Quote:
Originally posted by MoNkaholic There were eleven teams in the East vying for the playoffs this season in the final week, that simply was not the case last season.
Anyway, to get back to the tangent we originally went off on... You say: "why are his teams better off without him?"
I say Phoenix, and suddenly I can't use them because they break some made up rules of yours? hrmmm...
I ask how could the Timberwolves have gotten better if they never went any further in the postseason, no response.
The only team I could think of, were the Nets, and they already had significant reasons for improving regardless of who the point gaurd was... let alone the fact that Jason Kidd was (and still is so long as he's healthy) the better point gaurd. |
Well, okay, as far as eleven teams, I wouldn't use the term "vying" for anything. Hell, they were stumbling all over the place, the majority of them with 30 something wins. The Celtics traded everyone away, sabotaged their season and STILL accidently made the playoffs. Yes, the East is so bad that a team tried to tank it for the lottery and FAILED.
As far as the "made up" Phoenix rule, how could Phoenix get better by making a trade simply to clear up cap space? The team wasn't even intending to get better in the short term, therefore it's kinda difficult to say they are either worse or better off without him. It may be too early to say. Regardless, it's like saying the Bucks were better off without Sam Cassell and Gary Payton, even though Payton was lost to free agency and Cassell was dealt for... well, shoot, I don't remember.
As for the Timberwolves, I think the difference in their play was negligible once Marbury left. Hard to say there was any difference there, but they weren't exactly world beaters there with Marbury as opposed to the following seasons' alternatives, which I believe consisted of the likes of Chauncey Billups and Troy Hudson.
And even with the "healthy" angle, I think Marbury was in NJ long enough (three/two years?) to be able to at least make that team somewhat better, something that didn't happen. Sure, there was the initial excitement of his arrival, but after that, his body language, his unhappiness and his refusal to push the ball upcourt hurt his teammates and they grew stagnant.
Marbury hasn't played for a true winner, and I can't see that ever changing. He is one of the five most talented players in the league, but he's not even one of the twenty BEST.