CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE CHEWERS › The Chewers Catch-All › Getting Dumped
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Getting Dumped

post #1 of 54
Thread Starter 

So, I got dumped yesterday by my girlfriend of five months.  She's probably my first super serious girlfriend.  We had a good Christmas, had just gotten back from a trip to Vegas (which was a little bumpy) and had a good new years eve/day, and then boom.  Dumpsville.  She claims a bunch of stuff like not feeling the same love for me that she thinks I feel for her.  She says she feels love for me, likes me, finds me attractive, and thinks we have great sex, but doesn't think our personalities match enough, which I think is bullshit.  Says I deserve better (equivalent of it's not you, it's me).  She's a bit bi-polar and I know she goes into these emotional funks pretty often, and I also know she's pmsing right now.  I feel like she has these insecurities and believes she doesn't deserve to be happy, so pushes people away.  So, do I just let her throw us away?  How far into pathetic desperation do I go to get her back?

 

Helluva fucking way to start the new year, I tell ya.

 

Oh, I know this is stupid, but she still hasn't changed our relationship status on facebook.  Is it retarded for me to take that as meaning there's still a chance?

post #2 of 54
Don't waste your time hoping on stuff like that. It sucks but if she was willing to do that to you when she did and for those reasons, she probably fears the commitment. Maybe saving you a lot of valuable time.
post #3 of 54

I'm with Nick on this one. Take it from someone who spent more of last year than I'd care to remember wondering about stuff like that, it just ain't worth fretting over morning, noon, and night, Mike. Hope things work out for the best. I wouldn't wish that kind of thing on anyone.

post #4 of 54
I agree with Nick.. It sucks man but stop thinking about all that crap, It'll only eat you up on the inside. Go out with some friends, gets some beers and watch some Football or movies or whatever. Enjoy your freedom.
post #5 of 54

While I've never been dumped before, it is my considered opinion that your best bet would be to try and move forward and shut yourself off emotionally to the situation. It's the past, and you need to focus on the present/future. Even if the timing of her decision was the result of having a bad week, ETC, that is unlikely to factor into her willingness to reconsider (IMHO). Having made the move to sever all connections, the only thing more painful than cutting you off would be to dive back into the relationship anew only with all this fresh baggage to go with it. Better to just focus on yourself right now

 

Best of luck to you

post #6 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by MikeShaynePI View PostOh, I know this is stupid, but she still hasn't changed our relationship status on facebook.  Is it retarded for me to take that as meaning there's still a chance?


She doesn't want to appear heartless. I was in her shoes recently. There's no etiquette manual for Facebook.

 

Resign yourself that it's over, take the time to heal, and take care of yourself.

post #7 of 54

If you got back with her it wouldn't be the last time she ditched you.   Insecure chicks like that begin to hate you for being good to them and treat you like shit in an almost masohistic way.

post #8 of 54
Thread Starter 

Yeah, sounds like her...

 

She was also into anything in bed, though.  Anything.  (Well, not like scat.  Neither am I, mind you.)

post #9 of 54

Sad to hear about your break up, Mike.

 

A girl into ANYTHING in bed sounds like a treasure indeed, but there's always going to be another girl like that. One who'll appreciate you more, and not give you some stupid crap about not having personalities that match.

post #10 of 54

...alcohol...

post #11 of 54

Sever all contact, hit the gym, hook up with tons of strange. Worked amazingly well for me. If she's serious about it, she'll come back. If not, you got all that cliched shit about fish and seas to worry about.

post #12 of 54

Pretty much echoing what Nick and Jake say: sever all contact (don't try any of that "we'll be friends" bullshit) and move on.

 

Which doesn't mean not acknowledging the hurt or loneliness. But not with her, and not aimed at some reconciliation. Whether those are the real reasons or not, she's telling you she's done.

 

Sorry for the breakup, though - especially after a trip together. That's got to suck in a number of ways.

post #13 of 54

Take it from me, sever all contact. Do you share mutual friends, or do you work together? If not then delete her off your phone and block (not necessarily delete) her on Facebook. I haven't talked to my ex-wife in almost six months and I'm the better for it. 

 

Do you usually...stay friends with exes?

post #14 of 54

If you want to wallow a bit, then listen to Local H's "Twelve Angry Months". Best CD for an angry/bad break up. I'm happily married and I still think it rocks.

post #15 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bartleby_Scriven View Post

 

Do you usually...stay friends with exes?


