CHUD.com Community › Forums › MUSIC › Music › Album of the Month: Emmylou Harris + Aretha Franklin
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Album of the Month: Emmylou Harris + Aretha Franklin

post #1 of 22
Thread Starter 
Decision, decisions, decisions!

How could I not pick an album by Otis Redding? Or the Allman Brothers Band? Or The Stooges? Rod Stewart? The Kinks? Al Green? Dylan? Willie? OutKast? Or RUN DMC?

In the end I tried to find a common thread linking R & B and country; choosing to put the spotlight on the two respective Queens of musical form. The two albums I chose are Quarter Moon In A Ten Cent Town by Emmylou Harris and Live At Fillmore West by Aretha Franklin.
***

An Allmusic quote from a review of her boxset:
"It's difficult to write about Emmylou Harris without lapsing into a long train of superlatives — she really does have one of the most beautiful voices of her generation, and her taste in material and skill in using her instrument is nearly faultless. However, as good as Harris is and as consistently strong as her body of work has been, one could make a convincing argument that she's been frequently underrated through much of her career — more than just a lovely woman with a pure, clear voice and a fine ear, she's championed a number of gifted songwriters before they went on to have distinguished careers of their own, matured into a first-rate tunesmith herself, collaborated with a remarkable array of artists, and has never been afraid to take her talents into unexpected directions...."

After the death of her mentor and and musical soul mate, Gram Parsons, Emmylou's first three records were a continuation of his spirit and Cosmic- American legacy. On Quarter Moon in a Ten Cent Town, she not only forges her own identify- for the first time not covering any of his songs but embraces the burgeoning Outlaw movement shaking up Nashville. This record is a marriage of the sensibilities of Gram Parsons and Waylon & Willie. It's her most Rock n Roll attitude album. Yet she never completely abandons the Traditional--you still hear ol' Hank & Lefty. (Curiously in Nathan Rabin's Nashville or Bust entry on Harris, his write up abruptly ends before coming to Quarter Moon. I would have liked to have gotten his opinion, because I think her "the perfection problem" as he coined it, is less an issue here. I mean "Two More Bottles of Wine" and "Burn that Candle" are down right raunchy!)

Aretha Live at the Filmore West is definitely a sleeper. When people talk about the great live albums, it is rarely mentioned. To my ears though it captures everything that made her so exciting at her peak. A blistering live band --King Curtis and the Kingpins supplemented by the Memphis Horns and Billy Preston–--adds fire to her unique brand of secular gospel. A first covers heavy set is pretty good, but be patient because she comes out roaring in the second set and is absolutely amazing! An old Rolling Stone review sums up what you have in store:


"Aretha infuses R&B with pure gospel feeling, acknowledges the joys or pains of people's lives and transforms these emotions by exalting them. The process of this transformation is evident on stage: Aretha's radiance, the confidence and perfection of her impulses, the gestures, sighs, croons that she uses for soulful punctuation, her own complete involvement and the effortless control of the audience."

"Do you feel like hearin' the blues?" Aretha asks, and takes us right into "Dr. Feelgood," brimming with every funky, suggestive technique in her command, all used to maximum effect. The unbelievable gospel exchange that follows without pause...is exciting enough here to justify the record all by itself-"


"..."Dr. Feelgood," tagged with a moaning, shouting, testifying exchange between Aretha, the audience, the band and a robust backing chorus called the Sweethearts of Soul, became even more clearly a gospel–of the bedroom rather than the church."


Or as my man Arthur Conley sang:

Do you like good music
That sweet soul music
Just as long as it's swingin'
Oh yeah, oh yeah

Out here on the floor now
We're going to a go go
Ah dancin to the music
Oh yeah, oh yeah

(A heads up-don't listen to Aretha's album at your office in the middle of the day with the hustle and bustle of people all around. It should be played loud, with the lights dim or in the dark, to get that feeling of being swept up, of actually being at the show)
post #2 of 22
REALLY looking forward to the Emmylou Harris. I loved the Patty Griffin disc that DaveB picked during his round, and knowing what an influence Harris has been on her output should make for a fascinating analysis.

As for Aretha Franklin. Always admired her voice. Rarely familiar with her actual catalogue. She's a legend...that much I know.

Will get on the both of these this weekend.

Good picks, Elvis.
post #3 of 22
Elvis had some trouble posting the links/artwork to the albums, so here ya go (both are on Lala):

Emmylou Harris - Quarter Moon in a Ten Cent Town (1978)



Aretha Franklin - Live at Fillmore West (1971)

post #4 of 22
Really looking forward to these, too. I think the only Aretha album I've heard all the way through is "I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You," and this is one of the many Harris albums I haven't heard.

