CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE CHEWERS › Drafts & Lists › TV DRAMA KNOCKOUT
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

TV DRAMA KNOCKOUT

post #1 of 630
Thread Starter 

39 shows enter.  39 shows leave, in an order vaguely corresponding with their respective qualities.

 

Standard Rules.  Add one point, take one away.  You can vote 3 times in a day, but not consecutively.  Once a show reaches 0 points, it goes to syndication with the appropriate rank.

 

Note:  this is noticeably weighted toward HBO, because they beat a lot of other networks to the punch in terms of churning out quality programming, and I'm restricting this to shows that have completed their runs.  The exceptions being  Mad Men and Breaking Bad, which have 5+ years and handily secured their places in the pantheon.  Feel free to criticize this as silly and arbitrary, as it is certainly both.

 

 

+1 Deadwood, -1 TNG

 

24  - 3

Angel - 3

Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3

Battlestar Galactica - 3

Breaking Bad - 3

Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 3

Carnivale - 3

Deadwood - 4

Dexter - 3

Dr. Who - 3

Firefly - 3

Freaks And Geeks - 3

Friday Night Lights - 3

I, Claudius - 3

LOST - 3

Luther - 3

Luck - 3

Mad Men - 3

My So-Called Life - 3

Oz  - 3

The Prisoner - 3

Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 3

Rome - 3

The Sopranos - 3

Shameless - 3

The Shield - 3

Six Feet Under - 3

Spartacus - 3

Star Trek - 3

Star Trek: TNG - 2

Supernatural - 3

The Twilight Zone - 3

Twin Peaks - 3

The West Wing - 3

The Wire - 3

Veronica Mars - 3

The X-Files - 3


Edited by Schwartz - 8/28/13 at 12:12pm
post #2 of 630

+1 - The Wire

 

Idris Elba is amazing, and just one of the great elements of this remarkable show.

 

-1 - Luther

 

Idris Elba is amazing, and the only great element of this mediocre show.

post #3 of 630

NOOJ Wed #1

 

+1 Friday Night Lights

-1  Dexter

 

Also incorporating Mangy's Elba combo

___________________________________________________________________________

24  - 3

Angel - 3

Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3

Battlestar Galactica - 3

Breaking Bad - 3

Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 3

Carnivale - 3

Deadwood - 4

Dexter - 2

Dr. Who - 3

Firefly - 3

Freaks And Geeks - 3

Friday Night Lights - 4

I, Claudius - 3

LOST - 3

Luther - 2

Luck - 3

Mad Men - 3

My So-Called Life - 3

Oz  - 3

The Prisoner - 3

Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 3

Rome - 3

The Sopranos - 3

Shameless - 3

The Shield - 3

Six Feet Under - 3

Spartacus - 3

Star Trek - 3

Star Trek: TNG - 2

Supernatural - 3

The Twilight Zone - 3

Twin Peaks - 3

The West Wing - 3

The Wire - 4

Veronica Mars - 3

The X-Files - 3

post #4 of 630
Thread Starter 

The next person input Mangy's points for him, since he is such a lazy sumbitch (with exquisite taste).

post #5 of 630

+1 THE PRISONER

-1 MY SO CALLED LIFE

 

edited to include Mangy's selections

 

24  - 3

Angel - 3

Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3

Battlestar Galactica - 3

Breaking Bad - 3

Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 3

Carnivale - 3

Deadwood - 4

Dexter - 2

Dr. Who - 3

Firefly - 3

Freaks And Geeks - 3

Friday Night Lights - 4

I, Claudius - 3

LOST - 3

Luther - 2

Luck - 3

Mad Men - 3

My So-Called Life - 2

Oz  - 3

The Prisoner - 4

Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 3

Rome - 3

The Sopranos - 3

Shameless - 3

The Shield - 3

Six Feet Under - 3

Spartacus - 3

Star Trek - 3

Star Trek: TNG - 2

Supernatural - 3

The Twilight Zone - 3

Twin Peaks - 3

The West Wing - 3

The Wire - 4

Veronica Mars - 3

The X-Files - 3

post #6 of 630
Wed.#1

+1 Battlestar Galactica
-1 Dexter (had only one great season)

24 - 3
Angel - 3
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 3
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dexter - 1
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 3
Freaks And Geeks - 3
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 3
LOST - 3
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 3
My So-Called Life - 2
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 3
Rome - 3
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 3
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 2
Supernatural - 3
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3
post #7 of 630

numbers are off again.  THE PRISONER should be at 4.

post #8 of 630

EVERYBODY FOLLOW ME!!!

post #9 of 630
Corrected.
post #10 of 630

I'm going to ride Spartacus for all it's worth.