Listen to Bart. He knows the perils!
 

post #16 of 54

Don't be surprised if she starts making noises about getting back together near Valentine's Day.

post #17 of 54

How old are you, Mike?

post #18 of 54

Great advice in this thread. If she's insecure like you say, you should be grateful that it only lasted as long as it did. That seems like cold comfort until you spend years of your life with someone who ends up resenting you for caring. Not a fun way to learn that some things shouldn't be dragged out.

post #19 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by joeypants View Post

How old are you, Mike?


Wondering the same, because not to downplay your upset, but five months is a blip. You'll be fine.

post #20 of 54

Bipolar girl? 

Run, Mike, Run... forrest-gump-fight-282x300.jpg

post #21 of 54
Thread Starter 

I tried to post from my iPad, but ever since the change to the boards that doesn't seem to be possible.

 

To catch up:

 

I'm 27.  I've had relationships, but mostly dating and fucking until now.  She's probably a bit bipolar.

 

We got back together Sunday...

 

So it'll probably last at least another month.

post #22 of 54

Good luck, dude.  But be cautious. 

post #23 of 54

shit man, don't do it.  All the advice in this thread has been golden.  You have to just walk away.  I've been through too many goddamned break up/make up relationships and wasted too much time thinking about this exact shit.

 

I've been with the wife for ten years now, married for 8, never broken up once.  Makes me look back at all the previous ones and think 'what were you doing, wasting your time like that?'

 

I could be wrong though, I hope so, but if she does it again just walk and don't look back.

 

Good luck.

post #24 of 54

Yeah, I don't want to shit on your dessert, so I'll say good luck.....but I agree with Andy that you should have made a clean break and run the hell away.

 

Reconciling ain't impossible, but outside of the movies, I think some time away from each other - really away from each other - is necessary to gain some perspective on what went wrong.

post #25 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by MikeShaynePI View Post

 

We got back together Sunday...

 

So it'll probably last at least another month.



Everyone's too nice. You're an idiot. She's got you totally by the balls. You should have walked away.

However - at least you realize it probably won't last. So fuck the shit out of her for now. Sooner or later you'll learn there isn't time for mind fuck games like this chick is playing.

post #26 of 54

IMHO whatever causes led to the breakup in the first place have not gone away (most probably) and I fear that you're merely delaying the inevitable. She most likely just started to feel lonely and decided that she'd rather not be alone at that moment

 

Good luck though

post #27 of 54
Thread Starter 

That's certainly a possibility, Kate.  I also think alot of this stems from her thinking she doesn't deserve anything good and thus creates these other problems to push me away.  Totally unhealthy either way, but she's seemed pretty happy the last few days. 

 

As far as having me by the balls, it's difficult to rationalize that.  She doesn't make me do things.  She doesn't make me buy her things.  She just made me breakfast.  So as far as manipulating me, it doesn't seem to be doing anything if she is.  If she's trying to manipulate me into staying with her, well, I was fine being with her before this, so my opinion hasn't really changed. 

 

I do thank you all for you advice though.  If or when this happens again I do plan on calling it done for good. 

post #28 of 54

In my personal experience, it's not that you think you don't deserve good things, it's that the burden of a nice person is tough to live up to. If someone treats you nicely, it's as if you have to live up to some idealized version of you they may have in their head

 

Anyway, best of luck

post #29 of 54

Well, it does sound like you don't think the second phase of the relationship has any real longevity. I'm no expert, but it seems like there's some resentment from both parties that lingers. I say good luck to you, as you might have to embrace that things could get darker between you two. I got back together with one of my girlfriends months after we broke up, and if the first part of our relationship was Gremlins, then the second part was Gremlins 2: darker, more experimental, and ultimately a lot less well-liked than the first. If it will be short lived, embrace the fact that its possible both of you are doing it for selfish reasons, which is entirely healthy as long as one is honest with oneself. Though I do hope you two find a way to click that few do and have a happy life (or even a couple of years) together.

post #30 of 54

And I guess this might be the place for all of us to share our experiences getting dumped, isn't it? Apologies if I'm stealing any sort of attention, Mike.

