Because somebody mentioned it and I thought it sounded like a great idea.
Carlito's Way - This is probably my second favorite De Palma, after Blow Out. It'd make a fantastic triple feature with Prince of the City and American Gangster. I was a big anti-De Palma guy on the boards for a while, but this film, yet again, proves what a fool I was. Pacino is so good here, as is Penn. It's one of the great late-period Pacino performances, and I like the poor man's Michelle Pfeiffer, Penelope Ann Miller.* That end set piece (even though I recognized the profile when the film started) is better than the train sequence from The Untouchables, and I really liked the film's use of voice over.
Barton Fink - Eh. I liked parts of it, but overall, it felt more like an exercise than anything. Considering that's how the project got started (while the Coens were writing Miller's Crossing, a far superior film), I can see how Barton is everything the Coens were going through at that time. I liked Goodman a great deal, and I thought the visuals were stunning, but this is one that I appreciated on a technical level rather than really connecting with. As a fan of Lynch and Mulholland Drive, I am all about the "What's it all about, Alfie?" school of filmmaking, but I didn't feel like this film challenged me enough to make me want to think about it further. The Coens have done far better.
*She's Carmine Sabitini's daughter Tina.
Carlito's Way - This is probably my second favorite De Palma, after Blow Out. It'd make a fantastic triple feature with Prince of the City and American Gangster. I was a big anti-De Palma guy on the boards for a while, but this film, yet again, proves what a fool I was. Pacino is so good here, as is Penn. It's one of the great late-period Pacino performances, and I like the poor man's Michelle Pfeiffer, Penelope Ann Miller.* That end set piece (even though I recognized the profile when the film started) is better than the train sequence from The Untouchables, and I really liked the film's use of voice over.
Barton Fink - Eh. I liked parts of it, but overall, it felt more like an exercise than anything. Considering that's how the project got started (while the Coens were writing Miller's Crossing, a far superior film), I can see how Barton is everything the Coens were going through at that time. I liked Goodman a great deal, and I thought the visuals were stunning, but this is one that I appreciated on a technical level rather than really connecting with. As a fan of Lynch and Mulholland Drive, I am all about the "What's it all about, Alfie?" school of filmmaking, but I didn't feel like this film challenged me enough to make me want to think about it further. The Coens have done far better.
*She's Carmine Sabitini's daughter Tina.