+1 Spartacus

-1 Supernatural

 

24 - 3
Angel - 3
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 3
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dexter - 1
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 3
Freaks And Geeks - 3
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 3
LOST - 3
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 3
My So-Called Life - 2
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 3
Rome - 3
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 2
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

post #11 of 630

Dammit, sorry guys. My first contribution to one of these knockouts and I screw it all up. Bah. Here's my 2nd vote for the day (EDIT: using Cooper's numbers above):

 

+1 Mad Men
-1 Dexter (the last 3-4 seasons have been garbage)

24 - 3
Angel - 3
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 3
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dexter - 0
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 3
Freaks And Geeks - 3
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 3
LOST - 3
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
My So-Called Life - 2
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 3
Rome - 3
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 2
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

post #12 of 630

This is going to be a murderer's row. I'll let someone else be the one to bring the axe down on Dexter. Pushing Daisies was just a little too cutesy for my tastes.

 

Edit: AAH, it's moving so fast

 

+1 Buffy

-1 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me

 

24 - 3
Angel - 3
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 4
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 3
Freaks And Geeks - 3
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 3
LOST - 3
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
My So-Called Life - 2
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 3
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 3
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 2
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

 

Killed off:

 

39. Dexter

post #13 of 630

As a reminder: once you post, look to ensure that nobody else posted at the same time.  If they did and they beat you to the punch, do an edit on your post to include their numbers.

post #14 of 630

Numbers are totally fucked now.

post #15 of 630
Thread Starter 

Fixed, I think.

 

Note:  there will be 37 ranks, as there are two combined entries.

 

Wed. #2

 

+1 Buffy The Vampire Slayer, -1 TNG

 

24 - 3
Angel - 3
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 3
Freaks And Geeks - 3
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 3
LOST - 3
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
My So-Called Life - 2
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 3
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

 

 

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

 

37.  Dexter

post #16 of 630

Hmm.  My first vote of the day, and my first run around with a knockout on CHUD.

 

 

+1 Freaks and Geeks (ended far too early), -1 Lost (will never accept the final season)

 

 

24 - 3
Angel - 3
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 3
Freaks And Geeks - 4

Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 3
LOST - 2

Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
My So-Called Life - 2
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 3
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

post #17 of 630

+1 Angel

-1 24

 

Sorry 24. You're fun enough, but these are the big boys you're playing with.

 

24 - 2
Angel - 4
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 3
Freaks And Geeks - 4

Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 3
LOST - 2

Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
My So-Called Life - 2
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 3
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

 

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

 

37.  Dexter

post #18 of 630

Suggestion: I think it's easier to read to have the number in front of the title.  You have two columns that way, and it's easier to scan the list and see the point values associated with the titles.

post #19 of 630
#2

+1 Firefly
-1 Rome

24 - 2
Angel - 4
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 4
Freaks And Geeks - 4
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 3
LOST - 2
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
My So-Called Life - 2
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 2
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

37. Dexter
post #20 of 630

+1 I, CLAUDIUS

-1 MY SO CALLED LIFE

 

24 - 2
Angel - 4
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 4
Freaks And Geeks - 4
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 4
LOST - 2
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
My So-Called Life - 1
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 2
The Sopranos - 3
Shameless - 3
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

37. Dexter

post #21 of 630
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Judas Booth View Post

Suggestion: I think it's easier to read to have the number in front of the title.  You have two columns that way, and it's easier to scan the list and see the point values associated with the titles.

 

If anyone wants to flip them, it's not going to put me out.

post #22 of 630

Wed. #3, final vote of the day for me:

 

+1 The Sopranos 

-1 Shameless (Emmy Rossum is fantastic, but an all-time show? No)

 

24 - 2
Angel - 4
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 4
Freaks And Geeks - 4
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 4
LOST - 2
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
My So-Called Life - 1
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 4
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 2
The Sopranos - 4
Shameless - 2
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

37. Dexter

post #23 of 630

If everyone agrees, I'll go ahead and flip the numbers later on.

 

In the meantime:

+1 THE PRISONER

-1 MY SO CALLED LIFE

 

24 - 2
Angel - 4
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 4
Freaks And Geeks - 4
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 4
LOST - 2
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 5
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 2
The Sopranos - 4
Shameless - 2
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 4
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION


36. My So-Called Life 
37. Dexter

post #24 of 630

2nd Wednesday vote.

