Quote:
Originally Posted by
Farsight 
As noted, Andrea didn't leave the fights. And she complained about them trivializing the zombies, not about barbarism, etc.
On Andrea smiling, yeah. I'm not impressed with that actress. She plays Andrea as alternately smirking and gutpunched. The Governor's blowing her off the screen.
The kid was cowardly until Michonne killed his two friends, then he wanted revenge.
No argument on Rick's phone call. I don't care that it's from the comic book; it's dumb to include it, especially when your version of Rick and Lori never seemed particularly in love.
We don't know how coherent Carol was, but screaming out when zombies are around isn't always a good idea.
Maggie and Glen are used to killing zombies. Shooting living people is really beyond their level of instinct.
Andrea was clearly disturbed by the fights. She was repulsed, indicated by her body language the look on her face and in what she said. The next day she admits she liked them. That's an instantaneous flip flop that makes zero sense.
The kid was cowardly AFTER Michonne killed his friends. He didn't want to go on until Merle forced him to. After Michonne comes back and the walkers attack in the middle of her attack, she escapes again. Then Merle is happy to leave, which is exactly what the kid wanted to do minutes earlier...but suddenly the kid wants to go after her deep into the red zone of zombies. No, doesn't make sense at all. Another instantaneous flip flop.
Daryl and the others had been in the hallway talking and there were no zombies present...they were literally right next to the room Carol was in. Unless she believes zombies now speak english, it makes no sense for her to just sit there and say nothing. When Daryl opened the door, she was clearly awake and didn't have her throat ripped out, so what was stopping her from calling out?
The Maggie Glen thing is even worse upon closer inspection. They love each other. Glen especially knows how dangerous Merle is. Maggie sees he has a knife for a hand and a moment ago had a gun on them. Both Maggie and Glen has every reason to hair trigger that situation, their loved ones life was at stake...yet as soon as Merle makes a move they dive out of the way. Shooting a zombie is no different than shooting a human, they're both targets made of meat, with similar size and shape. How is shooting a person "beyond their level of instinct"? You have a gun on somebody, all it takes is a trigger squeeze, especially if they're a threat to a loved one.
Now these are things I could've ignored if they weren't all piled into one episode. Separately they're sort of forgiveable.