Before clicking on Ray's link to Lala, I went to the Wikipedia entry for the Franklin album to see the tracklisting. The listing it gives is for a four-disc re-release that compiles Aretha and King Curtis performances from Fillmore West. It looks daunting, but kind of amazing.
post #5 of 22
Two favorites, though as with the recent James Brown At the Garden re-issue, I only know the original release of the Aretha, so I can't wait to try out the re-release.
post #6 of 22
Thread Starter 
Ha. I was hoping the track listings for the re-release didn't give anybody an aneurysm. I was going to suggest it for further listening. It's breathtaking in a similar way as hearing the expanded Fillmore East or Live At Leeds for the first time--shocking how much more was going on outside of an already awesome record. Of course, the Aretha set list was pretty tight, so you get a lot of repeat songs, but the variation can be fascinating. "You're All I Need to Get By" and "Call Me" easily could have made the final cut.

Something else I meant to comment on:

I have always found "Love the One You're With" to be one of the more repulsive Boomer anthems. Somehow, through the R & B covers of it, most notably by the Isley Brothers and Aretha, a plaintive quality is brought out allowing the song to shine.

In Aretha's version on this album she seems to be almost mocking the sentiment by turning it around on the point of view. It is not quite as successful or radical a reclamation as Otis Reddings's "Respect", but it's along the same vein.
post #7 of 22
Thread Starter 
Another quick note on Emmylou Harris:

During her classic 70's run, she assembled arguably the greatest band in country music. Told by an executive that they would sign her if she would "get a hot band"; she went out and hired the best of the best, toungue in cheek-ly calling the group The Hot Band. In spite of the revolving door of membership (most notably James Burton-famed guitarist with Elvis and Ricky Nelson, Rodney Crowell, Glen Hardin, Albert Lee, Bill Payne, Tony Rice, and bluegrass multi-instrumentalist Ricky Skaggs) they all seemed united in a common vision, over the kind of country music they love--never just expensive mercenaries playing for a paycheck. "Quarter Moon In A Ten Cent Town is the pinnacle of the spirit of what they were doing (after this it was a retreat towards the tradional). The bonus track "New Cut Road" gives hint of how blazing this Hot Band was live on stage.
post #8 of 22
Thread Starter 
"Hey Nineteen
That's 'Retha Franklin
She don't remember the Queen of Soul
It's hard times befallen
The sole survivors"

Thinking of those lyrics today, I had to laugh. Sums up both why i was hesitant, yet felt it very necessary to select one of Aretha's albums for the Club. That's from a song released something like ten years after her peak. The divide is larger. She's become even more marginalized. In fact, I can think of few Legends more under-appreciated. Kids still get The Beatles. The Stones. Elvis. James Brown. Even Janis. But Aretha has become something of a joke.

I blame the Big Chill.

It ruined her for X at least. The movie took one of her most powerful, sultry songs, "(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman", and forever associated it with boring white people's mid-life crises--and image of Kevin Kline getting it on.

Unfair.

So this is a call to give the music a chance. Set preconceived notions aside; leave it at the door. Listen to the album, allow yourself to be open to an experience. If you don't dig it, you don't dig it. Perhaps at least a new appreciation will be formed for her artistic brilliance, captivating presence, and command of the stage.

(The connection with the audience is magical and spiritual--the kind of real something we've been chasing since the revolution of '77)


***

I can't get enough of "Sprit in the Dark" and "Spirit in the Dark (Reprise). Wow. At first I was embarrassed by the banter with Ray Charles, but now I think it's charming and kinda cool that Ray was so into it he was getting turned on!

Also, I think her version of "Bridge Over Troubled Water" is definitive. She finds real emotion in it and makes it come alive.

The alternate cuts of "Eleanor Rigby" are better, but I love the wild interpretation.
post #9 of 22
Thread Starter 
Frozen out again!

I hoped for at least a little feedback. Oh well. i'll drown my sorrows tonight by watching I Wanna Hold Your Hand and Shampoo!

To toss up a little something for discussion: "I Ain't Living Long Like This"--a great outlaw anthem, but only Waylon Jennings ever really pulled it off. The only unconvincing song on the "Quarter Moon" record..
post #10 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fat Elvis View Post
Frozen out again!

I hoped for at least a little feedback. Oh well. i'll drown my sorrows tonight by watching I Wanna Hold Your Hand and Shampoo!