 

+1 Spartacus

-1 24

 

24 - 1
Angel - 4
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 3
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 4
Freaks And Geeks - 4
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 4
LOST - 2
Luther - 2
Luck - 3
Mad Men - 4
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 5
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 2
The Sopranos - 4
Shameless - 2
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 5
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION


36. My So-Called Life 
37. Dexter

post #25 of 630

Well, this will get ugly.  

 

First vote for the day

 

+1  BAND OF BROTHERS

-1   LUCK  (A.K.A GOODBYE HORSES)

 

24 - 1
Angel - 4
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 4
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 4
Freaks And Geeks - 4
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 4
LOST - 2
Luther - 2
Luck - 2
Mad Men - 4
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 5
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 2
The Sopranos - 4
Shameless - 2
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 5
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION


36. My So-Called Life 
37. Dexter

post #26 of 630
Thread Starter 

Final vote of the day for me.

 

+1 Sopranos, for being a despairing but blackly funny look at how ugly American culture was becoming around the turn of the millenium

-1 24, for being a fist-pumping celebration of how ugly American culture was becoming after the turn of the millenium

 


Angel - 4
Band of Brothers/The Pacific - 4
Battlestar Galactica - 4
Breaking Bad - 3
Buffy The Vampire Slayer - 5
Carnivale - 3
Deadwood - 4
Dr. Who - 3
Firefly - 4
Freaks And Geeks - 4
Friday Night Lights - 4
I, Claudius - 4
LOST - 2
Luther - 2
Luck - 2
Mad Men - 4
Oz - 3
The Prisoner - 5
Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me - 2
Rome - 2
The Sopranos - 5
Shameless - 2
The Shield - 3
Six Feet Under - 3
Spartacus - 5
Star Trek - 3
Star Trek: TNG - 1
Supernatural - 2
The Twilight Zone - 3
Twin Peaks - 3
The West Wing - 3
The Wire - 4
Veronica Mars - 3
The X-Files - 3

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

 

35. 24
36. My So-Called Life 
37. Dexter

post #27 of 630

+1 Breaking Bad - The best show on TV right now

-1 Supernatural - I love it to death, but it's not the same caliber as the big boys.

 

4 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
3 Dr. Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
4 I, Claudius
2 LOST
2 Luther
2 Luck
4 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
5 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
3 Six Feet Under
5 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
1 Star Trek: TNG
1 Supernatural
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
3 The X-Files

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

 

35. 24
36. My So-Called Life 
37. Dexter


Edited by SomethingClever - 8/28/13 at 1:50pm
post #28 of 630
Thread Starter 

SomethingClever tried to sneak a point back to Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me!   Throw stuff at him!

post #29 of 630

It was all a clever ploy, seeing as I was the one who took the point away in the first place.

 

We're back on track though. I double-checked, and we're at 111 total points, as we should be.

post #30 of 630

Second vote

 

+1  ANGEL

-1   LUCK

 

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
3 Dr. Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
4 I, Claudius
2 LOST
2 Luther
1 Luck
4 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
5 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
3 Six Feet Under
5 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
1 Star Trek: TNG
1 Supernatural
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
3 The X-Files

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

 

35. 24
36. My So-Called Life 
37. Dexter

post #31 of 630

Wednesday #1

 

+1 Doctor Who - For its sheer longevity, ability to recreate itself, and enduring popularity.  Not expecting it to compete with this list, but it deserves at least one upvote.

-1 X-Files - Too often got lost in its own mythology for its own good.  Fringe came along and did it better. 

 

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
4 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
4 I, Claudius
2 LOST
2 Luther
1 Luck
4 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
5 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
3 Six Feet Under
5 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
1 Star Trek: TNG
1 Supernatural
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

 

35. 24
36. My So-Called Life 
37. Dexter


Edited by Richard Dickson - 8/28/13 at 2:18pm
post #32 of 630
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by SomethingClever View Post

It was all a clever ploy, seeing as I was the one who took the point away in the first place.

 

We're back on track though. I double-checked, and we're at 111 total points, as we should be.

 

 

I'd say you should be ashamed of yourself, but we're on track to have Spartacus handily finish the day over The Wire, The Twilight Zone, X-Files....

post #33 of 630

Eh, people are just jockeying for position so that their lower-tier favorites don't get knocked out early. I don't think there's any doubt that The Wire is going to be around for the long haul.

 

Also, check your numbers Dickson, I think you gave Who 2 points instead of 1.

post #34 of 630
Take Luck out to the glue factory!

+1 Battlestar Galactica
-1 Luck

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
5 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
5 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
4 I, Claudius
2 LOST
2 Luther
4 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
5 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
3 Six Feet Under
5 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
1 Star Trek: TNG
1 Supernatural
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter
post #35 of 630
Quote:
Originally Posted by SomethingClever View Post

Also, check your numbers Dickson, I think you gave Who 2 points instead of 1.

