CHUD.com Community › Forums › MUSIC › Music › Gettin' to be that time: Best of 2010?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Gettin' to be that time: Best of 2010?

post #1 of 77
Thread Starter 
Having spent most of this year reviewing music for CHUD's Special Edition column, I've listened to and written about somewhere in the vicinity of 400 2010 releases (and we're not done yet: among others, we've got Duffy, the Tron soundtrack, and Duran Duran still to come.).

Lest you think that makes it easy to select a Top Ten, I started thinking about it the other day, and realized that I was having difficulty narrowing down my ten favorite blues albums of 2010, much less ten albums overall.

So I'm not sure there's much hope for me on this; maybe I'll try for a Top Fifty.

Anyway, NPR has kindly provided a massive list of worthwhile 2010 albums for your consideration, which includes a goodly sample of stuff that I haven't heard myself yet.

I note, however, that, for all its staggering inclusiveness, it's missing several that I thought were among the very best of the year, including Balkan Beat Box's Blue-Eyed Black Boy, Buddy Guy's Living Proof, Keith Jarrett and Charlie Haden's Jasmine, Group Inerane's Guitars From Agadez Volume 3, and Alejandro Escovedo's Street Songs of Love, among others; I'd also say that this year's releases from the Soft Pack, Imelda May, Codeine Velvet Club, Southern Culture on the Skids, Swans, Kenny Burrell, The Unthanks, Tomasz Stanko, Steve Wynn, Tom Jones, Melissa Auf Der Maur, Calle 13, Dwight Twilley, TWO EP's from The Biters and THREE albums from Madlib, just to name a few, were, if not necessarily Top Ten material, then every bit as worthy of inclusion on such a comprehensive list as plenty of other stuff that is there. They even included Justin Bieber, for chrissakes.

But then, we already know that The Suburbs is going to win all these polls, anyway.
post #2 of 77
Tron soundtrack is fantastic btw.
post #3 of 77
It's a tough call between High Violet and the Suburbs. Ironically I think High Violet is way more immediate than The Suburbs, but The Suburbs has grown in stature over the past few months.
post #4 of 77
Honestly, unless something comes out in the next few weeks that blows me the fuck away, Kanye West My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is my favorite album this year by a large margin.

The Suburbs didn't connect for me as much as I thought it would. There's some great tracks on it, yeah, but I felt like it dragged a bit in places.
post #5 of 77
EDIT: Didn't realize this was was the music forum. My bad! I apologize

I don't listen to much current music, but the best song I've heard all year is GO SPEED RACER GO from the movie SPEED RACER. According to iTunes I've heard it more than 500 times
post #6 of 77
Kate rules.

I still think I would put Oddblood and Sigh No More at the top, but, my goodness, what a year.

ETA: God Willin' & The Creek Don't Rise would also definitely be in the top ten.
post #7 of 77
Music thread, Kate, music thread. The top ten film list is in Movie Miscellany, I think, just follow the sounds of intermittent moaning about what a wash this year has been for films.
post #8 of 77
Thread Starter 
Lovely poster, though.
post #9 of 77
Sorry guys! Should have paid attention to the forum. I amended my posting to make it about music

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeb View Post
Lovely poster, though.
I agree, definitely one of the years best posters... of course the American release version featured floating heads
post #10 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Raspberry Leper View Post
Kate rules.

I still think I would put Oddblood and Sigh No More at the top, but, my goodness, what a year.
Sigh No More was last year. I'd agree with you on Oddblood, but a lot of my enthusiasm for that album comes from how amazing they were as a live act. The new Hidden Cameras album, Origin: Orphan, is a similar thing. The album is amazing because of how great they were live.
post #11 of 77
Was kind of a lean year for me musically. There just never seemed to be much that I liked. In fact, 2010 can pretty much be summed up for me with two albums -

Coheed & Cambria - Year Of The Black Rainbow
Red Dead Redemption OST
post #12 of 77
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spike Marshall View Post
Sigh No More was last year.
It was a 2010 release on this side of the Atlantic, which I realize doesn't count for much in the online digital world of music, but I think for list-making purposes, it qualifies.
post #13 of 77
It's High Violet. No doubt.
post #14 of 77
I've had a firm top three for some time now, and nothing I've heard lately has challenged them (although the new Kanye might eventually come close).

