CHUD.com Community › Forums › POLITICS & RELIGION › Political Discourse › Obesity in America: A Political Issue?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Obesity in America: A Political Issue? - Page 2

post #51 of 199
On the freezing of plastics.

http://urbanlegends.about.com/librar...tic_dioxin.htm
Quote:
Comments: This widely circulated email (actually a revised version of an earlier message dating from 2002) not only conveys inaccurate information, it is falsely attributed to a Johns Hopkins University newsletter as well. No such information was ever issued by any department of the university.

To combat the inaccuracies, Professor Rolf Halden of Johns Hopkins' Bloomberg School of Public Health addressed the email's opening allegation in a news release:

OC&PA: What do you make of this recent email warning that claims dioxins can be released by freezing water in plastic bottles?

RH: No. This is an urban legend. Freezing actually works against the release of chemicals. Chemicals do not diffuse as readily in cold temperatures, which would limit chemical release if there were dioxins in plastic, and we don't think there are.
post #52 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by billylove View Post
It might be cheaper looking, but factor in the nutritional cost vs the nutritional cost of cooking fresh food, and it might be cheaper going for fresh foods.
That's where I'm coming from. Okay, so maybe making those same entrees from scratch, one-to-one, could be more expensive. But a bowl of beans and rice is still cheaper and way healthier than some surplus MRE disguised as a tv dinner.
post #53 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Egg View Post
That's where I'm coming from. Okay, so maybe making those same entrees from scratch, one-to-one, could be more expensive. But a bowl of beans and rice is still cheaper and way healthier than some surplus MRE disguised as a tv dinner.
The other issue with frozen, prepackaged meals, as well as most restaurant meals, is that the sodium is usually through the roof. You will probably use much less salt preparing something fresh yourself.
post #54 of 199
I think Obesity does play into how politicians are perceived. I saw Colbert interview some lady with a book about weight and she said that Obama is considered "more moral" because he is so slim. We have a bias for preceiving fat people as less moral. (Full Disclosure: BMI or not, I'm fat as shit)

I think that the republican challenger to NJ Governor John Corzine, might lose simply cause he is a fat guy.
post #55 of 199
Yes, this kind of debunkery of the dangers of smoking worked for about 20 years, and I see now that after a decade or more of awareness throughout Europe and the rest of the world, reality about SAR and cell phone use is starting to seep into the US.

Obviously, everyone can choose what path to take. My choice is to err on the side of skepticism of corporate honesty and overdo it when it comes to food safety for myself and my kids.

ps. I can't find it now but the post about buying locally grown food and going to farmers markets is a do-er.
post #56 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rourkefan View Post
I think Obesity does play into how politicians are perceived. I saw Colbert interview some lady with a book about weight and she said that Obama is considered "more moral" because he is so slim. We have a bias for preceiving fat people as less moral. (Full Disclosure: BMI or not, I'm fat as shit)

I think that the republican challenger to NJ Governor John Corzine, might lose simply cause he is a fat guy.
There's a reason they call them fat cats!
post #57 of 199
You can also get frozen vegetables that are cheaper than, and about as nutritious as, most fresh vegetables you'd get in a supermarket. Of course, these are grown and frozen by EVIL CORPORATIONS, so maybe it's not such a good idea.
post #58 of 199
It is all of these things and more. Everybody needs to take some blame for the lack of nutrition in our diets and the general unhealthiness of the country. Food corporations, government, doctors and individuals/families all need to get on the bus or get the fuck off. Shit, you'd think that health insurance companies would sponsor nutrition and wellness events or marketing in order to drive down their own expenses. Of course the effect is too diffuse to see tangible benefits, but there's an opportunity being missed for sure.
post #59 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pop Zeus View Post
It is all of these things and more. Everybody needs to take some blame for the lack of nutrition in our diets and the general unhealthiness of the country. Food corporations, government, doctors and individuals/families all need to get on the bus or get the fuck off. Shit, you'd think that health insurance companies would sponsor nutrition and wellness events or marketing in order to drive down their own expenses. Of course the effect is too diffuse to see tangible benefits, but there's an opportunity being missed for sure.
I hear you there. The obesity epidemic is a cultural one. It's a whole host of things that need to be done to get this problem under control. An easy place to start would be restaurants offering half servings of their meals. When me and the wife eat out, we split an entree and it's enough to fill us both up (and I'm a big guy). I think if restaurants and fast food places would just offer smaller portion options, this would be a good first step.

