Quote:
Originally Posted by Martin S 
The book was bad. Like, really bad.
|
Agreed 1000%. And I was very much in the "This is going to be great!" camp before it came out. I actually *pre-ordered* it, and was excited to sit down and read it. But it was a crushing disappointment. If the zombie stuff interspersed with the story were written by a competent storyteller...it could be a lot of fun. This was not the case.
On the plus side, I think the movie could possibly work. Largely because if you get a decent writer to have some fun with it, there's a lot of possibility there. If Elizabeth comes of as an intelligent but normal Victorian young woman who happens to have to fight zombies, the story could be fun. But in the book, she's presented as a hard-bitten warrior chick who has nothing but comic disdain for non-warriors.