Janelle Monae - The ArchAndroid
Titus Andronicus - The Monitor
The National - High Violet

Man, many, many more to come...
post #15 of 77
Last week I thought I had my Top 10 figured out and then I heard The ArchAndroid. I think I'm still going to end up with How I Got Over by the Roots as my number one because it really is the album that defined this year for me. It's funny I think my Top 5 is all going to end up being somewhat hip hop related for the first time ever.
post #16 of 77
If the Suburbs had come from an anonymous new indie band instead of one of the best loved bands of the last decade, no one would in a million years put it in the running for best of the year. A lot of the key 00's acts put out records this year that, while not necessarily perfect or masterpieces, either underlined the things they do best (LCD Soundsystem), made ridiculously ambitious grand statements (Kanye, Joanna Newsom) or pushed themselves in unexpected new directions (Sufjan). The Arcade Fire regressed if anything, and just made a mundane indie rock record with a few solid songs and a load more underwritten filler.

I doubt anyone will be with me on this, but personally while I wouldn't call their album in its somewhat compromised major label form the album of the year, the music phenomenon and surprise discovery of the year for me was Die Antwoord and their array of earlier incarnations. It just hit the perfect sweet spot of catchy, inventive music, cutting edge multimedia artsy elements and a totally original concept and aesthetic. Plus I've found their videos are a great litmus test to separate the really interesting people from the knee-jerking squares.
post #17 of 77
Yeah, as much as I love Arcade Fire, The Suburbs isn't album of the year material. I can definitely see it in the top 10 but not number one. My issue is I almost never am able to decide on a clear #1 and just have a top three that I change around all the time.
post #18 of 77
Personally I love The Suburbs, its really grown on me over time and a couple of tracks I think are among the best ones Arcade Fire have ever produced.

Other faves of 2010:

Heaven is Whenever: The Hold Steady
Forgiveness Rock Record: Broken Social Scene
Tron Legacy OST: Daft Punk
Astro Coast: Surfer Blood
Big Echo: The Morning Benders
Contra: Vampire Weekend
post #19 of 77
I think the Suburbs is a great record, but it's been a great year. I feel a personal connection to the album that grew over time because it reminds me of where I grew up (and it was eerie listening to it when I recently visited). But it's not the best album of the year. That probably won't stop it from winning the NPR thing though.

One thing I don't think some folks are given credit to is how well written the lyrics are on The Suburbs. Butler really grew a lot as a lyricist from Neon Bible to this thing. You could argue that it's a bit repetitive, but he's dealing with a very specific theme, so it fits. He does have to cut down on how often he sings "kids" though.
post #20 of 77
When all is said and done, The Suburbs has a great shot at sticking with me years from now (probably more than most of the albums I've listened to this year). The simplicity that's apparent in many of the tracks could be its greatest asset. Listened to 'Suburban War' a couple days ago and I was moved to near tears. The majority of the songs remind me of my childhood, yes. But it's so much more than that. The album's central resonance dwells up feelings of accepting the past and moving on into adulthood, leaving any regrets, fear, and lost friendships behind. That's a powerful statement to guide and carry throughout an entire album. The band successfully weaves growing pains into beautiful compositions.

It might not be an album I'll want to listen to on constant rotation, but when I do listen to it, it'll hit me like a ton of bricks.
post #21 of 77
Exactly what you two said is exactly why I love it...

I had a horrible 2010 and many of the issues I faced are a direct result of a traumatic childhood growing up in the burbs. This album hit me at the exact right moment and there was acceptance and I am now in the moving on phase.

The lyrics to the title track, city with no children, we used to wait and sprawl 2 resonate so deeply with me that I can imagine in a year or so not being able to listen to it without crying...

Not the best record of 2010, but perhaps the most powerful...
post #22 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul C View Post
If the Suburbs had come from an anonymous new indie band instead of one of the best loved bands of the last decade, no one would in a million years put it in the running for best of the year.
I feel like you could just as easily say the opposite: This album might have gotten more love without the spectre of Funeral looming over it.
post #23 of 77
So here's my list:
Flying Lotus-Cosmagrama
Kanye West- My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
Gorillaz-Plastic Beach
Janelle Monae-The ArchAndroid
Curren$y-Pilot Talk(still haven't heard Pilot Talk 2 yet)
Madlib/Guilty Simpson- Before The Verdict/OJ Simpson
Sleigh Bells-Treats

I'd say that Kanye has the one to beat this year, but I haven't had time to digest it as much as the others.
post #24 of 77
The National- High Violet
LCD Soundsystem- This Is Happening
Janelle Monae- The ArchAndroid
Gorillaz- Plastic Beach
Vampire Weekend- Contra
Arcade Fire- The Suburbs
Kanye West- My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
Tame Impala- Innerspeaker

