Quote:
hiro!:
nobody walks on water. not everything written by barker is sacred. pointing it out doesn't make me a "dickhead" or a "moron", but blind loyalty over something like this is a waste of time. acknowlege true horror if you are a horror fan. don't just cling to the past. |
Firstly, nobody is saying the guy is perfect. You've missed the point. This was a thread asking for serious questions I can ask Clive in an interview. Not a "what do you think of Clive Barker" thread. Rather than contribute usefully, you used it as a chance to demonstrate your half-assed sarcasm. Did you seriously expect me to ask him why his recent books "sucked"? My guess is "no". Or were you just playing to the gallery - dazzling us with your shocking against-the-grain opinion? Your post came across as the worst kind of smug trolling, and was phrased in an assholish way. "You read it here first"? Wow, thanks for the exclusive. You saw a thread asking for questions for a guy you think is overrated, but rather than leaving it be, you chose to chime in with an irritating and pointless snipe. This annoys people. That's why you got a cold reaction, not because of your daring and radical opinion.
Secondly, Clive Barker is not a horror author. He has never claimed to be a horror author. He has been pigeon-holed as a "horror" guy because of Hellraiser, but even his first books are dark fantasy rather than blood and guts. So slamming the guy for "not being scary" is redundant. Most of his novels have traces of what we would call "horror", but he's moved beyond the confines of one genre now and is - gasp! - creating unique and fascinating new work across genres. It may not always work (I thought Galilee was a big letdown) but at least with a talent like Barker at the helm, the journey is always interesting. Don't like it? Don't read it. If he didn't set out to write a horror story, it's not really his problem if you don't think it's scary. Don't project your inability to look past the obvious onto the author.
Thirdly, what is "true horror" exactly? You know, just so we can all spot it in the future and save ourselves from this sort of confusion. Is it, by any chance, anything
you like?