CHUD.com Community › Forums › CULTURE, HUMOR, & FREE FORM › Gossip › Nikki Finke refused to blame Fox for making critically-lambasted films
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Nikki Finke refused to blame Fox for making critically-lambasted films

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
A lot of people trashed Tom Rothman. But Nikki Finke respects and Steven Spielberg decides to direct a film for him.... Do it mean something?

http://www.deadline.com/hollywood/wh...-marc-shmuger/

Quote:
In 2008, the usually successful studio Twentieth Century Fox had one of its worst summers in recent memory. Almost immediately, certain journalists predicted heads would roll among the long stable management because of what was suddenly seen as deep systemic problems at the studio. Prior to the summer, Tom Rothman and Jim Gianopulos had been lauded for doing more with less: spending little money and smartly laying off risk on highly commercial movies that outperformed with moviegoers if not the critics. Rothman especially was rumored ready to be axed that summer, and the relentless media rushed to print the minuscule Rotten Tomatoes scores for his slate of swill. (Ring a bell, LA Times columnist/blogger Patrick Goldstein?)

But what the film community didn't know (and it even took Fox a long time to find out) is that those stories were no coincidence. They were planted by Shmuger who pushed and prodded and pressured entertainment and business journalists to badmouth the rival studio. He gave reporters all the ammunition they needed, from pithy off-the-record quotes about how Rothman had "ruined" the movie biz, to emailed handouts with facts and figures. He even put together the list of Rotten Tomatoes scores for all of Fox movies in recent years. His motivation for going to the media was that Fox made junk while he was making edgy and important movies at Universal. He depicted himself as the one truly creative mogul. And when some journalists wouldn't play his nasty parlor game [Full Disclosure: I refused, arguing that successful slates were cyclical and the place for this criticism was in my weekly box office reports and not my banner headlines], he froze them out.

Flash forward to 2009 when suddenly it's Universal's turn to fall apart at the box office. To their credit, the Fox moguls didn't return the favor when now it was Shmuger's time for public humiliation. And that's why no one is crying a river for Shmuger now. If anything, the feeling is he's getting what he deserved. Certainly, Uni's movie slate isn't getting any better since the summer. Love Happens didn't with audiences, and that upcoming Vince Vaughn starrer Couples Retreat has little box office heat. True, Nancy Meyer's It's Complicated does have considerable buzz, but it's a comedy aimed at adults. As a result, Universal won’t make its numbers this year, which would mean that for the first time in a long while the studio won't be quietly contributing is annual $1 billion profit into GE coffers.
post #2 of 5
Quote:
Originally Posted by chans View Post
A lot of people trashed Tom Rothman. But Nikki Finke respects and Steven Spielberg decides to direct a film for him.... Do it mean something?

http://www.deadline.com/hollywood/wh...-marc-shmuger/
Shame. She is defending the indefensible when she defends Mr Rothman and his War on Intelligence. She has always struck me as a pretty shallow person and lousy journalist though, so this comes as no surprise. Her constant slander of the movie film blogs is totally lacking in intellectual honesty.
post #3 of 5
Damn it, I've never met the guy but I like Shmuger a lot for weird reasons. I honestly believe he cares about making good movies, too, and that he understands what makes movies good. Universal would not make Wolverine. I also doubt Eastwood hates Shmuger; Shmuger's mentor is a friend of Eastwood's.

I have met Alan Horn, whom I like because he's a cool guy and smart. WB cares about its movies, but I think theirs is a different type of interest and definition of what's "good" than Univeral's. Universal's into a more Classical approach, WB into maybe an artsier style, with longer, stranger, and seemingly riskier films. A friend tells me Rothman is cool in person, but I really don't like most of Fox's pictures. But I still want Avatar to be so good.
post #4 of 5
Quote:
He even put together the list of Rotten Tomatoes scores for all of Fox movies in recent years.
Was that data otherwise TOP SECRET???
post #5 of 5
Quote:
Originally Posted by DARKMITE8 View Post
Was that data otherwise TOP SECRET???
Only he was spiteful enough to cut and paste statistics from a public film review aggregator website! Can't you see how he must have been seething with hate? Good for Nikki to point this out, as it clearly discredits his reasons for disliking Rothman. (sarcasm)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gossip
CHUD.com Community › Forums › CULTURE, HUMOR, & FREE FORM › Gossip › Nikki Finke refused to blame Fox for making critically-lambasted films