 

I was dumped two months ago by the woman I thought I was going to marry. It was a long distance relationship that began in 2007, as I admired her writing from afar. Once 2009 rolled around, we proposed to try to be a romantic couple, and she began visiting from Florida (I am in NYC) every two or three months for weeks at a time. She had lots of disposable income, and I had none, so it was constantly her paying me visits, and we loved each other's company. We loved discussing movies, music, books. I made her a new mixtape every two weeks. We talked for more than an hour every day on the internet and on the phone, and she was always within reach. We shared everything. And yes, she did EVERYTHING in bed. And some people say everything, but I mean EVERYTHING.

 

We got into an argument while she was last visiting in November where she suddenly revealed that she didn't think I was giving 100% of myself to the relationship and that she wasn't happy. The main issue was that I hadn't visited Florida, though I had just been unfairly terminated from my menial job and was fighting my former employer, who had successfully blocked my unemployment benefits twice. She left that night, announcing to her 7000+ followers on Tumblr (yes, I know) that she was single, alone and in a hotel room in NYC. Baseless suspicions that I was meeting other girls or dating a week later (I wans't, I was too wrecked still) led her to stop talking to me completely. And so my only communications were via Tumblr, where I read her everyday essays and writing samples. Ocassionally she would make a veiled reference to me being somewhat unfaithful (I wasn't) or her not being enough for me(she was, and then some). It's a little weird to read something suggesting you're an unfit boyfriend and to see 80 people literally click "like" in response.

 

I started to pick up from her Tumblr in early December that she had already found another boyfriend. Then she started talking about being in love. Then she started talking about moving in with him. Then pictures of him alone started ending up on her Tumblr. Then I found out he, too, lived in New York City. There were times she visited me in NYC where I would be at work, but by and large we spent most of the time together. Who was this man? When did he enter her life? When did he become a lover? Is she really moving to New York City to live with another man when I always wanted her to move in with me? Why does he even kind of look like me?

 

I found this out while visiting my family during the holidays. In addition to their usual awfulness, I found that my mother had begun to read her Tumblr, and had firmly sided with her, despite not knowing what I did or might have been doing to screw up the relationship. She also commented on her being an "excellent writer" despite my lifelong writerly ambitions, which I'm pretty sure she has never commented on herself. There's no real resolution or "what now" step like Mike's predicament, I've just been drinking a lot and needed to vent about this somewhere. I"ve washed my hands of the whole thing, I think, but I am still going through an extremely dark depression, the first real big one of my entire life.

post #31 of 54

I read that entire last post as "I miss the rich girl who used to let me anally fuck her".

post #32 of 54

Just a hunch: people who claim that exes did 'everything' in bed have limited imaginations

post #33 of 54

Well, fuck you very much guys, off to Happy Hour(s).

post #34 of 54

This post right here made me love Kate, suddenly, and with great force. 

post #35 of 54

As for you, Gabe. I agree, that is total bullshit, and it sucks that you can't even rely on your family for support during such a trying time. 

 

That being said, if everything that you wrote about is true, why the fuck would you even want to be with someone like that? Now, I'm a life long bachelor (so far, anyway), much more interested in casual sex than a relationship (I've sworn off relationships after a particularly traumatic one... yeah, yeah, I'm too hurt to love and all of that shit), but in my experience, I would much rather go out and get some average strange than have a committed relationship with a woman with whom I have great sex but apparently has very serious trust issues. 

 

She's got trust issues, a desire to only engage in long term relationships, and apparently a willingness to move on rather quickly. Fuck her. Follow Jakes advice: get toned, get drunk, get laid.

post #36 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mezz View Post

As for you, Gabe. I agree, that is total bullshit, and it sucks that you can't even rely on your family for support during such a trying time. 

 

That being said, if everything that you wrote about is true, why the fuck would you even want to be with someone like that? Now, I'm a life long bachelor (so far, anyway), much more interested in casual sex than a relationship (I've sworn off relationships after a particularly traumatic one... yeah, yeah, I'm too hurt to love and all of that shit), but in my experience, I would much rather go out and get some average strange than have a committed relationship with a woman with whom I have great sex but apparently has very serious trust issues. 

 

She's got trust issues, a desire to only engage in long term relationships, and apparently a willingness to move on rather quickly. Fuck her. Follow Jakes advice: get toned, get drunk, get laid.


