CHUD.com Community › Forums › SPECIFIC FILMS › Films in Release or On Video › TSUNAMI: The Aftermath
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

TSUNAMI: The Aftermath

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
Quote:
"Wasn't it also decided that people have the right to fight for their lives?"


Spoken in another disaster film, when rogue waves once again imperiled the globe, the words of Chiwetel Ejiofor really resonated with me when I watched T:TA. If anything, that spirit of survival, that refusal to give up, is embodied to much greater effect in this television miniseries than in Emmerichs similarly themed mega budget disaster flick

The film is a BBC/HBO co production, and the acting is absolutely harrowing. Elijapor is at the top of his game, and his very grounded and believable performance puts us right into the psychology of what it must be like to not only experience a disaster.. but to survive, and be left to pick up the pieces of your shattered life. Unlike in 2012 where he views the end of the world from a chilly remove in the white house situation room, here is in the midst of things and has to fight to reunite his family. It kind of makes you wish he had been the star of 2012 instead of Cusack*

I'm done with the first half of it and if I have any complaints so far it's that the focus seems to be embarrassingly western centric. There is a Thai character who we follow a bit, and see how the wave wiped out his village. But for the most part the focus of the tale is on people who had their vacations wrecked. At one point, a white person tearfully says "This is where people come to get away from their problems, and now this..."

Uh?

People live their lives in Thailand on a non vacational basis. Most of the victims of the Tsunami attack were asians, not posh tourists! Combined with the Tim Roth storyline (where he runs around shouting about how they're burning the bodies of westerners and how it's disrespectful --hey news flash, it's the tropics and bodies spread disease-- ), the whole thing seems a tad tone deaf in some ways. There are efforts made to show things from inside the British embassy, with a bumbling 'Brownie' type character more interested in press conferences than search parties, but it falls flat

Oh well

Anyway, it's gripping television and I think a sober and serious examination of the risks posed by earth quakes. Films like 2012 may have the spectacle, but TSUNAMI THE AFTERMATH has the heart to make you care. I think everyone living along a coast should check it out. The part where Ejiofor's daughter notices the ocean disappearing and her dad's only reaction is to shrug just kills me... Some *basic* disaster preparedness education could have saved these people! I learned about the whole ocean disappearing before a big wave thing in fifth grade for crying out loud

I will return with my thoughts on part two later on

*who gave a boring performance that was totally phoned in
post #2 of 12
I thought this one was passable, just. My issues with it were close to what you're mentioning. It seems almost impossible to handle the story without some condecension creeping in. Frankly, I had gotten plenty of that with the western media's ridiculous coverage of the event by focusing on the tragedies of the twenty or so white folks who happened to be vacationing in the wrong place at the wrong time.

I have to say, though, that on their own, the BBC has been behind some truly effective docu-dramas on disasters. KRAKATOA featuring Olivia Williams was very well done and LUSITANIA (with THE MUMMY's John Hannah) will break your heart. But the real stunner is POMPEII (with rascally Tim-Pigott Smith as Pliny!). Dispensing with soap opera melodrama, they reconstruct the lives of the average residents of Pompeii, Herculaneum and the Neapolitan Gulf from their local context on what was, for too many of them, the last horrifying day of their lives.

Their intellectually thoughtful attention to detail and the personal stories of people caught at varying degrees of proximity give a staggering emotional impact to catastrophes whose tragic dimensions are often diluted by temporal distance.

(Are you going to see Emmerich/Bay level special effects? No. What you will get, that you don't from blank check auteurs, is the compulsion to give a shit about the human beings caught in the nightmare.)

Fortune smiles, they're all NetFlixable.
post #3 of 12
Thread Starter 
I am unable to find KRAKATOA on netflix, and also searched by Ms Williams filmography. Am I doing something wrong?

PS Pompei sounds great! I'm excited to see some of those. I am definitely glad that I was not there in 79 AD. I love how on ROME Atia in one episode says that "Pompei has become so distasteful " or something. Understatement of the century!
post #4 of 12
Are you sure Atia wasn't talking about Pompey, the man?
post #5 of 12
When they aired these on American television, they went through The Discovery Channel, which incidentally proceeded to fuck with the editing. I'm pretty sure the one listed at NetFlix is the right one and I'd fathom that it may have the recut version.

Caution though, by 2008 another British version had been made and getting confirmation on which one is which is hampered by the fact that no two sites (IMDb, NetFlix, Amazon) have matching details for either one. On top of that, I clicked the 'Rent It' link on the 2008 version's IMDb page to see about a cover image and I was sent to a page with the fuckin' 1969 Maximillian Schell potboiler KRAKATOA: EAST OF JAVA (which it isn't, btw).

As each of these were made even the IMDb couldn't get the details right. I only caught the last half of the Lusitania one the first time it aired, naturally recognizing John Hannah I went right to IDMb but there was no listing for it under his profile. It was months after the fact before it showed up.

