Inspired by the release of the Buffy: Season 8 "Motion Comic," I'm putting on my grouchy old man hat for a moment.
What's the point of Motion Comics? As far as I'm able to tell, their primary purpose is to move the panels for the reader, occasionally making some of the pictures blink/move their entire bodies like a badly-animated Speed Racer cartoon. If these things were fully-animated they'd have some reason for being, since they'd transcend what they already are and offer up an interpretation of the comic that's justified by (potentially) having better production values, a decent voice cast, etc. As it is, they're comics for the laziest subset of humanity I can imagine: people who don't want to do the "hard work" of moving their eyes across the page, or imagining the movement that artists are already paid to evoke through their pens.
Is someone glowing in the panel of a comic? The "Motion Comic" will make that glow literal, brightening and dimming the image for you. Is there a sound effect creatively juxtaposed over text? The "Motion Comic" will simulate that sound effect (poorly) so your mind doesn't have to do it for you. Are people talking? Why should you have to imagine what they sound like when a voice actor can half-assedly do it for you?
I'm being harsh, I know, but I'm bewildered by these things. Clearly there's a market for them - but why?
Someone younger/cooler than me, please explain the appeal of the Motion Comic.
What's the point of Motion Comics? As far as I'm able to tell, their primary purpose is to move the panels for the reader, occasionally making some of the pictures blink/move their entire bodies like a badly-animated Speed Racer cartoon. If these things were fully-animated they'd have some reason for being, since they'd transcend what they already are and offer up an interpretation of the comic that's justified by (potentially) having better production values, a decent voice cast, etc. As it is, they're comics for the laziest subset of humanity I can imagine: people who don't want to do the "hard work" of moving their eyes across the page, or imagining the movement that artists are already paid to evoke through their pens.
Is someone glowing in the panel of a comic? The "Motion Comic" will make that glow literal, brightening and dimming the image for you. Is there a sound effect creatively juxtaposed over text? The "Motion Comic" will simulate that sound effect (poorly) so your mind doesn't have to do it for you. Are people talking? Why should you have to imagine what they sound like when a voice actor can half-assedly do it for you?
I'm being harsh, I know, but I'm bewildered by these things. Clearly there's a market for them - but why?
Someone younger/cooler than me, please explain the appeal of the Motion Comic.