Well, I mean, I never saw any of it coming. I always felt she had slight trust issues with me since in a prior relationship, I had cheated (like an asshole!), but it felt like she thought I had atoned. When she told me she was unhappy and that I wasn't giving my all to the relationship, it came out of left field. I was surprised, and I wonder how much of it was stuff I hadn't seen, but also because she had always been open to me about what the both of us could be doing better.

 

It's not that I miss her as much as I felt she really hurt me quite a bit, and I was genuinely in love with her. I don't think I'm ever going to meet a woman who was that sweet and generous and caring to me, who was also sarcastic, funny, witty and talented. And just stunningly beautiful.

 

I wanted to go out and try to forget it all, but I've become such a weeping vagina since she left. I am terrified (TERRIFIED) of rejection at this point, and I don't feel aggressive enough to be flirty with NYC women. As of now, most nights (including my birthday last week) have been spent drinking alone, nursing a knee injury and watching movies, and (I should seek help for this) every movie or TV show that has anything VAGUELY emotional turns me into a fucking crying machine. I don't want her back, but I don't have much of anything lately. It comes and goes, and the only reason I shared it here is because the last week has been particularly bad. I haven't spoken an audible word in three days!

post #37 of 54

Gabe, I can beat your mom siding with your ex: my mom actually told my (then) estranged wife to go after "all my money," despite 1) me not having any and 2) the (now ex-)wife and I still talking on a regular basis.

 

And Jake's right: get in shape, get blitzed, and get some. I know you're feeling pretty awful now, but the best thing is to channel that energy into reachable, physical goals. Working out regularly will do wonders (as long as you're eating right, too).

post #38 of 54

Ack, I think I blew something out in my knee a little while ago. It felt great the other day and I ran four miles, but since then it's been feeling balky again. I don't really have anything in the budget to see a doctor. I held off on seeing anyone over the holidays because my brother is a doctor, but he weirdly told me to go fuck myself, so I'm not sure what I can do with it, keeping me from some good workout time. Otherwise, I would be out there wittling my body into something kinda awesome.

post #39 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gabe T View Post

Well, fuck you very much guys, off to Happy Hour(s).



 



Quote:
Originally Posted by Gabe T View Post

Ack, I think I blew something out in my knee a little while ago. It felt great the other day and I ran four miles, but since then it's been feeling balky again. I don't really have anything in the budget to see a doctor. I held off on seeing anyone over the holidays because my brother is a doctor, but he weirdly told me to go fuck myself, so I'm not sure what I can do with it, keeping me from some good workout time. Otherwise, I would be out there wittling my body into something kinda awesome.



 Gabe,

 

Sorry to hear about your joint difficulties and I wasn't trying to pick on you before just was commenting more generally on something other people had said as well. Anyway, rest up and get better soon

post #40 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gabe T View Post

It's not that I miss her as much as I felt she really hurt me quite a bit, and I was genuinely in love with her. I don't think I'm ever going to meet a woman who was that sweet and generous and caring to me, who was also sarcastic, funny, witty and talented. And just stunningly beautiful.

You're in NYC. You're gonna be fine.
 

Even in L.A., I can name at least five single women I've met within the past 11 months since I broke up with my ex that fit these criteria. Again, you're gonna be perfectly fine. Cowboy up, dude, there's a whole world to dive into out there.

 

(But definitely don't jump into anything heavy right off the bat.)

post #41 of 54

And about all that joint shit: You taking fish oil? If not, start giving it a go. 4-6 caps per day, then up it if the joint pain increases. Also get your gait analyzed at a proper running shoe store when you have the time. It might just be your shoes.

post #42 of 54

Listen to Jake, Gabe.  He is wise beyond his years.  And I feel for you man, I've gone through something similar:  Long distance relationship,  I thought she was the greatest, love of my life, all that shit but it pretty much imploded after I found out she was screwing around (ALOT) when not with me.  It pretty much destroyed me at the time (mainly because I was at an already shitty stage in my life and she was the only good thing back then), but you know what?  And I'm pretty sure anyone who's been through a bad break-up will agree with me, it always gets better.  Yeah your hurting now but you'll survive: a little stronger and a little wiser.  Chin up, man!  After I pulled myself out of that pit and started going after girls again (nothing serious though) I started seeing how many girls there were that were even more awesome than my ex was.  And you'll be surprised how many of them are into "everything". 