Most times if either site sees something as a doc, they don't bother with cast listings.
post #6 of 12
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by elsnakeo View Post
Are you sure Atia wasn't talking about Pompey, the man?
No I think it was when it looked like Pompey was going to win the war and they were discussing places that she could live while in exile
post #7 of 12
Thread Starter 
soylentgreen ,

I am searching KRAKATOA on NETFLIX and I get exactly two results. One is a PBS documentary from 2005 listed as being 90 minutes long. The other one is the EAST OF JAVA one from 1969

EDIT: I can hardly find any of those on NETFLIX, solyent. Not sure whats going on. My netflix seems odd some times. For example, I can't get Dr Zhivago through NetFlix. It only has the "save" option for notifying you when it's released on dvd
post #8 of 12
Upon some deeper research, it appears that that PBS video at NetFlix is not the right one, after all. PBS's site doesn't even remember it. It looks as if this is the one mislisted elsewhere as having been made later, although one site identified it as having been made in 1932!

I'm getting the distinct impression that outside of combing some used sources, the one I'm recommending is only left floating around as a Region 2 dvd. Here's a tantalizing link for an overseas version.

I'd still urge you to seek it out. If you've read Simon Winchester's The Day The World Exploded (THE book on the 1883 eruption!), it makes a great companion piece. For what it's worth, I'll keep my eyes peeled for a domestic option for us both as I've been lazy in pursuing an upgrade for my bootleg.

This the hyper for the Pompeii title (It's listed as POMPEII: THE LAST DAY) http://www.netflix.com/WiMovie/Pompe...t_Day/70020148

The Lusitania one had different names depending on where it was broadcast. I saw it as LUSITANIA: MURDER ON THE ATLANTIC. On Netflix it's the one titled : Sinking of the Lusitania: Terror At Sea
If someone was wondering what the great british actor Kenneth Cranham had been up to, you'll be pleased to see him here in a touching performance. A real compassionate look at the captain who was torpedoed by both the Germans and his own damned government.
post #9 of 12
Thread Starter 
SG,

I've actually been meaning to read THE DAY THE WORLD EXPLODED. Krakatoa has fascinated me for a long time now, much like Tunguska. I too will have to keep an eye peeled for that film if it ever gets released over here

In the mean time thanks so much for your helpful links. I ended up adding them both to my queue! Kenneth "Pompey" Cranham is pure class and so I'm excited to see them


Anyway thanks again for your help. It kind of amazes me that in the year 2010 there are still things that you can't get on dvd (including ZHIVAGO, for some reason..)
post #10 of 12
How embarrassing. I don't have HBO and haven't seen any of ROME, so when I mentioned Cranham above, I assumed most folks wouldn't have seen him so recently in so regular a situation. I'll get to the series at some point, compelled mostly by the casting to be honest.

I just wanted to give you(and anyone else) a heads up on that Krakatoa listed at Netflix. I can 100% confirm it's not the right one, or at least not the one I was recommending. In fact, it's so not the right one, it's even the wrong one by NetFlix's fucked up details. The plain jane dvd had an Anchor Bay logo on it and an ABC films credit etched on it so I knew something was wrong. Turns out it's the goddamned KRAKATOA, EAST OF JAVA (which it isn't, btw) film! From 1969! I can confirm this because I too threw it my queue and it just arrived.

So it's the wrong dvd...squared! If it hasn't shipped and unless you're that interested in Maximilian Schell and Brian Keith in a shlocky MYSTERIOUS ISLAND knock-off, get it out of your queue asap.

Sorry for the runaround. It's what I get for trusting NetFlix with details in such a vague and misleading state.
post #11 of 12
Thread Starter 
No worries, Mr Green. I hate when netflix has weird issues like that. For example, why can't I get DR ZHIVAGO through netflix? How does that make sense!? Arg...


Anyway, yes Cranham is aces as Pompey. It's a remarkably layered and "real" performance and it's a shame that it only lasts six episodes (although his final moments in Alexandria are so well shot and the music is so great that you almost don't care*)

Anyway, finished up T:TA last night. The second half was not as strong as the first. Robbed of the chaos and frantic energy that immediately followed the disaster, the last 1.5 hrs of T:TA feels like it's just ticking off boxes for things it didn't cover in the first half (poor quake warning system, ETC) and the momentum slows down until it finally just stops and the program ends. Kind of disappointing. But still, it was worth it for Mr Ejiofor



PS Apropo of nothing, but I've been pronouncing the title of this miniseries "T.S.U. Nami" to amuse myself all weekend lol


*plus his head makes a cameo appearance in the next episode (which awesomely is set entirely in Alexandria... a city founded by Alexander III of Macedon!)
post #12 of 12
Thread Starter 
Mr Green,

I will return to post a thread for it later today but in the mean time I am posting this from my iPod to say that I really enjoyed Pompeii Last Day! It was pretty great it just deserved better special fx...


PS pyroclastic surge, yikes!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Films in Release or On Video
CHUD.com Community › Forums › SPECIFIC FILMS › Films in Release or On Video › TSUNAMI: The Aftermath