 

I was actually keeping with the theme and pulling from tomorrow's list when it will have 5 votes.

post #36 of 630

touche

post #37 of 630

Wednesday 1:

Mad Men +1

Supernatural -1

 

 

 

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
5 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
4 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
4 I, Claudius
2 LOST
2 Luther
5 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
5 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
3 Six Feet Under
5 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
1 Star Trek: TNG
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

33. Supernatural
34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter

post #38 of 630

Last vote today

 

Battle of the Stewarts!

 

+1  I, CLAUDIUS

-1  STAR TREK: TNG

 

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
5 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
4 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
5 I, Claudius
2 LOST
2 Luther
5 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
5 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
3 Six Feet Under
5 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

Did Not Make It So:

32. Star Trek: TNG

33. Supernatural
34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter

post #39 of 630

Final vote for the day.

 

+1 Spartacus

-1 Lost

 

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
5 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
4 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
5 I, Claudius
1 LOST
2 Luther
5 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
5 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
3 Six Feet Under
6 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

Did Not Make It So:

32. Star Trek: TNG

33. Supernatural
34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter

post #40 of 630

I almost feel bad for Lost. The greatest show I never want to see again.

post #41 of 630
Oh its okay now you don't have to feel bad for that show. Lost gets swallowed up by the smoke monster!

+1 Six Feet Under
-1 Lost

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
5 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
5 I, Claudius
2 Luther
5 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
5 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
4 Six Feet Under
6 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

31. Lost
32. Star Trek: TNG
33. Supernatural
34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter
post #42 of 630

Rome +1

 

Sopranos -1

 


+1 Six Feet Under
-1 Lost

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
5 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
4 I, Claudius
2 Luther
4 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
3 Rome
4 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
4 Six Feet Under
6 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter

post #43 of 630
Thread Starter 

You should check your numbers, Kayla.  You're missing several from the "Left The Fuzzy Afterlife For Another, Fuzzier, Church-ier Afterlife" section.

post #44 of 630

Harford's post is a little confusing since he copied the +1 and -1 from Kayla's post and then added his own, and we also lost a point from Mad Men and I, Claudius. Just so that the most current post is correct, here's where we stand:


5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
5 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
5 I, Claudius
2 Luther
5 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
3 Rome
4 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
4 Six Feet Under
6 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

 

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

31. Lost
32. Star Trek: TNG
33. Supernatural
34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter

post #45 of 630
Wednesday #3

+1 Six Feet Under
-1 Rome

5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
5 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
5 I, Claudius
2 Luther
5 Mad Men
3 Oz
5 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
4 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
5 Six Feet Under
6 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files

FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION

31. Lost
32. Star Trek: TNG
33. Supernatural
34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter
post #46 of 630
TNG is gone before Spartacus?
post #47 of 630
I think Picard needs to have a word with Geordi.
post #48 of 630
+1 The Prisoner
-1 Spartacus
 
 
5 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
5 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
5 I, Claudius
2 Luther
5 Mad Men
3 Oz
6 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
4 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
5 Six Feet Under
5 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files
 
FEASTING IN THE HALLS OF SYNDICATION
 
31. Lost
32. Star Trek: TNG
33. Supernatural
34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter
post #49 of 630
+1 The Prisoner
-1 Angel
 
 
4 Angel
4 Band of Brothers/The Pacific
4 Battlestar Galactica
4 Breaking Bad
5 Buffy The Vampire Slayer
3 Carnivale
4 Deadwood
5 Doctor Who
4 Firefly
4 Freaks And Geeks
4 Friday Night Lights
5 I, Claudius
2 Luther
5 Mad Men
3 Oz
7 The Prisoner
2 Pushing Daisies/Dead Like Me
2 Rome
4 The Sopranos
2 Shameless
3 The Shield
5 Six Feet Under
5 Spartacus
3 Star Trek
3 The Twilight Zone
3 Twin Peaks
3 The West Wing
4 The Wire
3 Veronica Mars
2 The X-Files
 
NICK AT NOT:
 
31. Lost
32. Star Trek: TNG
33. Supernatural
34. Luck
35. 24
36. My So-Called Life
37. Dexter
post #50 of 630
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Harford View Post

TNG is gone before Spartacus?

 

Apparently the only person who cares enough about Spartacus to vote for it likes it.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Drafts & Lists
CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE CHEWERS › Drafts & Lists › TV DRAMA KNOCKOUT