific, too - possibly one of the most insightful, which you wouldn't necessarily expect, given the subject matter.

That's narratively speaking, of course. There are some pretty great concept albums totally lacking in overall story or obvious subject matter, like the aforementioned Sgt. Pepper, but also Elvis Costello's tragically overlooked Juliet Letters. Those are harder to pin down, though. Is Pet Sounds a concept album? Kid A? Hard to say.
post #12 of 92
Mr Lif - I Phantom (maybe not my favorite, but definitely one worth checking out)

I could desrcribe the story, but the liner notes actually break down the story, per song, for you.

It starts of micro and expands to macro

Basically, it's starts off as a dream, turns into reality and has a couple songs dealing with the "struggle", then morphs into a couple stories told from different perspectives of members of the same family(which I think is meant to show the de-evolution of the american family), then expands out to discuss global turmoil and our place in it. It ends with guest appearances by El-P, Jean Grey, and Akrobatic, who tell stories of what their "character" would be thinking about seconds before a nuclear strike over some Dawn of the Dead-esque synths, and the album ends with an explosion. Pretty cool shit, and he pulls it off.

Note this is some underground rap shit, but it is definitely accesible to those that aren't into gangsta rap. I would equate it to something along the lines of Common or Mos Def, but more intellectual and the beats are definitely something your not used to hearing.

Mr Lif also has a new concept album coming out in a week or so called I Heard it Today. Basically, he wrote a song every day of the election up until election day. Sounds pretty cool from what I have heard.

You can download a free "megamix" here(which includes some tracks from I Phantom):

http://2dopeboyz.okayplayer.com/2009...today-megamix/
post #13 of 92
I've come to really enjoy Devin Townsend's Ziltoid the Omniscient, the music is great (but it usually always is with Townsend) and the story is weird and pretty out there, but that's exactly why I like it.
post #14 of 92
Geez, everyone's listed my favorites already. So, being the Rush fan that I am, I gotta stand up for 2112, Hemispheres, and Cygnus X-1 from Farewell to Kings among my favorites. Plus all the parts of their Fear trilogy(?) from various albums played back-to-back.
post #15 of 92
I'm a huge RUSH fan, but you really can't count any of their albums as concept albums. All of those mentioned are epic length concept songs ('2112', 'Hemispheres', etc) on albums that feature stand-alone material. 'A Passage to Bangkok' deals with trying out various forms of weed, for instance...not a futuristic society.
post #16 of 92
Well, Floyd is obviously going to loom large over this.

-Dark Side of the Moon
-The Wall
-Animals

also

ISIS - Panopticon
Mastodon - Leviathan
The Mars Volta - Frances the Mute
NIN - Year Zero
post #17 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by joeypants View Post
Well, Floyd is obviously going to loom large over this.

-Dark Side of the Moon
-The Wall
-Animals

also

ISIS - Panopticon
Mastodon - Leviathan
The Mars Volta - Frances the Mute
NIN - Year Zero
I think you could throw NIN Downward Spiral and, to a lesser extent The Fragile(mainly cause it's probably my least favorite NIN album, although it does have some great moments)
post #18 of 92
Since people have already vaunted the Floyd efforts, I'll throw in my (probably soon to be bashed) contribution of all of Coheed and Cambria's output. Every album is based on and around Claudio Sanchez's (the lead singer/rythm guitarist) comic book. The music is a great mix of hard rock, thrash, metal, and blues, and Claudio's voice, while some may find irritating, I find great. The sci-fi lyrics fit well with the music, and can range from hokey to compelling, but move things along none the less. The instrumental nods to Floyd, Zeppelin, and Rush are always appreciated, while still showing modern day technical chops and insane guitar runs.
post #19 of 92
Ill second RCA with Mr. Lif's I Phantom. If Im cleaning the house sometimes that CD will find its way on. About halfway through i usually just kinda chill out and listen to it and pick up on a couple new things.

Ill add Murder By Death - Who Will Survive, And What Will Be Left Of Them?
post #20 of 92
Uh...Bowie. Yeah, I'll go with Ziggy. Though the story isn't told especially well, great as the songs are.
post #21 of 92
Regarding Queensryche: 'Operation: Mindcrime' is a landmark conceptual album, but the sequel 'Operation: Mindcrime 2' sucks (for the most part).