Another thing would be schools being required to reach certain nutrition goals when they serve lunch to their students. Also, increased funding for PE programs. And yes, tax the shit out of sodas, candy, and juice boxes. None of those things add one bit to a healthy lifestyle.

In my 36 years, I've seen society change from when it was rare to see a morbidly obese person on the street to where it's even stranger when I don't see a morbidly obese person a day (or several). We need to treat this as a real problem.
post #60 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by dynamotv View Post
An easy place to start would be restaurants offering half servings of their meals. When me and the wife eat out, we split an entree and it's enough to fill us both up (and I'm a big guy). I think if restaurants and fast food places would just offer smaller portion options, this would be a good first step.
Many restaurants (particularly upscale ones) do serve smaller portions, but they do so to help maximize profit.
post #61 of 199
Problem with taxing fast food is, it will hurt the poor. Who do you think goes to the Taco Bell/Micky D's/ KFC dollar menu?

Plus, as pointed out above, it's the "Family Style" places that are actually less healthy, combined with the shit that goes into our processed foods in grocery stores.

I agree with YT about Corn Syrup etc. Also, one of the (very few) things SF's mayor Gavin Newson has got right was the proposal to mandate healthy foods in the city.
post #62 of 199
Thread Starter 
I'm with yt on killing the corn subsidy. Why am I, through my government, paying money I don't have to companies nowhere near me so they can grow stuff I don't need?

I'm with Snaike on personal responsibility. It's not Society's fault if I put extra inches on my waist because I consume more calories than I burn.

It's interesting to me that no one has questioned the assumption that obesity is bad. According to this article on obesity and mortality in the New England Journal of Medicine, "In analyses of BMI during midlife (age of 50 years) among those who had never smoked, the associations became stronger, with the risk of death increasing by 20 to 40 percent among overweight persons and by two to at least three times among obese persons; the risk of death among underweight persons was attenuated."

If, as The Closer suggests, America spends $150b/yr on obesity related health issues, I wonder whether that figure is balanced by the savings that accrue through increased obesity - related mortality. In other words, people who die early spend less time drawing social security and medicare. How do those numbers work out?
post #63 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cylon Baby View Post
Problem with taxing fast food is, it will hurt the poor. Who do you think goes to the Taco Bell/Micky D's/ KFC dollar menu?
And that’s the conundrum, we could end corn subsidies, tax soda, and otherwise punish people who purchase fast food, but if you don’t also subsidize healthy alternatives all you’re doing is hurting the poor.
post #64 of 199
Remember, fatties are voters too!
post #65 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Martianman View Post
BMI is somewhat bullshit to me. I'm 5'10", and weigh 192, and my body fat percentage is less than 18%. I'm not obese, but my BMI is 28 which is borderline obese. I saw an article talking about BMI a few years ago, and one of the people that were considered obese was Tom Cruise. You can't just take two measurements and decide if that person is obese or not. People aren't just geometric shapes that you can apply the Pythagorean theorem to.
BMI is considered a good proxy for obesity at a population level, if not necessarily for individuals. Most people with high BMIs have them because of body fat, not because they're athletes.
post #66 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by FrankCobretti View Post
I'm with yt on killing the corn subsidy. Why am I, through my government, paying money I don't have to companies nowhere near me so they can grow stuff I don't need?
To stop food from getting too expensive, I mean, that was the argument 40 years ago when the Nixon administration was looking for a way to boost food production, and it’s hard to argue with the results—at least in that regard.

The $64,000 question is how can we produce food at a similar cost—nationwide—without resorting to the monocultures many believe to be at the of the core issue.
post #67 of 199
Thread Starter 
Thing is, our food is ridiculously expensive. It's just that those expenses are hidden in health costs, environmental degradation, and collapsing towns in the Midwest.
post #68 of 199
You know when I don't eat healthy? When I'm drinking. Know when I'm drinking? Often.

In conclusion: Drinking = obesity
post #69 of 199
Is obesity a political issue?
Absolutely. And it's a national security issue, an economic security issue, and a moral issue.

Every time I hear about people talking about "Fat-ism" (because of all those fat people who got lynched in the south, I guess?) , I want to go on a hunger strike and die.


