I watched the scene twice, wondering why this scene in particular was being singled out. And it is pretty amazing how In-the-moment Pitt appears to be. He looks angry, frustrated, concerned. And yet it does seem as if there's some affection behind his bullying. I felt sorry for the boys, but you sense that the character really thinks he's trying to help the boys be men. It'll be an even stronger scene, I'm sure, when shown within the context of the film.
Sometimes I forget what it's like to see a really great actor performing. Though the movie wasn't great (in fact, I had to look up the name just now) I had a moment of epiphany during Adjustment Bureau where it kind of hit me that it didn't seem like Matt Damon and Emily Blunt were acting. They seemed genuine. Another great moment is in Mulholland Drive. Naomi Watts. I watched the first half of that movie, thinking that the production values seemed a little Cinemax, or made for TV. And then you hit that audition scene, and it's like... Whoa.
I just watched The Thin Red Line a few weeks ago. My first Malick. Really looking forward to this one.