Has anyone heard their new concept album, 'American Soldier'? The sound clip that I heard for one of the songs sounded terrible.
post #22 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by Judas Booth View Post
I'm a huge RUSH fan, but you really can't count any of their albums as concept albums. All of those mentioned are epic length concept songs ('2112', 'Hemispheres', etc) on albums that feature stand-alone material. 'A Passage to Bangkok' deals with trying out various forms of weed, for instance...not a futuristic society.
True, true. 2112 and Cygnus X1 each take up a side of their respective albums, but it was closest to a concept album from Rush as I could get at the moment ('sides Iggy started it ;D).

Reading this thread's also reminded me of how long it's been since I really listened to any music apart from the stuff I get on my radio at work. Time to get me some tunes!
post #23 of 92
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Timothy225 View Post
True, true. 2112 and Cygnus X1 each take up a side of their respective albums, but it was closest to a concept album from Rush as I could get at the moment ('sides Iggy started it ;D).
I don't actually own 2112. I love some of Rush's work, but what I heard of 2112 I didn't care for. A guy I went to college with was HUGE into them, and read me some of the liner notes, which led me to believe it was a concept album. Until this moment, I had no idea the whole thing wasn't related to the concept's narrative.
post #24 of 92
In terms of Hip Hop, Deltron 3030 (by Del Tha Funkee Homo Sapien) wins. A fantastic rapper, working with a fantastic composer to create a really dense and rich dystopian atmosphere. The opening track sets up the album perfectly.

While I'm not at all a fan of Adult Swim (save for a few select shows), Danger Doom is a great album for MF Doom and Danger Mouse. Even without an appreciation for the references and soundbites, it's one of MF's most interesting albums.
post #25 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by IggytheBorg View Post
I don't actually own 2112. I love some of Rush's work, but what I heard of 2112 I didn't care for. A guy I went to college with was HUGE into them, and read me some of the liner notes, which led me to believe it was a concept album. Until this moment, I had no idea the whole thing wasn't related to the concept's narrative.
It was one of the first albums I picked up when I started getting into them (around the time of Signals and Grace Under Pressure, two of my all time favorites - once I heard those, I was hooked and started buying any album of theirs I could get).

Here's one for ya, Ig - did Motorhead ever do a concept album or anything close to it (does their work with Girlschool count?)
post #26 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveB View Post
...the nerve that went into making Husker Du's Zen Arcade impresses me more and more as time goes on. A double-disc concept album with a narrative throughline that balances the amazing speed and ferocity of their early work with a newfound grasp of nuance and melody? And they made it in the space of a couple days?... Zen Arcade was, bar-none, the ballsiest concept album ever made.
What about the Minutemen's answer, Double Nickels on the Dime?
post #27 of 92
My personal favorite is Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness by the Smashing Pumpkins. I was so young when this came out and it blew my mind. The individual discs of day and night or happy and sadness was enough for me to follow the entire album from beginning to end. Also love the continuity of the instrumental title track with various other songs.
post #28 of 92
I'm going to second the mentions of The Decemberists HAZARDS OF LOVE and Deltron 3030, because both are great and amongst my favorite albums.

I'd definitely throw in the two Kinks albums The Kinks Are the Village Green Preservation Society and Arthur (Or the Decline and Fall of the British Empire). Both have been on heavy rotation in my iPod lately.
post #29 of 92
Of what's been mentioned I love Scenes from a Memory, that album was a revelation to me the first time I heard it.

Besides that I think my favorite is "De-Loused in the Comatorium" by The Mars Volta. It actually inspired me to write a paper about it in college.
post #30 of 92
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Timothy225 View Post
Here's one for ya, Ig - did Motorhead ever do a concept album or anything close to it (does their work with Girlschool count?)
I doubt it. Lemmy never struck me as having such grandiose artistic vision. Motorhead was article of the day on Wikipedia yesterday. A friend sent me the link. I read part of the top page, and while Motorhead is considered by many to be a pioneering band in the subgenres of Thrash Metal & Speed Metal, Lemmy himself apparently doesn't like such labels, preferring to call what they play just "rock and roll." That doesn't sound like the comment of aman who has a concept album in him. The article went on to say, in the discography section, that neirther Motorhead or their fans mind that they seem to put out more of the same (in the good way) with every album. I own mainly a couple of the greatest hits collections, though (I have the full albums of "Orgasmatron", "Rock and Roll" and "Inferno" - the former two on vinyl, no less), so I can't say w/ absolute certainlty. But again, I doubt it.
post #31 of 92
I like several of the bands mentioned. NIN, Mastodon the Mars Volta. I'd also like to get into Dream Theater one day. If I had to pick a single album it would be The Downward Spiral.
post #32 of 92
Kriegaffe: If you're serious about trying to get into Dream Theater, SFaM is your perfect entry point. Don't be turned off just because it's a concept album; it truly is a very accessible album to get into.
post #33 of 92
It gets tricky ascribing the phrase 'concept album' to certain records...there's a difference between a thematic album and a narrative one, and that can muddy the waters a bit...but a few great narrative-minded ones not mentioned above:

Genesis--The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Jethro Tull--Thick as a Brick
Opeth--Still Life
post #34 of 92
One of my favorites is Extreme's III Sides To Every Story. The time-signatures are gloriously flowing with synergy, the melodies rich and dexterous...a craftsmanship displayed in a studio setting that very few bands have duplicated, let alone on an ambitious "three-pieced" concept album.

If you consider Liz Phair's Exile in Guyville to be a concept album that challenges The Stones' Exile on Main Street song-for-song, and Phair still claims this to be the case today, then that would likely be at the top of my list. It's a raw, powerful, swaggering statement.
post #35 of 92
Wow Iggy, I can't believe that someone around here is familiar enough with The Alan Parsons Project to include Turn of a Friendly Card. Makes me feel marginally less a freak for owning all of their albums.

The Project is actually, in a way, kind of the ultimate concept album band, since they weren't supposed to be a band in the first place. Parsons was putting together his Edgar Allen Poe album under that heading, and he and his collaborators just kept making more albums. The Poe album actually remains one of my favorites. Parsons worked on Dark Side of the Moon, by the way.

And while I like Quadrophenia quite a lot, I still, for whatever reason, still prefer to listen to Tommy. Maybe it's just that there's more of a narrative to it.
post #36 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by Greg David View Post
Wow Iggy, I can't believe that someone around here is familiar enough with The Alan Parsons Project to include Turn of a Friendly Card. Makes me feel marginally less a freak for owning all of their albums.

The Project is actually, in a way, kind of the ultimate concept album band, since they weren't supposed to be a band in the first place. Parsons was putting together his Edgar Allen Poe album under that heading, and he and his collaborators just kept making more albums. The Poe album actually remains one of my favorites. Parsons worked on Dark Side of the Moon, by the way.

And while I like Quadrophenia quite a lot, I still, for whatever reason, still prefer to listen to Tommy. Maybe it's just that there's more of a narrative to it.
I'd like to add King Diamond's Abigail, Them, and Conspiracy.

Them and Conspiracy tell one story over the course of two albums, as a teenager I tried to write a screenplay based on those albums.

Also, Cradle of Filth - Cruelty and the Beast is a really good concept album about the life of Elizabeth Bathory.

I have been digging the Decemberist Hazards of Love, but seeing as I haven't been able to buy a copy, I've been listening to the NPR live recording to get my fix.

I will definitely second the love for Zen Arcade by Husker Du
post #37 of 92
Favorite? Roger Waters' The Pros and Cons of Hitchiking, easy.
post #38 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by Judas Booth View Post
Kriegaffe: If you're serious about trying to get into Dream Theater, SFaM is your perfect entry point. Don't be turned off just because it's a concept album; it truly is a very accessible album to get into.
Thanks for the suggestion. I'd heard of the band before, but with such a long career I was unsure where to begin.
post #39 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by Renn Brown View Post
In terms of Hip Hop, Deltron 3030 (by Del Tha Funkee Homo Sapien) wins. A fantastic rapper, working with a fantastic composer to create a really dense and rich dystopian atmosphere. The opening track sets up the album perfectly.

While I'm not at all a fan of Adult Swim (save for a few select shows), Danger Doom is a great album for MF Doom and Danger Mouse. Even without an appreciation for the references and soundbites, it's one of MF's most interesting albums.
One could argue N.W.A.'s Straight Outta Compton is in the same vein as "Sgt. Peppers". A loosely connected group of songs by a band adapting assumed persona for effect. (Easy-E =Billy Shears)
post #40 of 92
I'll go with The Cure's Disintegration. A haunting and beautiful album about the disintegration of a love affair.
post #41 of 92
More essentials:

The Who Sell Out
The Kinks Are The Village Green Preservation Society
Tommy
Arthur(Or The Decline And Fall Of The British Empire
Yesterday's Wine
Phases and Stages
The Red-Headed Stranger
post #42 of 92
I love that Mr Lif and Deltron 3030 were mentioned on this thread. Those are great, great albums.