Yes, unfortunately the worst foods are often the cheapest and that makes diet a harder issue to get under control for those who are poor. For instance, I love tacos. However, the start up costs for me to make tacos are over 20$. If I had a different metabolism, I'd have to struggle to stay slim because alot of the food I eat is pretty terrible for me. With that said though, I feel it's unpatriotic to be a giant blob. You owe it to your country to get in shape. I am making an effort to do strength training so I can start Skiing again, and if I don't follow through and get some muscles, I'll be just as critical of myself as I currently am of the KFC-Blobs out there*


PS for the record I love fried chicken, but if I got fat from eating it I'd cease to eat it.
post #70 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by FrankCobretti View Post
Thing is, our food is ridiculously expensive. It's just that those expenses are hidden in health costs, environmental degradation, and collapsing towns in the Midwest.
Bingo. In his acuity, FC illustrates why big corporations prefer 'em uneducated, uninformed and desperate. Lucky for them, our schools are in shambles, our media belongs to them and wages & employment are in the toilet.
post #71 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by FrankCobretti View Post
Thing is, our food is ridiculously expensive. It's just that those expenses are hidden in health costs, environmental degradation, and collapsing towns in the Midwest.
Sure, but our government has always been willing to accept those consequences in order to prevent families from being unable to afford milk. I’m not saying the current situation is good, just that there are reasons for why it exists, and fixing one problem only to create another is, well... problematic.
post #72 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post
However, the start up costs for me to make tacos are over 20$.
How big are these fucking tacos?
post #73 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by FrankCobretti View Post
Thing is, our food is ridiculously expensive. It's just that those expenses are hidden in health costs, environmental degradation, and collapsing towns in the Midwest.
Right. The companies who produce those foods have offloaded those costs off of their spreadsheets but as consumers of food, we're the ones who have to foot the bill one way or another.
post #74 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
How big are these fucking tacos?
Yeah. What's the price of a taco at Taco Bell? 99 cents? I don't know I haven't been there in a long time. PK is still saving money.
post #75 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
How big are these fucking tacos?
Taco Powder: 1.50$
Taco Shells $3
Lettuce 2$
1lb Hamburger 5-7$
Taco Sauce 2.50$
Salsa 3$
Tomatos 3-4$
Shredded Cheese 2.50 (at least)$

Now, I'm no math expert, and some of those prices vary depending on sales, but tacos are pretty darn expensive

EDIT: Plus they take forever to make, which kind of kills my enthusiasm for cooking. I've been eating a diet of crabcakes and cookies for the past week basically, because prep time is almost zero
post #76 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post
Taco Powder: 1.50$
Taco Shells $3
Lettuce 2$
1lb Hamburger 5-7$
Taco Sauce 2.50$
Salsa 3$
Tomatos #-4$
Shredded Cheese 2.50 (at least)$

Now, I'm no math expert, and some of those prices varry depending on sales, but tacos are pretty darn expensive
Not to mention:
Fry Pan - $84.99
Cookie Sheet - $19.99
Spatula - $7.99
Gas Range - $314.99
House in Bridgewater Mass in which to cook - $289,900.00

It's a wonder so many people can afford to eat them.
post #77 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by jvc View Post
Not to mention:
Fry Pan - $84.99
Cookie Sheet - $19.99
Spatula - $7.99
Gas Range - $314.99
House in Bridgewater Mass in which to cook - $289,900.00

It's a wonder so many people can afford to eat them.
Well actually I cook mine a little differently than that. I do not use a cookie sheet, instead 'hanging' the taco shells on the grate of the oven. (Hard to explain, maybe I'll take a photo sometime). Also, I use an electric stove not a gas one. A 90$ frying pan? Mine cost no more than 30, and I do not live in Bridgewater.

You're right about the spatula though : P
post #78 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
How big are these fucking tacos?
post #79 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryan S~ View Post
I've never actually eaten anything from a Taco Bell. I used to eat their hot sauce packets when I'd hang out at the mall, but I heard too many health-scare horror stories growing up about the food at TB to ever take a bite
post #80 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post
I've never actually eaten anything from a Taco Bell. I used to eat their hot sauce packets when I'd hang out at the mall, but I heard too many health-scare horror stories growing up about the food at TB to ever take a bite
post #81 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by yt View Post
Judging by the fact someone took the time to photoshop a "larva bell" sign, I guess I'm not alone in my fear of fast-food tacos

PS: One night I was watching an all night POTA marathon on AMC when I was about 10 or so. My mom had purchased me a box of Hostess Cupcakes to eat. I found, to my horror, a white worm (larva?) in one of them. I have not eaten a Hostess product since that time. I still eat Little Debbie, hoping somehow there are vast manufacturing differences between the two manufacturers
post #82 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post
Taco Powder: 1.50$
Taco Shells $3
Lettuce 2$
1lb Hamburger 5-7$
Taco Sauce 2.50$
Salsa 3$
Tomatos 3-4$
Shredded Cheese 2.50 (at least)$

Now, I'm no math expert, and some of those prices vary depending on sales, but tacos are pretty darn expensive.
You can get taco dinner kits that contain shells, taco seasoning mix and sauce for about $4, which is $3 less than the separate ingredients.

