CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE MAIN SEWER › CHUD.COM Main › DOC STRANGE TO REALLY BRING THE COSMIC TO MARVEL FILMS
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

DOC STRANGE TO REALLY BRING THE COSMIC TO MARVEL FILMS - Page 2

post #51 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spike Marshall View Post

Jason Isaacs could be a fun Doctor Strange, if he could curtail his inbuilt malevolence.


If we are going to typecast magicians then I vote for Will Arnett.

 

post #52 of 98

Give Mark Strong a chance to flex his hero muscles for once. Or, y'know, Fassbender. Can't believe Rain Dog hasn't dropped that in yet!

post #53 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Merriweather View Post

Give Mark Strong a chance to flex his hero muscles for once. Or, y'know, Fassbender. Can't believe Rain Dog hasn't dropped that in yet!


I think Rain Dog is DONE with Superhero movies. Fassbender would be quite a decent fit.

 

I think that Doctor Strange, due to not having quite the rabid fanbase of other characters, is actually kind of mallebale in his casting. The sheer breadth of talent listed here shows that there are different facets of the character that everyone views as important.

 

It's a shame that Steven Rattazzi, the voice of Dr. Orpheus in Venture Bros., is so schubbly in real life.

post #54 of 98

Wow, page 2 and not a single Bruce Campbell mention. Someone cue up "Times They Are A-Changin"

post #55 of 98

I wouldn't have pictured Campbell as Strange in his prime.  He was just never a fit for the character.

post #56 of 98
post #57 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by TonyRockyHorror View Post

 

LULZ

 

Because I mention it nearly every time, it's expected, but...

 

Jeffrey "Dr Mordrid" Combs

 

dr-mordrid-03.jpg
 

 

post #58 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Merriweather View Post

Give Mark Strong a chance to flex his hero muscles for once. Or, y'know, Fassbender. Can't believe Rain Dog hasn't dropped that in yet!



I typed it out and deleted it about four times.

 

I hate being so predictable.

 

(buthereallywouldbegreat)

5355135.jpg

 

 



Quote:
Originally Posted by Spike Marshall View Post

I think Rain Dog is DONE with Superhero movies. Fassbender would be quite a decent fit.


Not quite. I'm still keen for Bats and Supes next year and would love to see a decent Wally West Flash movie. Other than that I'd just like to see the genre rested for a bit, I don't really get what more it can say right now - but these are silly artistic and thematic concerns that have no baring on Hollywoods thought process, so I'll just wait for more of them to flop before Hollywood moves on.

 
post #59 of 98

Is that Fassbender or Kevin Kline?

post #60 of 98

Great now I can't stop imaging Fassbender as Otto.

post #61 of 98

Doubting Thomas: RD, that's your solution to everything. To cast Fassbender in every movie. It's not going to happen!
RD: Not with that attitude.

post #62 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by DARKMITE8 View Post

Doubting Thomas: RD, that's your solution to everything. To cast Fassbender in every movie. It's not going to happen!



I will not stop until he is all-encompassing!

 

fassbenderwood-cropped.JPG

post #63 of 98

A site I ran across earlier today had Viggo Mortensen as one of their top choices.  I like the sound of that, but I suspect Marvel is going to skew young on this one.

 

Viggo would make a fun Baron Mordo though!

post #64 of 98

Wayne Coyne was born to play this role

 

images.jpg

post #65 of 98

Henry Ian Cusick's done jack shit since LOST wrapped. Give him a ring.

post #66 of 98



 

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Rain Dog View Post

I will not stop until he is all-encompassing!

 

 

 

Just like with every good actor that everybody loves when the general public doesn't really know who they are, they become overexposed and then a backlash forms. Fassbender's day will come.  
 

 

post #67 of 98

Ooh, love the Henry Ian Cusick idea.

 

If they want someone on the cheap, talented, and up and coming, how about Matt Bomer from White Collar? Not too young, can definitely play the more intelligent aspects of the character. And the ladies love him. Oh do they love him...

post #68 of 98

I'm glad we have finally stopped casting Jon Hamm(who I am not dissing) in everything now.

 

Here's my pick:

 

Jim%20Caviezel%20-%20Count.jpg

post #69 of 98

Caviezel had been my top pick for years but he's lookin' rather bloaty nowadays.

post #70 of 98

Really? I saw a picture of him in that Person of Interest show he's doing, and he looked pretty thin. Maybe bending down over Michael Emerson's shoulder looking at a computer is tricking my eyes?

