CHUD.com Community › Forums › SPORTS, GAMES & LEISURE › Television › National Parks: America's Best Idea -- The new Ken Burns miniseries
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

National Parks: America's Best Idea -- The new Ken Burns miniseries

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
Is anyone else looking forward to this one? I kind of tired of Burns and his style a while ago, but PBS is one of the few stations I get in HD and I think it's going to be cool to see all the High Def nature footage.

At my job, we've been handing out promotional little pieces of paper for this film. The paper? IMPRINTED WITH SEEDS! Have you ever heard of anything so crazy? Soak it in water and grow wild flowers. That really caught my attention


Starts Sunday at 7 or 8 PM or so.
post #2 of 8
Thread Starter 
, unfortunately this is not turning out to be the program I'd hoped it would be. I think I'm going to change the channel in a few minutes. Started out strong but is really going down hill fast. I wanted to see HD nature footage of our National Parks. But now it seems to be entirely HD footage of.... blurry old 19th century photographs. Why show those when the whole point is that the land has been preserved so that it should look just the same today as it did back then? Watching a waterfall in HD is alot more fun that staring at a blurry black and white photo of one.


Oh well,this one had potential.

EDIT: Well I ended up watching all the way through. It was so pretentious though. the narrator says something like "The park included a valley John Muir described as the most beautiful he'd ever seen", and then instead of showing us a HD shot of the park, so, you know, we could see what John was talking about, he shows us a blurry black and white post card taken at the time. Why do that? When Muir was talking about it being so beautiful, that wasn't based on his reaction to looking at a post card.

Just a pointless "Look at how historical this all is!" style rather than trying to connect with the audience in a meaningful emotional way.
post #3 of 8
I'm enjoying it thus far, but I think I'll refrain from saying much else until I've seen each episode.

I'll just say that I love the National Parks (despite only being to a few) and wish to visit many more in the future.
post #4 of 8
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Iron Maiden View Post
I'm enjoying it thus far, but I think I'll refrain from saying much else until I've seen each episode.

I'll just say that I love the National Parks (despite only being to a few) and wish to visit many more in the future.
I love the parks too. I just wish the show was less black and white photo heavy. Night 2 was better, but only barely.

I mean, do not get me wrong, I find the info fascinating. Unfortunately as film I'd have to say it is utterly dull. The effect of watching it is like listening to a book on tape about the Parks, while a slide show plays on your TV.

I was hoping this would be a bit more "Planet Earth: National Parks Edition"
post #5 of 8
Hey, whenever they get to Ft. Pickens/Naval Live Oaks/Gulf Islands National Seashore... yeah, that's where I live (the area, not the Fort itself).

It's boring most of the time here, but oh so beautiful.
post #6 of 8
Fucking insanity. This is a wonderful documentary brimming with the breath-taking images of the natural wonders that exist in our nation and loaded with the incredible history that led to the creation of our parks. Honestly, it's a reminder of how great this country really is, and it makes me proud to be from the US without waving a flag or spouting some jingoistic political bullshit.

At the same time it's a pretty damning indictment of the people who went out of their way to halt progress to preserve our lands, and sort of a subtle call to arms to viewers to do what they can to fight the destruction of our environment. Great stuff so far, but that's what I expect from Burns.
post #7 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post
and then instead of showing us a HD shot of the park, so, you know, we could see what John was talking about, he shows us a blurry black and white post card taken at the time. Why do that?
The point, I will say, you missed (or don't appreciate). Lawmakers creating the legislation didn't sit around a widescreen for proof of the beauty, the beauty was enough to overcome the technology of the time. So spending time with John Muir, Burns chooses to stick with mostly with the forms of art and media of the times. And seeing it through what Muir was able to use (poetry, articles, etchings, paintings, grainy photographs) to promote the vistas he loved, I think is integral. That's how the parks got started.

You forget, it's also a history lesson steeped in the artifacts of the time.

Loving this so far.
post #8 of 8
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by agracru View Post
Fucking insanity. This is a wonderful documentary brimming with the breath-taking images of the natural wonders that exist in our nation and loaded with the incredible history that led to the creation of our parks. Honestly, it's a reminder of how great this country really is, and it makes me proud to be from the US without waving a flag or spouting some jingoistic political bullshit.
Ok, just to quickly update my thoughts:

At the same time it's a pretty damning indictment of the people who went out of their way to halt progress to preserve our lands, and sort of a subtle call to arms to viewers to do what they can to fight the destruction of our environment. Great stuff so far, but that's what I expect from Burns.

Ok, just to quickly update my thoughts:

I ended up liking it alot more than I did at first. Watched the first four episodes, and I feel they really picked up in quality.

With that said, I felt that some of what they chose to focus on was a little dull, and some of the history was rushed or unexplained.

Over all though, I do agree with the films premise: The National Parks are an amazing idea, and it's even more amazing they exist at all. Looking at our current health care "debate", it's astounding that we ever set aside millions of square miles for non commercial purposes. As a big fan of nature and endangered animals (my avatar is an extinct animal), I'm glad the parks exist.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Television
CHUD.com Community › Forums › SPORTS, GAMES & LEISURE › Television › National Parks: America's Best Idea -- The new Ken Burns miniseries