Quote:
Originally Posted by Andre Dellamorte 
Okay, when the monster shows up for the first time, it's awesome in the staging and execution. Whatever you think about the film, if you deny that, you were just in the wrong mindset. It would be like denying the reveal of Ben Harper's head isn't startling.
|
I'm not denying anything.
For me a horrible movie does not have to be bad from start to finish. It just has to fail at what it sets out to do. One marker for that failing is requiring me to make too many leaps of faith that it breaks me me out of it's story.
The more promising the movie is in its first act, the bigger it's failings seem, because it betrayed the trust I gave it when looking for escapism.
Another movie that falls into my 100 worst of the decade is the Descent. I'm not going to formally list it here because I don't want to be jeopardizing this thread with more than one "loved" movie.
The Descent was brilliantly suspenseful and claustrophobic up until the monsters were shown and then it turned into a gory action film which completely broke the mood it had set up and thus made me aware that I am watching a movie.
It is the feeling of betrayal that gets to me. At least the movies that most other people are listing here start out bad and therefore are more honest to its audience. Instead of getting you involved and then suddenly deciding to no longer make the effort.