 

post #71 of 98

 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Walker View Post

Really? I saw a picture of him in that Person of Interest show he's doing, and he looked pretty thin. Maybe bending down over Michael Emerson's shoulder looking at a computer is tricking my eyes?

 


The pic I'm thinking of was in a recent issue of EW & he really didn't look too hot.

post #72 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by Love Machine View Post



Sold on JGL, but can we pleased have a better villian than Mordo. If the Harry Potter movies taught us anything, it's that magic battles are pretty boring things to watch on the big screen.

 

 


Agreed about JGL-- great choice. But I'm OK with Mordo, because frankly the only reason I can see for doing this would be to try and come up with a different approach to magic battles that somehow approximates the disorientation of a classic Ditko story, or maybe some of Brunner's stuff. 

 

I don't know how you'd do that without looking retro/cheesy, but that's not my job.

 

post #73 of 98

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sebastian OB View Post

I heard an industry rumor that the reason Marvel wants to get these second tier characters off the ground is so they can be in future Avengers movies. They know that they won't be able to afford the big names past the first Avengers film, so they want to do one-offs of Dr. Strange and Luke Cage and others to fill in the cast for Avengers sequels.

 

So basically don't hold your breath for a Defenders film; the Avengers will be a rotating cast.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sebastian OB View Post

I'm sure RDJ will be the first to go, but I bet he'd be willing to do a cameo in an Avengers sequel. I imagine Avengers 2 will still likely have Thor and Cap, with Hawkeye and Black Widow taking bigger roles, possibly War Machine filling the robot man part, and adding Dr. Strange and/or Luke Cage.

 

 

This kind of blows my mind if true. Marvel's shown that they really don't care about recasting key parts in their movies -- I mean, they recast Bruce Banner for God's sake. They play casting hardball specifically because they think their characters shouldn't be tied to any one actor. It seems silly to me that they'll ditch that philosophy and just eliminate the chance of, for example, making another Iron Man film or putting Iron Man in an Avengers sequel just because Downey isn't in the role anymore. The same goes for their other heroes -- just get another dude and keep moving forward. It works. I don't think they necessarily have a finite vision for their franchises (within reason).

 

Edit: also of these suggestions I personally like Michael Sheen or Benedict Cumberpatch the best. Patrick Dempsey wants the role apparently -- I think that could sort of work, honestly. He's a little old but I do think Strange should sit around the 35ish Tony Stark range, rather than 25ish like Thor and Cap.

post #74 of 98

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by JMulder View Post

 

Edit: also of these suggestions I personally like Michael Sheen or Benedict Cumberpatch the best. Patrick Dempsey wants the role apparently -- I think that could sort of work, honestly. He's a little old but I do think Strange should sit around the 35ish Tony Stark range, rather than 25ish like Thor and Cap.


I'd actually say no younger than 39-40 for the same reason one shouldn't cast someone over 30 for Spidey. Doc has greying temples & has always been a somewhat more mature, austere Marvel presence. Going younger just brings up bad memories of Ioan Gruffudd/Mr Fantastic. Patrick Dempsey is actually pretty awesome on Grey's..., but as a mystical figure? That's a stretch. I hope he at least auditions.

post #75 of 98

I can dig Dempsey. Kinda hope that one goes through. Either that, or Nicolas Turturro.

 

post #76 of 98

Please not Dempsey.

 

If they went with Downey on Iron Man, they can go with Guy Pearce on Dr. Strange. I am now 800% aboard that idea.

post #77 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMulder View Post


This kind of blows my mind if true. Marvel's shown that they really don't care about recasting key parts in their movies -- I mean, they recast Bruce Banner for God's sake. They play casting hardball specifically because they think their characters shouldn't be tied to any one actor. It seems silly to me that they'll ditch that philosophy and just eliminate the chance of, for example, making another Iron Man film or putting Iron Man in an Avengers sequel just because Downey isn't in the role anymore. The same goes for their other heroes -- just get another dude and keep moving forward. It works. I don't think they necessarily have a finite vision for their franchises (within reason).

 

Edit: also of these suggestions I personally like Michael Sheen or Benedict Cumberpatch the best. Patrick Dempsey wants the role apparently -- I think that could sort of work, honestly. He's a little old but I do think Strange should sit around the 35ish Tony Stark range, rather than 25ish like Thor and Cap.