post #43 of 54

And you have to have to have to get the fuck out of the apartment and go do things. Not just to keep you distracted, but to meet people. My social life EXPLODED about three months into my breakup with my ex. Not only did I meet some awesome people (some of whom were women!), I learned a lot of stuff, came out of my shell, and did some stuff that I never expected to. I'm still on that road and still having a ball. I also reconnected with some old friends that I had shunned at her behest, and our friendship's stronger now than it was before. Take this time to take stock of yourself AS AN INDIVIDUAL, INDEPENDENT OF THE DUALITY OF A RELATIONSHIP and see what you want to fix/improve/shed, and do it.

 

And for the love of christ you guys don't try to be friends with your exes until you can seriously, genuinely imagine seeing them on the street with someone else and being absolutely cool with it.

post #44 of 54


 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post

And you have to have to have to get the fuck out of the apartment and go do things. Not just to keep you distracted, but to meet people. My social life EXPLODED about three months into my breakup with my ex. Not only did I meet some awesome people (some of whom were women!), I learned a lot of stuff, came out of my shell, and did some stuff that I never expected to. I'm still on that road and still having a ball. I also reconnected with some old friends that I had shunned at her behest, and our friendship's stronger now than it was before. Take this time to take stock of yourself AS AN INDIVIDUAL, INDEPENDENT OF THE DUALITY OF A RELATIONSHIP and see what you want to fix/improve/shed, and do it.

 

And for the love of christ you guys don't try to be friends with your exes until you can seriously, genuinely imagine seeing them on the street with someone else and being absolutely cool with it.


DING DING DING!

 

To Mike and Gabe - I can NOT say this enough: it is much better for relationship with hidden issues to crash and burn before you commit yourself to a long term, torturous existence. You gotta get all Ash and say "This hand is evil and I'm lopping it off, for survival. In the sequel I will build an even better robot hand that will make Luke Skywalker jealous, in a barn, without the advantage of modern technology. And I'll do it all looking good."

 


 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post

the burden of a nice person is tough to live up to.


 

I know, right? I hate it when people are nice to me!

post #45 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post

And you have to have to have to get the fuck out of the apartment and go do things. Not just to keep you distracted, but to meet people. My social life EXPLODED about three months into my breakup with my ex. Not only did I meet some awesome people (some of whom were women!), I learned a lot of stuff, came out of my shell, and did some stuff that I never expected to. I'm still on that road and still having a ball. I also reconnected with some old friends that I had shunned at her behest, and our friendship's stronger now than it was before. Take this time to take stock of yourself AS AN INDIVIDUAL, INDEPENDENT OF THE DUALITY OF A RELATIONSHIP and see what you want to fix/improve/shed, and do it.

 

And for the love of christ you guys don't try to be friends with your exes until you can seriously, genuinely imagine seeing them on the street with someone else and being absolutely cool with it.


I like how you're simultaneously trying to help and explain how TOTALLY FUCKING AWESOME you are. It's charming. 

post #46 of 54

Thanks, kitten. I love you too.

post #47 of 54

To be honest I just wanted to subscribe to this thread so I could get some schadenfraude. But really, you're kind of hilarious. Both self pitying and self aggrandising in the same breath. Just fascinating. 

post #48 of 54



 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sphere_Monk View Post

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post

the burden of a nice person is tough to live up to.


 

I know, right? I hate it when people are nice to me!



 Right because that's exactly what I said ::polar bear facepalm::

post #49 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by Princess Kate View Post

::polar bear facepalm::


Princess, I'm actually really glad you brought this up. I've been meaning to talk to you about it.

 

I'm 78% sure that polar bears don't have palms. If you look at this scientific diagram you'll see that they specifically omit mentioning it between "long claws for tearing apart prey" and "large furry feet for walking on ice and snow." Now, I'm no bearologist, but even though the small rounded ears and black nose are adorable, you might want to consider doing more research on the subject.

 

During the interim, here's a less risky loaner that should get you through the rough spots. You're welcome.

post #50 of 54

Who said polar bears had palms? A "facepalm" is a gesture.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Chewers Catch-All
CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE CHEWERS › The Chewers Catch-All › Getting Dumped