Quote:
Southern Belle de Jour:
Why does it seem like every short student film I've ever seen is about suicide? I helped project for this Wednesday night screening series at Columbia College, screening student films...and they were all HORRIBLE and ridiculously melodramatic...and for some reason they are usually about suicide. It's pathetic. |
Quote:
Floydian Trip
SOuthern Belle isn't that a sign of the times? Aren't most youths these days all depressed and angst filled, pill popping, masochists? |
Not sure if this was aimed at my earlier post about the films I have done, but I'll give my opinion anyway.
I don't consider a short film about suicide to be pathetic any more than I would consider a Shakespeare tragedy to be pathetic. Suicide is a pretty important topic in my opinion. I am sure that many filmmakers don't carry it out right, it is a tragedy and should be treated serious, and not just be a showcase for the melodramatic.
And in responce to Floydian Trip, I don't think that acuratlly describes everyone who makes shorts about suicide. I am not angst filled, I don't pop pills and I am not a masochist. I do admit to being a person who suffers from mild depression though.
I got the idea for my suicide film (entitled Happy Holidays) when I was shopping at Wal Mart. I saw happy people everywhere and at the time was single (which is pretty shitty during the Holidays). I saw an old man sitting alone on a bench in Wal Mart. He looked sad, completely alone and ignored by everyone. My first thought was "what if that is me in 30 years?" I came home and wrote the screenplay for the short. It involves a man shopping at Wal Mart during Christmas, seeing all the happy people and then going home to kill himself.
I shot the short a year later, during the Christmas season, and got permission to shoot inside Wal Mart. It is a completely silent film with only Christmas music playing over the tracks. I guess, it is the thought that Holiday Depression is a pretty tough thing for people who are alone and it is kind of a message film about that type of depression.
A final note, at the end of my film, the gun jams and he lives. Cut to a title card with the definition of Holiday Depression and a more upbeat Christmas song.
I guess, I went on here because I think it is unfair to judge a student filmmaker based solely on the type of film they are making without knowing why they made this type of film.
I just felt the need to get this off my chest.