For every Planet Earth or Lord of the Rings EE, there are several Blu-Rays that have disappointing transfers, a dearth of extras, or both. How about a thread that warns folks about some of the shoddier Blu-Rays on the market?
For example: Goodfellas. Be sure to get the 20th Anniversary Edition, which at least appears to have a ton of extras. I got this bare bones edition that had hardly any extras and a disappointing, muddy transfer.
I also recently bought Universal's release of Traffic, not realizing that Criterion was going to release one a couple of months later. It appears that the transfers are comparable, but the Criterion's set of extras is amazing and worth the higher price.
What are some of yours?