Chewers of Chud:
I come to you with a renting conundrum, and your timely assistance would be greatly appreciated

I live on the top floor of a three story Victorian house. The bottom two floors are taken up with ethnic Bosnians. I am a private person, and try not to interact with my neighbors much. I came from a house where I was all on my own, and so it kind of freaks me out to have other people living and moving around one level down. I said hello to them once, and mentioned that "I'm sure we'll see each other around!", and then promptly did everything I could to avoid ever talking to them again
When I first moved in, I noticed that in certain rooms, I could hear muffled conversations through the floor. It kind of freaked me out. As a consequence, I avoid ever playing music or watching videos on my iPad from my bedroom past a certain hour (where the floor seems thinnest). My TV is in the living room, and 99% of the time, no sound ever comes out of it since I watch stuff with my V-MODA CROSSFADE LP over ear headphones on
Sometimes, if I'm eating dinner, depending on the hour I'll turn on the TV sound at either a low level or a very low level, but I never leave it on for more than 20 minutes before plugging my headphones back in
Now, with that basic info out of the way, I'll get to the heart of the matter: I'm a night owl. A late night owl
I'm trying to change this and adapt my ways to live life at better hours, but it's hard when I've been living a nocturnal existence for years on end. I'll play games at night, or watch movies, and this involves walking around at times. I try my best to pad about as silently as possible without literally tip toeing (I don't walk flat footed, I keep my heels up)
While I'm often working, napping or sedentary during the day, it's at night that I tend to cook myself dinner. This is because it usually takes me a long time to work up an appetite to eat. When I do cook late, I try and do my best to avoid clattering dishes, ETC, and then I always leave my dishes to clean up the next day. Sometimes I'll put on low volume chill out music while I cook, but not loud enough that it could be heard from any room other than the kitchen, or often even above the sound of food cooking
Now, before I continue, some key facts:
1) My neighbors also keep odd hours
They seem to regularly exit (or perhaps come home) at 2 30 AM, and then I hear people leave at other times too. I hear them talking, and moving about late at night. They march up and down the stairs of the vestibule (which my front door opens onto) and slamming the door to their apartment and then the door to the outside
It is worth noting that if I were keeping normal hours, this could potentially wake me up
2) My neighbors fight
I've heard them fighting with each other, and earlier this week, around 3 AM or so, there was prolonged shouting followed by what I believe was a sobbing fit
3) My neighbors are in violation of the lease, by way of cat ownership
Apparently the previous tenant in my apartment was friendly with the beast, and it would come up to visit her. I politely declined such visits when they mentioned the situation with the cat, and otherwise have kept my mouth shut. With that said, their cat reeks with a choking stench that stinks up our shared stairwell. There have been times where it's literally caused me to gag walking past their door up to my apartment. It's gotten slightly better in recent weeks (no clue why), but the carpets in our shared stairway are covered in hair, and sometimes the cat will spring out at me from the second landing when I am going home at night, scaring the beejeesus out of me. My mom has mentioned that we could complain to the landlord, but my philosophy is to "not make waves", and so I light scented candles near my door to keep out the odor of their illegal pet
The point is though, if I wanted, I could either force them to leave, or force their cat to leave
So, with that in mind, I do sometimes make noise at night. Last evening this involved cooking dinner from 3-4 AM (again, as quietly as possible, with a minimum of clatter), and then putting GANGS OF NEW YORK on at an extremely low volume while I ate my dinner
I also dropped a controller on the floor around 3, which I'll note just for the purposes of fairness. Sometimes I'm clumsy.. What can I say? I'm human
Anyway, when I finished my dinner I turned off the TV, and proceeded to gently slide a little squat table I use for food away from the front of my chair off to the side, so I could extend my recliner and return to reading
That's when my downstairs neighbors began to pound, with violent force, on their ceiling/my floor (right under my chair). They pounded like eight or nine times, hard enough to shake the floor, and certainly MUCH louder than any noise I was making. I heard the downstairs guy's wife plead "Stop it!", which I am 90% certain was in reference to the angry pounding
After that I was pretty freaked out and didn't move for a while. What I did do was google this problem, to see what the general public opinion was on how to proceed. I read opinions both from people with noisy neighbor problems, and people with "angry ceiling pounding neighbor" problems. I read several sources, and the general opinion was that you shouldn't be excessively noisy late at night, but that also if someone has a problem, they should knock on your door, or wait till the next morning and write you a letter. Pounding shouldn't be the first step
Now.. I don't want to cause anyone any problems... but I *am* a night person. I'm of the opinion that I have a right to be moving around my apartment and doing stuff, regardless of the time of day. I'm utterly silent the great majority of the time, and if I happen to eat dinner late? That's just how I roll. I'm working to eat earlier, but it's taking effort
What if I worked a job that meant my only free time was at night? That's not the case, but the crazy hours I do work often result in my sleep schedule getting out of wack. Am I not allowed to live my life just because I happen to live it at certain times of day that bother them? Again, they're up late too, and if I went to sleep early, their late night stuff would potentially be waking *me* up. And again, they're in violation with the cat
I'm not unsympathetic, but I don't also feel that I'm totally in the wrong
Now, already, I've come up with a plan in three parts and typed it out on my iPad:
1) "No music after 12 without headphones, for any reason"
2) "No TV after 12 without headphones, for any reason"
3) "Take care.. beware", a rule inspired by Bella in ED WOOD, which essentially means try and not make noise if possible
But with those rules having been stated, I'm not willing to say that I'm never going to cook late at night, or life my life at the hours best for me
I checked my mail box this morning, and my door, and there was no note or letter from them
I don't intend to follow up on the banging, and will simply abide by the three edicts for late night behavior I've set down for myself. Hopefully that'll do the trick
With all that said, I'd like to hear some Chewers weigh in on this situation, who is right, who is wrong, and how best to proceed
Edited by Princess Kate - 11/1/11 at 4:27pm