Spent the last few days going through seasons 1-3 of SOA, thus breaking the promise I made to myself after Green Street Hooligans- that is never to watch anything featuring Charlie Hunnam as lead.
While it's definitely no The Shield, it is a good show, and it does have that wanna-see-what-happens-next quality. I think what I like best is the sense of humour, it can be really funny at times (e.g. the Coates/Johnson/German Shepherd reveal killed me). To me the writing is a bit like Garth Ennis, if Ennis had slightly less of an imagination and all he ever did was play Grand Theft Auto and produce a TV show about bike gangs. There are many enjoyable character actors having fun just being those guys and spitting out those ridiculous Sutter lines. I liked Perlman and Coates before, but I don't think I really appreciated them until now- some good laughs, as well as some good meaty dramatic moments from them. Hunnam is tolerable, surprisingly enough. Sutter is actually very effective when on screen, and one of the few who I would actually buy as an actual MC member. And some of the most LOL scenes are whenever the camera cuts to David "Happy" Labrava and he's smiling at horrific torture or asking permission to kill a rival gang member in some violent fashion.
My biggest issues with the show would be the cheap gotcha twists it uses sometimes, and how it basically turned Ally Walker's character into a villain from 24. Another thing for me is that instead of making the outlaw biker lifestyle look cool and badass, often it's just kind of petty and retarded here. If the actors were not so entertaining, to me the gang would just be a bunch of scuzzy pricks who reject mainstream society's rules yet still have their own weird, stupid, nerdy traditions like votes and cuts and patches and "old ladies". I think I like the lone biker archetype in my fiction more.
I do like it though. Season three was worth it just for Perlman's "I don't recognize yer bullshit MC". And for big Jim Cosmo throwing a hysterical Hunnam across the room like a rag doll. And for Mutton Chops unceremoniously shoved off the roof (small yelp of surprise from him... long silence... finally a thud). Anyway, it ended well, so I'm looking forward to tonight. Sad that Perlman won't be able to shout "gash!" so much now that a certain character is gone.