Pretty much the usual suspects for me doing what they do best with a couple new talents (Monae, Impala) coming out strong. I still have to get to a few albums. I haven't gotten through Big Boi's, haven't heard Cee-Lo's, still haven't picked up Surfer Blood's. All in all I think it was a really great year; the only dissapointments for me was Sufjan Stevens' new LP which is at least (in my eyes...er, ears) an interesting failure, and Interpol's self-titled LP which ultimately didn't live up to the energy that I got from 'Lights.'
post #25 of 77
1. Sigh No more- Mumford And Sons
2. High Violet - The National
3. The Suburbs- Arcade Fire
4. The Winter of Mixed Drinks- Frightened Rabbitt
5. History From Below- Delta Spirit
post #26 of 77
This has been a fantastic year. A damn fine year.

1. The ArchAndroid - Janelle Monae
2. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy - Kanye West
3. Sigh No More - Mumford and Sons
4. The Lady Killer - Cee Lo Green
5. As I Call You Down - Fistful of Mercy
6. Contra - Vampire Weekend
7. The Suburbs - Arcade Fire
post #27 of 77
Here is my top ten list from my blog:

Basically new band Owarikara and their album "Door Tachi" was my favorite album of 2010. Totally amazing rock group that kicked my ass.
post #28 of 77
I'm going to have to retreat to my mountain hideaway for some deep rumination before giving my final list, but right now I'm eyeing Band of Horses, Dessa (whose album A Badly Broken Code is just an extraordinary debut), Wolf Parade, Delphic, Star's new album, The National, and Tokyo Police Club's newest, which might be my favorite of the year.
post #29 of 77
There are still 3 albums coming out in the next 2 weeks that may affect my list:

TRUE GRIT
The Tempest
Kepler by Glass
post #30 of 77
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by andrewhawkins View Post
There are still 3 albums coming out in the next 2 weeks that may affect my list:

TRUE GRIT
The Tempest
Kepler by Glass
Definitely looking forward to those. I have a friend who saw Kepler in New York last year; she didn't care for it, but she acknowledges that she really knows nothing about Glass' music.
post #31 of 77
1.- It's Kanye, guys. P4k told us so.

2.- The fact that most posts don't get to a proper top10 tells me this year wasn't really that good. 2007 or 2009, it wasn't that difficult to end up with 50+ "Honorable Mentions".

3.- I love seeing someone mention Dessa's A Badly Broken Code. Seriously, check her album out. (Bonus track from a couple years ago, check her totally own this song by P.O.S.)

4.- Since most people (by which I mean definitely me and presumably others) use this kind of thread and similar year-end lists to discover things they might've missed in the year, here's a small list (with links) of worthy albums I've enjoyed this year (with added youtubes!) that haven't been mentioned in this thread:

High Places' High Places vs Mankind. Truly gorgeous atmospheric/relaxing.
Matthew Dear's Black City. Which includes Little People, a top10 contender for track of the human history.
Kylie Minogue's Aphrodite. Yes, fucking really.
Brendan Perry's Ark. Formerly of Dead Can Dance, nothing further should be said.
Les Discrets' Septembre Et Ses Dernières Pensées. Blackwave/post blackmetal/shoegaze/whatever you wanna call it. I'd describe it as everything you ever liked about black, minus everything you ever disliked about it.
Autechre's Move of Ten. They actually released two albums this year, but this one is probably their best since Confield. Of course, standard "acquired taste disclaimer" applies.
Emancipator's Safe in the Steep Cliffs. Just chill.
Ariel Pink's Haunted Grafitti's Before Today. By rights, my "not yet mentioned in this thread" rule should've prevented me from mentioning this one. Shame on y'all.

Bonus, perhaps nonessential things I've personally enjoyed.

Serena Maneesh's No 2 Abyss In B Minor. Hooray for wtf album titles.
Army of the Pharaohs' The Unholy Terror. For when you want your battlerap to actually feel battle-y.
Broken Bells' Broken Bells. The high profileness of this release and the fact that it was earthchanging might've made it slip, but its a very enjoyable album.
Twin Shadow's Forget. Just a good album. Shame expectations make that sound like a disappointment now.
The Birthday Massacre's Pins and Needles. Goth-y? Yes. Hot Topic-ish? Of course. You either like this kind of thing or not. I've probably have listened to this album more than others more objectively relevant.
Phaeleh's Fallen Light. Dubstep lives.
Jimmy Eat World's Invented. Saved for last to have at least some pretense at credibility throughout the post.
post #32 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Francis Wolcott View Post

