Ya know, after watching Cuckoo's Nest recently I was struck how overblown the common "Nurse Ratched is evil" thinking seems to be. Cold? Sure, but I think she's incredibly fragile & her stark rigidity is actually the defense mechanism of a woman who holds the thankless responsibility of providing daily stability to an entire ward of individuals with various mental diseases. Remember, the film takes place at a time when drugs that actually treated the brain's illnesses rather than the symptoms simply didn't exist. There was only a) Narcotic tranquilizers, b) Electro-shock therapy, c) Lobotomy, & d) A stable, carefully controlled environment where people could neither harm themselves or others. Option D was the closest thing to a panacea that existed.
McMurphy wants to change the channel? Fuck HIM. Those 5 underpaid state mental health workers are doing everything they can to keep those few dozen patients from becoming agitated. Why? Because that's the best weapon against mental illness they have.
"But what about Billy at the end? Ratched killed him!"
No. What we see is a lonely, miserable woman who'd spent years doing the best she humanly could to provide a safe, stable environment crumble & lash out at the nearest, weakest target after surveying the wreckage of her ward & realizing that these people don't give a SHIT about her or her daily, excruciating efforts. She's not malicious by nature, she's achingly human & gave way to a singular moment of malice when beaten down.
I'm all for the film being a martyr-centric metaphor but let's have some informed perspective on Ratched & her role here: In Cuckoo's Nest, Nurse Ratched is the "antagonist", not the "Anti-Christ".
I guess my point is that I don't believe the film belongs on this list, particularly if Nurse Ratched is the reason it was chosen. But of course, historically speaking, I'm sure that I'm in the vast minority with this opinion. It's just that this "Nurse Ratched is EVIL!" thing bugs the living hell outta me.
Edited by Art Decade - 9/25/11 at 8:40pm