To toss up a little something for discussion: "I Ain't Living Long Like This"--a great outlaw anthem, but only Waylon Jennings ever really pulled it off. The only unconvincing song on the "Quarter Moon" record..
Still consuming. I've only listened to the Harris album once (and liked it) and haven't had time to get the Franklin album.
post #11 of 22
Like Dave, I'm still consuming. Sorry, but I'm a little behind right now.
post #12 of 22
Been a crazy and overwhelming week. I've listened to both once (enjoyed them, especially the Harris disc). Will comment once I have the chance to digest them more.
post #13 of 22
Since I've been listening to both albums for years, I wanted to let people who are getting their initial impressions have the first word, but I know it can feel lonely to go without response.

The Emmylou might be the only album of hers that I pretty much enjoy all the way through (though there are several I haven't heard). It's one of the rare times that she seems more interested in the words than in the sound of her own voice (which is a staggeringly beautiful instrument, so that's more or less understandable). On the live tracks, even her audience banter seems looser and less forced than her live stuff would become in later years; "New Cut Road" is probably my favorite thing on the CD.

As for Aretha: I love the album, could swim in the energy, and given that I regard her as the finest vocalist that American popular music has yet produced, it's great to have this recording of her in her prime.

But. It's also an example of her Berry Gordy-like reach for white audiences, with the odd (if effectively presented) covers taking the place of such epics as "I Never Loved A Man", "Do Right Woman", "Ain't No Way", "Chain Of Fools", etc. It's reminiscent of the Motown live albums where someone like Marvin Gaye crams three or four hits into a dashed-off medley, to make room for a Broadway tune and something from the Tony Bennett catalog. Granted, she blows the roof off the studio versions she did (and at least we're spared "Elusive Butterfly" or "Gentle On My Mind"), but it still feels unbalanced to me; at the very least, I'd rather have heard "The Weight". And I don't deny the possibility that she simply loved those songs-- maybe if she'd tried a few more that she hadn't recorded already, the sense of discovery might have made up for it.

But that's a nitpick. It's still a great, great record.
post #14 of 22
Thread Starter 
Interesting takes, Jeb.

Did the "Spirit in the Dark" duet with Ray Charles work for you? And curious if you like the little spin she puts on "Love the One You're With"?

Agree "New Cut Road" is an amazing live cut. Makes me hope for a vintage live album from the Hot Band to show up. Always been a bit underwhelmed by Last Date. Driving in my car yesterday, I couldn't stop playing "Leaving Louisiana in the Broad Daylight". Probably my favorite song on the record. Fantastic vocal work on it. At about 2 mins in, she actually snarls the the title in the chorus. A cool little moment that still gives me chills.
post #15 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fat Elvis View Post
Interesting takes, Jeb.

Did the "Spirit in the Dark" duet with Ray Charles work for you? And curious if you like the little spin she puts on "Love the One You're With"?
It does-- I mean, it's epic by definition-- although I sort of miss the easy groove of the studio version versus the back-of-the-hall drumming, punched-up horn charts, and extended instrumental jam (it's about twice as long as it needs to be, and about four times as long if you only count the actual singing that takes place, but that's part of what live performance is about). As for "Love The One You're With"-- well, it's like "Elusive Butterfly": I'd rather hear her version than the original, but I still don't think it's much of a song; just her singing it at all improves it.
post #16 of 22
Really liking the Emmylou Harris album, Elvis. Much like the Patty Griffin album from a few threads ago, this is an album that I never would have discovered without some prompting.

She has a great voice, and the relatively minimalist production on this album really allows it to shine without sounding forced. There aren't really any standout cuts for me...they all kinda blur together into one long song, and that's not meant as a slam.

Nice one. I'll give Aretha a go this afternoon.
post #17 of 22
Emmylou Harris-Quarter Moon in a ten cent town

I've been a fan for Emmylou Harris for awhile, I got an anthology years ago which I still break out occasionally. I officially became a fan after hearing her perform for 'Sessions at West 54th', hearing 'Prayer in Open D' made me a fan. I just recently started listening to her early stuff, I got Pieces of the sky which I really liked. Quarter is Emmy at her best, the whole album is a wonderful mix of ballads and rockers. The opener 'Easy from now on' is just a wonderfully melancholic piece, 'Two more bottles of wine' and 'I ain't living long like this' prove Emmy is capable rockin' with the best of them, the two centrepieces for me are 'One Paper Kid', the character sketch of a lonely kid who has a collision with a drink driver, it's an achingly beautiful song, the other is Defying Gravity, a gospel tinged ballad, both these songs showcase Harris's voice at it's best, she pulls every ounce of emotion. Her voice is as beautiful as it ever was, she has the songs to back it up.

