Another vote for NIGHTBREED 2 & 3 as mentioned by Clive Barker (he of the extraordinary cocktease) in the early 90ies.
The same goes for the LORD OF ILLUSIONS sequel which was once supposed to happen with the subtitle VORTEX. Do it already!
They should also erase Hellraise III - ? from memory by making the follow-up to HELLRAISER II: HELLBOUND that they originally wanted to make, the one in which Clair Higgin's Julia becomes the Queen of the Cenobites. God, that would rule ...
DEAD RECKONING is also one I agree with. It has to happen.
More animated VAMPIRE HUNTER D!!!
David Lynch should do sequels to both LOST HIGHWAY and MULHOLLAND DRIVE.
HELLBOY 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11 etc., all directed by Guillermo del Toro and starring Ron Perlman!!!
TETSUO III: FLYING TETSUO; when will Tsukamoto finally do this???
JEEPERS CREEPERS 3,4,5,6,7,8,etc. all written and directed by Vicor Salva, including the Western prequel he once mentioned!
Not horror by any stretch of the imagination but I demand that Arnold Schwartzenegger gives up on his rediculous politics-plans and does KING CONAN and T4.
I also want more UROTSUKIDOJI!!! Again, they should forget about the utter shit that was the last episode of UROTSUKIDOJI IV and go from there. More quality tentacle rape is in order!
A sequel to Andrezej Zulawsky's POSSESSION would be nice.
Takashi Miike should do AUDITION II. I don't care what it will be about 'cause I'm sure it will be fucked up.
Again, agree with ALIEN 5, EVIL DEAD 4 if done right. Great Nightmare and F13 films should get pumped out. Peter Jackson's Nightmare script should be filmed ...
Not sure if you'd call it a sequel but Alex de la Iglesia should be allowed to make his FU MANCHU film and he should make a big-budget sequel to ACCION MUTANTE!!!
I could go on and on ... This thread sure proves that horror fans love sequels ... as long as they do them the right way ...