I have no doubt that Marvel will recast the role of Iron Man once RDJ vacates, but I wouldn't expect for them to do it immediately.  They will likely let the character sit for awhile and focus on other heroes before coming back to him.  Just like they announced they are going to do with Blade now that the rights have returned to them.  Marvel doesn't want Iron Man forever associated with RDJ, but don't think they will be dumb enough to crank out a Downey-less Iron Man IV two years after Iron Man III if Robert leaves the role.  It might do decently, but it would definitely take a big hit due to the lack of his presence.

 

All of these heroes will be recast on down the line when the contracts are up and the actors don't want to continue with the role.  Like I said though, immediate recasts are unlikely.....................especially when Marvel seems intent on jumpstarting enough new franchises (Dr. Strange, Ant-Man, Black Panther, Sub-Mariner, Runaways, Luke Cage, Iron Fist, etc.) that they can just focus on those for awhile and let actor-less roles sleep for a bit.  It's easy to not have Iron Man and Thor sequels on your schedule when you can fill those gaps with other characters for a few years and take your time to properly recast the roles.

 

Hell, if Terrence Howard and Ed Norton hadn't been divas on set and played hardball about sequels, both would still be in their respective roles for future films.

post #78 of 98

 

Just to play devil's advocate.... What's preventing them from casting an Indian, Middle Eastern, Asian or a Spaniard? Can't they be surgeon's too?

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Art Decade View Post
Doc has greying temples & has always been a somewhat more mature, austere Marvel presence.

I know Depp's already poopooed in this thread, but revisiting THE 9TH GATE recently, I can totally see it...

 

161937_179780208717470_8018811_n.jpgninth-gate-800-75.jpg

post #79 of 98

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by S.D. Bob Plissken View Post

I have no doubt that Marvel will recast the role of Iron Man once RDJ vacates, but I wouldn't expect for them to do it immediately.  They will likely let the character sit for awhile and focus on other heroes before coming back to him.  Just like they announced they are going to do with Blade now that the rights have returned to them.  Marvel doesn't want Iron Man forever associated with RDJ, but don't think they will be dumb enough to crank out a Downey-less Iron Man IV two years after Iron Man III if Robert leaves the role.  It might do decently, but it would definitely take a big hit due to the lack of his presence.

 

All of these heroes will be recast on down the line when the contracts are up and the actors don't want to continue with the role.  Like I said though, immediate recasts are unlikely.....................especially when Marvel seems intent on jumpstarting enough new franchises (Dr. Strange, Ant-Man, Black Panther, Sub-Mariner, Runaways, Luke Cage, Iron Fist, etc.) that they can just focus on those for awhile and let actor-less roles sleep for a bit.  It's easy to not have Iron Man and Thor sequels on your schedule when you can fill those gaps with other characters for a few years and take your time to properly recast the roles.

 

Hell, if Terrence Howard and Ed Norton hadn't been divas on set and played hardball about sequels, both would still be in their respective roles for future films.


Yeah true. I can imagine there being a slight grace period where the character rests, just so the public can acclimate to the possibility of a different actor in the part, but still -- nobody's gonna forget that Downey played Stark, and his portrayal is only gonna become more iconic. There'll be the same skepticism surrounding a new face in the role two years after the last Downey IM film as there will be four years after. As for Cap and Thor, those characters are honestly less "definitively played" by Hemsworth and Evans so it actually makes recasting less of an issue, but they'll be playing those roles for at least 6-7 more years anyway. Personally I say they just charge ahead and don't look back, but then again I'm not Kevin Feige.

 

That said, I don't envy our next Tony Stark actor. How that performance could come off as anything other than a Downey imitation is beyond me -- it would take a real fresh perspective on the character to keep it from seeming like a pale counterfeit.

post #80 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by DARKMITE8 View Post

 

Just to play devil's advocate.... What's preventing them from casting an Indian, Middle Eastern, Asian or a Spaniard? 


Institutionalized racism?

post #81 of 98



 

Quote:
Originally Posted by DARKMITE8 View Post

Just to play devil's advocate.... What's preventing them from casting an Indian, Middle Eastern, Asian or a Spaniard? Can't they be surgeon's too?