Aretha Franklin-Live at Fillmore West

Like others, I'm familiar with Aretha mainly through her most well known hits, I've been wanting to delve into her stuff. starting here is as good a place as any. Aretha put on a hell of a performance here, her backing band was tighter than a vault, although her voice was still pretty strong I noticed some wear and tear and the performance went on. I really liked how she took songs like 'Love the one you're with' and 'Eleanor Rigby' and reformatted them to an R'n'B sound, it made them sound fresh, the funky jam towards the end of 'Love the one..." was great. By the time Aretha get's to 'Spirit in the dark'. the crowd is approaching ecstasy, she just builds the energy from song to song, the crowd's enthusiasm reminds me of 'Cold Sweat' from Live at the Apollo Volume 2. while Maceo is delivering an unbelievable solo, you can hear one girl scream 'Yeah, YEAH', it just makes it that much better.
post #18 of 22
I really hate live albums, but I have to say the Aretha Franklin album is stellar. Something about soul/R&B albums work live where typical rock albums don't. The energy from the crowd builds into the atmosphere rather than as a distraction for me. Like the "Yeah, YEAH" moment that Nathan pointed out, that stuff is what I live for. I really enjoyed this and it's a great selection. Good choice, Fat!

Gonna tackle the Emmylou next.
post #19 of 22
The Aretha Franklin live album is quite unexpected. The arrangements on some fo the songs threw me off initially, but they really grew on me on subsequent listenings. And her voice? Yeah, it's pretty awesome. Good energy throughout the album from both Aretha and her band.

I'm not typically a fan of R&B (I really have to be in the mood for it), but I'll be keeping this one.
post #20 of 22
The Emmylou Harris disc---her singing is so heavenly, divine, angelic---that almost every word sounds like it's thrusting on the weight of the world. The first half of the album is the strongest. I love the rockabilly surge of 'Two More Bottles of Wine' and the melting warmth of 'To Daddy' (written by Dolly Parton!). I wouldn't have in a million years listened to an album like this, so thanks Elvis for opening my ears to something pretty special. Between Patty Griffin, and now Emmylou Harris, I've got two inspiring, fresh female singer-songwriters that are ripe for fruitful discovery.

As for Aretha, her backing band coupled with that extraordinary voice make this disc a force of nature. I usually get distracted by the audience when it comes to live recordings, but the audience here just adds to the excitement and energy of the performances. I never realized how much Aretha leaned on the rhythm section. It makes for one toe-tapping, ass-shakin' experience. 'Spirit In The Dark' is the huge highlight here. I don't want that song to end. Just so fun to sing along with and jam to. The reprise with Ray Charles gave me a sweaty workout.
post #21 of 22
Thread Starter 
Appreciate all the feedback guys!

I thought I might be out on a limb with the Aretha Franklin pick. Glad I wasn't the only one blown away by the energy.

My suggestions for further listening:

Emmylou Harris' Blue Kentucky Girl + Luxury Liner. The latter is her more well-regarded, but I like the former for the sassier attitude. It's her answering her tradionalist critics and firmly grabbing the Queen of Country Music crown. Stand out tracks: "You're Supposed to Be Feeling Good", "(You Never Can Tell) C'est La Vie", "Even Cowgirls Get The Blues", "Rough and Rocky", "Beneath Still Waters", and an achingly beautiful "Hickory Wind"

Aretha Franklin Amazing Grace: The Complete Recordings

You think her secular gospel is powerful! Wait to you hear her singing the real deal. If Heaven is anything like this record, you'll want to be there. Breath-takingly transcendent, I've never heard anything like it!

Here's AllMusic's take:

Among Aretha aficionados, Amazing Grace has long been considered one of her high-water marks, since it captured her glorious return to her gospel roots in front of a live audience. The original 1972 album contained just 14 tracks, culled from two live performances with the Southern California Community Choir, Ken Lupper, and the Rev. James Cleveland at the New Temple Missionary Baptist Church in Los Angeles. Fans have long wished for the release of the two complete concerts — which is exactly what Rhino's Amazing Grace: The Complete Recordings gives them. Over the course of two discs and 29 tracks, every performance Franklin gave that January, along with comments from Cleveland and solo tracks from Lupper and the Choir, is unfurled, and if anything, the music is even more impressive when heard complete and unedited.
post #22 of 22
I tried, oh god how I tried, with these albums but they just left me cold in every conceivable way. I appreciate the talent and energy on display in the Franklin record but it's an intellectual appreciation rather than a spirited appreciation and Harris was someone I found incredibly hard to get into. I don't know I found the album to be indistinct in some weird way.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Music
CHUD.com Community › Forums › MUSIC › Music › Album of the Month: Emmylou Harris + Aretha Franklin