2.- The fact that most posts don't get to a proper top10 tells me this year wasn't really that good. 2007 or 2009, it wasn't that difficult to end up with 50+ "Honorable Mentions".
.
No. This was the best year of music in recent memory. My posts said "many, many, many more to come" and I meant it. I'm just having a hard time figuring out what goes where and what gets included. It's barely December. Give people a chance.
post #33 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Francis Wolcott View Post
2.- The fact that most posts don't get to a proper top10 tells me this year wasn't really that good. 2007 or 2009, it wasn't that difficult to end up with 50+ "Honorable Mentions".
I keep hearing about what a good year it's been for music but I sure as hell haven't heard the proof.

Really digging Archandroid, the Kanye, Tron OST and High Violet. No great rock albums that I can think of.
post #34 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Parker View Post
No. This was the best year of music in recent memory. My posts said "many, many, many more to come" and I meant it. I'm just having a hard time figuring out what goes where and what gets included. It's barely December. Give people a chance.
Hey, I'm going to be checking this thread and all the year-end lists and for pure self-serving reasons I hope I'm wrong, but back in 2007 when I actually assembled a thorough top20 list of albums, I ended up with something around 110 honorable mentions and a couple months later I looked back to it and realized I had left off a couple incredibly obvious albums (Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga being the most high profile one).

Again though, I hope I'm mistaken and I come across a couple dozen albums I've somehow missed in the coming weeks.
post #35 of 77
Until further notice (including soundtracks, scores and re-releases):

1. EYE SPY: Declassified, Freedom Of Information Act - Drew Neumann
2. Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World - Nigel Godrich
3. The Suburbs - Arcade Fire
4. TRON Legacy - DAFT PUNK
5. INCEPTION - Hans Zimmer
6. Further - The Chemical Brothers
7. Grinderman 2 - Grinderman
8. The Social Network - Trent Reznor
9. HALO 02R [Pretty Hate Machine] - NIИ
10. EPARISTERA DAIMONES - TRIPTYKON
post #36 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Evi View Post
I keep hearing about what a good year it's been for music but I sure as hell haven't heard the proof.

Really digging Archandroid, the Kanye, Tron OST and High Violet. No great rock albums that I can think of.
Seriously? None?

Titus Andronicus? Superchunk? Ted Leo? The Walkmen? Gaslight Anthem? Arcade Fire? Fake Problems? And those are just a bunch I could think of off the top of my head.
post #37 of 77
Of those I've only heard the Titus Andronicus and Arcade Fire. Liked them both but didn't love them.
post #38 of 77
Below is my rough top 10 for the year (in no particular order) and many thanks to resident Chewers for introducing me to about half of these.

01. Janelle Monae - The ArchAndroid
02. Big Boi - Sir Lucious Left Foot...The Son Of Chico Dusty
03. Frightened Rabbit - The Winter of Mixed Drinks
04. Ryan Bingham - Junky Star
05. Justin Townes Earle - Harlem River Blues
06. Arcade Fire - The Suburbs
07. The National - High Violet
08. Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
09. Band of Horses - Infinite Arms
10. Daft Punk - Tron: Legacy ST

Then there's New Pornographers, LCD Soundsystem, The Hold Steady, Ok Go and a few more I'm sure I'm totally blanking on at the moment. Then there's some stuff I haven't heard/bought yet because I'm not sure of (MGMT, Drive By Truckers, Interpol, Gaslight Anthem and the like).
post #39 of 77
1. Arcade Fire - The Suburbs
2. Spoon - Transference
3. LCD Soundsystem - This is Happening

Those are my top 3. I don't know how to rank the rest, but they include:

The National - High Violet
Frightened Rabbit - The Winter of Mixed Drinks
Yeasayer - Oddblood
Gorillaz - Plastic Beach
Kanye West - MBDTF
Mike Phirman - The Very Last Songs I Will Ever Record (Part 1)

I still have a lot to catch up on, subject to change, etc etc.
post #40 of 77
Since Mumford & Sons was my favorite of 2009, I'll skip it.