And if you're eating by yourself, eat 1/2 or 1/3 of the total meal, and refrigerate the rest. Thus that $17 just fed you for 2 or 3 days.

And if it takes you longer than 10-15 minutes to cook a whole taco dinner, you're doing something wrong.
post #83 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by nekkerbee View Post
You can get taco dinner kits that contain shells, taco seasoning mix and sauce for about $4, which is $3 less than the separate ingredients.

And if you're eating by yourself, eat 1/2 or 1/3 of the total meal, and refrigerate the rest. Thus that $17 just fed you for 2 or 3 days.

And if it takes you longer than 10-15 minutes to cook a whole taco dinner, you're doing something wrong.
I don't like those kits unfortunately. I prefer "Bearitos" brand taco powder and shells. I actually wrote about that taco powder on my blog party.

And, I hate left overs. So when I make tacos I usually only have left overs for one day, and then I turn the rest of it over to my dad.

PS: It takes me at a minimum 2 hours to make tacos.

PPS: You also get very little sauce and it's in a un-re-sealable packet in those kits
post #84 of 199
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Girma View Post
... fixing one problem only to create another is, well... problematic.
If I were the kind of guy who lazily wrote "QFT" when I thought someone nailed a point, I'd totally write "QFT" right now.

Instead, I'll say that I agree: major structural changes (and ending the corn subsidy would be a major structural change) should be studied and implemented carefully in order to avoid or mitigate unintended second or third order effects.

But acculturating the idea is the first step toward change.
post #85 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post
Judging by the fact someone took the time to photoshop a "larva bell" sign, I guess I'm not alone in my fear of fast-food tacos
LOL. A friend who actually eats there made that gif for me in light of my many unheeded warnings to him not to eat "larva bell." I'm just glad I finally had a legitimate reason to post it.
post #86 of 199
I love your unhealthy food I gotta admit. I gained 25 pounds living 1½ years in the states, because I pretty much had to follow the habbits of my host family. After a year back home, with no dieting I had lost the weight again.

But I'm happy we don't have joints like this around here, cause I would probably go there. But it IS a big part of the problem.
post #87 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Phil View Post
You know when I don't eat healthy? When I'm drinking. Know when I'm drinking? Often.

In conclusion: Drinking = obesity
Um, are you me?

...and we have similair problems as you guys over here that we also refer to as an 'epidemic', we just don't have things like corn syrup in everything and a hell of a lot better access to fresh affordable produce in this country (I simply cannot stress how important that is and how lucky we are) so that we're not quite at your levels just yet - but we're still getting fatter at speed.

We also don't have things like these:



Your countrymen seemingly like some nasty, evil shit.



Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
How big are these fucking tacos?
post #88 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rourkefan View Post
I think Obesity does play into how politicians are perceived. I saw Colbert interview some lady with a book about weight and she said that Obama is considered "more moral" because he is so slim. We have a bias for preceiving fat people as less moral. (Full Disclosure: BMI or not, I'm fat as shit)

I think that the republican challenger to NJ Governor John Corzine, might lose simply cause he is a fat guy.
This is true; Chris Christie, who's running against Corzine in a dead heat, has been portrayed in recent commercials basically saying: "This fat POS can't even stay in shape, you want HIM running your state? Vote Corzine (cut to Corzine jogging through the park)."
post #89 of 199
Bacon-flavored mayo?

Must. Find.
post #90 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by jvc View Post
Bacon-flavored mayo?

Must. Find.
John Stewart did a hilarious bit about this stuff on the Daily Show. Appearently it tastes pretty bad.
post #91 of 199
post #92 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bitches Leave View Post
But I'm happy we don't have joints like this around here, cause I would probably go there. But it IS a big part of the problem.
You would think, right? But I suspect that it isn't all that big a part.