Won't happen, but this guy jumped immediately in my mind with your suggestion:

 

Alexander_Siddig_001.jpg

 

post #82 of 98

Siddigs one of those guys that if he was in everything, he still wouldn't be in enough. Seriously under-rated actor.

post #83 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by DARKMITE8 View Post

 

Just to play devil's advocate.... What's preventing them from casting an Indian, Middle Eastern, Asian or a Spaniard? Can't they be surgeon's too?


I've got no problem with it.  I've seen Oded Fehr get the fan nod on various sites this week.  They just need to find a good actor willing to take the material seriously and stick with the character for a few films, regardless of nationality.

post #84 of 98

Siddig was also pretty badass in Cairo Time.

 

Out of all the suggestions so far, this guy is the most intriguing IMO.

guy_pearce2.jpg

 

post #85 of 98

Guy Pearce is my new personal favorite for the role.

post #86 of 98

I doubt there will be a new Iron Man, until the inevitable reboot of the entire Marvel Universe, but that probably ain't happening any time soon. First off, Downey won't be going anywhere for a little while, and while I expect Tony Stark to take an extended break after 2013, it will be a great place for Downey to go to reestablish rep as he ages out of leading man roles. But also, with so many pots on the oven, would Marvel need to risk spending so much on the very chancy prospect of recasting Tony Stark?

 

I still like Sean Bean for Strange, which will never happen. But something that might happen and I could see working quite well would be Colin Farrell. Dude was great in the B Leagues of Daredevil, and has been aging into an much more interesting leading man that he started out as. He's attracted to cool charactery roles in auteur projects (In Bruges, Ondine, the Way Back), but also isn't above some populist fare (Fright Night, Total Recall). Men and women both like him, he can rock a goatee, and he's neither too young or too old. And he can do whatever accent you want.

post #87 of 98

Guy Pierce would be the most interesting choice by a long way, I just don't see him signing onto the Marvel multi-contract machine. The guys had quite a few opportunities to take the obvious movie star blockbuster route and he invariably ends up choosing more artistically interesting and challenging films instead.

 

Frankly, I get the feeling Pierce feels he's better than slumming it in a second tier Marvel superhero franchise - and if he does believe that I think he's probably correct.

post #88 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Rain Dog View Post

Frankly, I get the feeling Pierce feels he's better than slumming it in a second tier Marvel superhero franchise - and if he does believe that I think he's probably correct.


 

He better keep that thought to himself.

 

bedtimestoriesadamsandler.jpg
 

 

post #89 of 98

ah fuckit - don't I feel foolish.

post #90 of 98

Don't. That just means you don't watch sorry movies.

 

post #91 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by Walker View Post

Don't. That just means you don't watch sorry movies.

 



Sandler and I parted ways many moons ago tis true.

post #92 of 98

Pearce also slagged off superhero movies during the period where he was rumored for The Dark Knight as Dent. But, again, actors gotta eat. I don't think Pearce would look down on a superhero movie - it's those pesky five, six or seven-film contracts that would be problematic.

 

Still, Lockout and Prometheus coming out next year... guy's gonna be big again. Marvel, DO IT.

post #93 of 98

Its really the multi-contract issue I wouldn't see Pearce going for. Guys not hard up for work (or cash I'm guessing) and he's never been that drawn to the big budget stuff as a rule - I certainly don't see him locking himself into a Marvel franchise for 7-8 pictures. He doesn't need it, guys paid his dues and then some.

 

Shit, it's only just occurred to me I'm going to see Pearce and Fassbender bouncing off each other onscreen next year. God damn that'll be a masterclass in intensity.

post #94 of 98

Siddig being mentioned for Dr. Strange made my ears prick up like a dog's. And if I had a tail I'd be wagging it. It would be perfect. 

post #95 of 98
Quote:
Originally Posted by stelios View Post

Siddig being mentioned for Dr. Strange made my ears prick up like a dog's. And if I had a tail I'd be wagging it. It would be perfect. 



He'd rock my world but no way would Marvel cast an actor of his vintage.

post #96 of 98

Judging from this thread my favorites are easily Pearce, Caviezel or Siddig. All fine choices.

 

Make the smart play Marvel.

post #97 of 98

The Rain Dog, Alexander Siddig, was great in...Star Trek Deep Space Nine.  In that role, some people may feel he already played a...Strange Doctor!

post #98 of 98

I'm still expecting it to go to someone up-and-coming, like Oscar Isaac.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: CHUD.COM Main
CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE MAIN SEWER › CHUD.COM Main › DOC STRANGE TO REALLY BRING THE COSMIC TO MARVEL FILMS