My favorite concept album has to be Neutral Milk Hotel's In The Aeroplane Over The Sea. The through line is pretty loose, and the lyrics are often surreal and nonsensical, but many of the songs are about Anne Frank. Or about Jeff Mangum falling in love with her ghost. Or something. Whatever it is, the raw emotion in the raw voice combined with the almost baroque wall of sound instrumentation and arrangements never fails to move me. I thnk it's simply one of the greatest, most inscrutably personal albums ever made.
post #43 of 92
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Greg David View Post
Wow Iggy, I can't believe that someone around here is familiar enough with The Alan Parsons Project to include Turn of a Friendly Card. Makes me feel marginally less a freak for owning all of their albums.

The Project is actually, in a way, kind of the ultimate concept album band, since they weren't supposed to be a band in the first place. Parsons was putting together his Edgar Allen Poe album under that heading, and he and his collaborators just kept making more albums. The Poe album actually remains one of my favorites. Parsons worked on Dark Side of the Moon, by the way.

And while I like Quadrophenia quite a lot, I still, for whatever reason, still prefer to listen to Tommy. Maybe it's just that there's more of a narrative to it.
TOaFC is actually the only album I own by them but. . . a Poe concept album? Color me intrigued. What's it called?
post #44 of 92
Anyone else here ever heard of Lift to Experience? (I'm looking in DaveB's general direction) Their debut (and only album) is a double-disc effort called The Texas-Jerusalem Crossroads, about the end of the world and Texas as the promised land.

The group is a trio but deliver a dense wall-of-sound rock atmosphere. Very shoegazey. And the lead singer can be described as Jeff Buckley-lite. Definitely not the same range, but a great voice for the music.

It's among my favorite albums and though the material sounds kitschy, it's delivered with sincerity.
post #45 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chavez View Post
What about the Minutemen's answer, Double Nickels on the Dime?
A great album, no doubt, but the concept is really, really loose, and it's basically the Minutemen just doing what the Minutemen did (which, granted, was pretty groundbreaking in its own right). Zen Arcade isn't just a collection of great tracks, but an actual sustained and even sonically varied narrative for a genre that specialized in short bursts.

Quote:
Originally Posted by I poke badgers with spoons View Post
Anyone else here ever heard of Lift to Experience? (I'm looking in DaveB's general direction) Their debut (and only album) is a double-disc effort called The Texas-Jerusalem Crossroads, about the end of the world and Texas as the promised land.

The group is a trio but deliver a dense wall-of-sound rock atmosphere. Very shoegazey. And the lead singer can be described as Jeff Buckley-lite. Definitely not the same range, but a great voice for the music.

It's among my favorite albums and though the material sounds kitschy, it's delivered with sincerity.
A few of my friends (ex-bandmates, mostly) were so absolutely obsessed with this album to the point that I couldn't even give it a shot on its own terms. I have it, but haven't listened to it in years, since the accolades kind of ruined it for me. I remember it being okay, but the hokey lyrics and the sing-speak vocal delivery getting on my nerves. Maybe I'll try it again one of these days.
post #46 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by IggytheBorg View Post
TOaFC is actually the only album I own by them but. . . a Poe concept album? Color me intrigued. What's it called?
Tales of Mystery & Imagination
post #47 of 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by Richard Dickson View Post
Since everyone's going to rush to mention Who and Floyd (and rightly so), I'm gonna throw my two cents behind Green Day's American Idiot. The songwriting is infused with such passion and sense of purpose that it makes it easy to overlook some of the derivativeness present on the album. You can tell these three guys believe in every single thing they put down here, and that they put every bit of themselves into it. And I unapologetically love every glam-aping second of "Jesus of Suburbia".
Yeah, no.

That's nice that they believed what they were saying, but it's still not a very good album. And I say that as a guy who defended the shit out of it at the time. It's very surface in its story and "message," but I guess that makes it a perfect concept album for the generation it's targeted to. Maybe that was the point.
post #48 of 92
Lou Reed-Berlin and New York
Dylan-Blood On The Tracks
Public Enemy-It Takes A Nation Of Millions To Hold Us Back (If Pet Sounds is, so is this)
post #49 of 92
Blood on the Tracks is about a divorce/specific event in Dylan's voice. That doesn't really make it a concept album.

Both the Reed albums you mentioned are fucking amazing, though. I'd throw Street Hassle on that list, too.
post #50 of 92
Does having a unified theme equal concept album?

I say, yes!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Music
CHUD.com Community › Forums › MUSIC › Music › Favorite Concept Album?