I would guess that, by and large, people don't tend to use independent sit-down places like that for frequent dining - those sandwiches are guilty pleasures, and most people know not to eat them constantly. What most can't get into their heads is that comparatively bland commercial fast food (more innocuous-seeming because of its relative blandness), is just as bad for you - but probably far more affordable and, in some cases, marketed as a viable option for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. And here's the kicker - it's not as nutritious. Assuming that place uses fresh ingredients instead of artificial flavorings and preservatives, you will actually get full. When you eat at McDonald's, you stay hungry because their food barely offers any sustenance - just a bunch of carbs, fat, and artificial shit.

Certainly, our tendency toward the large portion in the U.S. is a bad thing. But never underestimate our tendency toward the cheap, fast, visible, and lowest-common-denominator. In other words, we're mostly getting fat on food that doesn't taste nearly as good as the sandwiches at that place.
post #93 of 199
The saturation of bad choices is what bugs me most. At my new job, as far as immediately available food goes, if I could throw caution to the wind, and eat whatever the hell I wanted, I would have a hundred options within two blocks, and at least half of them are burgers. Instead, I'm sensitive to salt, dont want a shit ton of fat in my food, picky about where my meat comes from, and would prefer to get some vegetables in with my major non-breakfast meals.

My options are Subway (much as I hate the place on principle, I can get a veggie sub there that is actually chock full of veggies) or Pita Pit (which is awesome, but expensive). THAT'S IT.
post #94 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Justin Clark View Post
The saturation of bad choices is what bugs me most. At my new job, as far as immediately available food goes, if I could throw caution to the wind, and eat whatever the hell I wanted, I would have a hundred options within two blocks, and at least half of them are burgers. Instead, I'm sensitive to salt, dont want a shit ton of fat in my food, picky about where my meat comes from, and would prefer to get some vegetables in with my major non-breakfast meals.

My options are Subway (much as I hate the place on principle, I can get a veggie sub there that is actually chock full of veggies) or Pita Pit (which is awesome, but expensive). THAT'S IT.
Yup. I have an In-N-Out Burger within three blocks of my office. You don't understand the sheer force of willpower it takes daily to not go down there and immediately slap down twenty bucks for three animal-style bunless Double-Doubles. And that's not even counting the plethora of shitty fast-food options around.

Then, I have moments like this morning where I held the elevator for an incredibly sweet but equally incredibly obese co-worker, and I kid you not it seemed to take approximately a minute for her to shuffle ten feet to get to the elevator (the "let the fucking door close" buzzer was going off, etc). By the time she got in the elevator, she was breathing ragged breaths and practically holding herself up by the handrail. She can't be any older than her late forties, and I doubt she's gonna see her mid-fifties.

Stuff like that reminds me to keep my shit (and my ego) in check.
post #95 of 199
I was hitting the Pita Pit three times a week last month. But when works stresses up, I eat like a man who's going to the chair tomorrow. AND IT'S ALL MY FAULT.
post #96 of 199
For those of you concerned about the availability of fresh veggies and dismayed by the lunch options near your work, I'd like to put a finer point on it - try thinking like a vegetarian next time you go out to eat. What's available to you on the menu? What actually sounds interesting and isn't just a lame attempt to give the hippies something to eat?

It's eye-opening, to say the least.
post #97 of 199
Ha ha, and you're in Wisconsin. "Mashed potatoes or pasta?"
post #98 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by MissZooey View Post
For those of you concerned about the availability of fresh veggies and dismayed by the lunch options near your work, I'd like to put a finer point on it - try thinking like a vegetarian next time you go out to eat. What's available to you on the menu? What actually sounds interesting and isn't just a lame attempt to give the hippies something to eat?

It's eye-opening, to say the least.
I do this, but we also have a Whole Foods, a Trader Joe's, and tons of awesome Thai, Indian, and Asian fusion restaurants around along with great pizza places and Mexican places and we're spoiled as fuck. I still bring my lunch all the time, though.
post #99 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
How big are these fucking tacos?
yum, tacos!
post #100 of 199
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
I do this, but we also have a Whole Foods, a Trader Joe's, and tons of awesome Thai, Indian, and Asian fusion restaurants around along with great pizza places and Mexican places and we're spoiled as fuck. I still bring my lunch all the time, though.
Yeah, I should have said that people in L.A. can't play that game. Because you are spoiled rotten. I ate like a queen out there.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phil
Ha ha, and you're in Wisconsin. "Mashed potatoes or pasta?"
I was once a 10-year-old vegetarian. In Wisconsin. In the 80s. You have no idea. NO IDEA...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Political Discourse
CHUD.com Community › Forums › POLITICS & RELIGION › Political Discourse › Obesity in America: A Political Issue?