Based on the wtf! thread it looks like people are starting to wrap up Season 1, so I figured it would be interesting to have a full spoiler thread to discuss the choices people made and their full impressions of the game. However, so as not to alienate those who haven't finished, I thought we could go episode by episode, with a clear marker when we bring the next one into the discussion. With that in mind:
EPISODE 1 SPOILERS AHOY!
So, Doug or Carley? I ended up in the large minority on this one by going with Doug, which I suspect stems from the fact that Carley is much more involved in the story up until that point and has the more developed personality. My reasoning however was that of the two, she was much more likely to be able to save herself, especially since if I remember correctly she was just being grabbed by the ankle. The first of what would be many blown calls, the Walking Dead specialty. Also a hint at how the game was much more streamlined than its choices initially success, something which to its credit isn't obvious until much later and even then doesn't really detract from the overall experience.
So, anyone else got thoughts on Episode 1?