1. The National - High Violet
2. The Walkmen - Lisbon
3. Jonsi - Go
4. Janelle Monae -The ArchAndroid
5. Frightened Rabbit - The Winter of Mixed Drinks
6. Arcade Fire - The Suburbs
7. The Besnard Lakes -The Besnard Lakes Are the Roaring Night
8. Vampire Weekend- Contra
9. Daft Punk - Tron Legacy
10. Titus Andronicus - The Monitor
11. Brendan Perry - Ark (nice call Wolcott)
12. Beach House - Teen Dream

One local band, Karkwa, would be #2 or 3 if I included them, but I kept my list to titles you guys will hear about.
post #41 of 77
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Martin S View Post
Since Mumford & Sons was my favorite of 2009, I'll skip it.
You could toss in their EP with Laura Marling and The Dharoar Project; it's pretty nifty.
post #42 of 77
To Darkness is the only truly outstanding song on that EP, even if I like the EP a lot.
post #43 of 77
I was really excited because I got tickets to see Mumford and Sons in my hometown, then it turned out to be that Mumford and Sons/Laura Marling/Dhaorar project and my heart was broken.

Still trying to work out my top 10 albums, but if anyone is interested you can listen to my twenty favourite songs of 2010 on this grooveshark playlist, tracklist below.

http://listen.grooveshark.com/playli..._2010/40424743

Quote:
1. Conversation 16 – The National
2. I Saw The Dead – Villagers
3. Black Sheep – Clash at the Demonhead
4. All Delighted People (Original) – Sufjan Stevens
5. Giving Up The Gun – Vampire Weekend
6. No Place To Fall – Isobel Campbell and Mark Lanegan
7. Cloud Shadow on the Mountain – Wolf Parade
8. Tornado – Jonsi
9. We Sleep On Stones – Cherry Ghost
10. The Big Guns of Highsmith – Lightspeed Champion
11. A Darkness Rises Up – Broken Records
12. Suburban War – Arcade Fire
13. Dead Hearts – Stars
14. Mondegreen – Yesayer
15. We Want To – New Young Pony Club
16. Compass – Jamie Lidell
17. This Is Where It Gets Good – Eels
18. Crash Tactics – 65daysofstatic
19. Divisive – We Have Band
20. You Fucking People Make Me Sick - Swans
post #44 of 77
I would have loved to see that show Spike.

Black Sheep is a Metric song btw. And I don't know a 1/4 of those bands on your list, like The Villagers.
post #45 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Martin S View Post
Black Sheep is a Metric song btw.
Perhaps he means, specifically, the movie version of the song with vocals by Brie Larson.
post #46 of 77
Spike, people call me crazy but Conversation 16 is my favorite song on High Violet and probably in my top three for the whole year.
post #47 of 77
Hell yes to The Besnard Lakes. That might come to be one of my favorites of the decade.
post #48 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spike Marshall View Post
I was really excited because I got tickets to see Mumford and Sons in my hometown, then it turned out to be that Mumford and Sons/Laura Marling/Dhaorar project and my heart was broken.

Still trying to work out my top 10 albums, but if anyone is interested you can listen to my twenty favourite songs of 2010 on this grooveshark playlist, tracklist below.

http://listen.grooveshark.com/playli..._2010/40424743
I like the bands on your list but you have the WRONG SONGS! Half Light II, Run, Fixed, and Terrible Love are clearly the best songs on their respective albums (Arcade Fire, Vampire Weekend, Stars, and The National)! :folds arms:

EDIT: The new New Young Pony Club album is good, but I think its a step down from their debut. But that's just me.
post #49 of 77
Rolling Stone never ceases to amaze me. The ArchAndroid didn't even make their top 30 albums of the year list. FUCKIN' RIDICULOUS.
post #50 of 77
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ali View Post
I like the bands on your list but you have the WRONG SONGS! Half Light II, Run, Fixed, and Terrible Love are clearly the best songs on their respective albums (Arcade Fire, Vampire Weekend, Stars, and The National)! :folds arms:
I was torn between Half Light II, Sprawl II, and Suburban War but I was in my old neighbourhood listening to my MP3 player when the "All my old friends, they don't know me now" utterly destroyed me.

I'm still getting to grips with the new Stars album and I will FIGHT YOU TO THE DEATH over which of the consistently amazing songs from High Violet is the best.

Quote:
EDIT: The new New Young Pony Club album is good, but I think its a step down from their debut. But that's just me.
I don't dig the album overall as much as their previous one, but there are a few songs on it which are so much fun.

Quote:
I would have loved to see that show Spike.
It was an OK show, in actuality kind of brilliant show, but I was disappointed by the lack of Mumford stuff.

Quote:
Black Sheep is a Metric song btw. And I don't know a 1/4 of those bands on your list, like The Villagers.
I was just being Cute with the Clash at Demonhead thing. You also need to hear Villagers ASAP.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Music
CHUD.com Community › Forums › MUSIC › Music › Gettin' to be that time: Best of 2010?