CHUD.com Community › Forums › SPECIFIC FILMS › Films in Release or On Video › Treasure of the Sierra Madre!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Treasure of the Sierra Madre!

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
http://imdb.com/title/tt0040897/

Just picked up the new special edition DVD of this classic. I haven't gotten into the special features yet, but I did want to put a plug in for this classic. IMHO it's Bogart's best. A lot of folks rank "The African Queen" and "The Maltese Falcon" ahead of "Treasure of the Sierra Madre," but I feel this gem shows off Bogart's acting chops better than the others. In "Falcon" he's the stable straight man of the film, always cool. In "African Queen" his character warms up over the course of the film, but still remains fundamentally the same. In "Treasure," however, Bogart gives us a detailed view of a man slowly coming apart at the seams. Fred Dobbs isn't an evil character. Like any man he has his good and bad elements. But the bad parts slowly consume his soul as his wealth grows.

Along the way we're treated to an outstanding supporting cast. Walter Huston as the old goat Howard. Wise enough to know his own flaws. Tim Holt as Dobb's friend slowly grows in strength while Dobbs sinks deeper into paranoia and madness. In a critical scene, Holt realizes he was about to kill an innocent man. We see the pang in his eyes after the deed is done by bandits. He realizes he wasn't much different from the bandits. Dobbs has no such insight. All this is done with voice and facial expresses. Very subtle, but very effective.


The action is also very well done, with some memorable shootouts and fights.

A must-see.
post #2 of 7
It's not even worth bringing up The Maltese Falcon when talking about Tresure of The Sierra Madre if you ask me; Treasure is a great film, while Maltese is pretty good.

If you're a Bogart fan and haven't seen The Big Sleep you should.
post #3 of 7
All good films, two other favourite Bogeys are The Big Sleep (love the atmosphere) and Key Largo (probably more down to Ed G Robinson than Bogey).

African Queen I could never stand. The dynamic between Bogart and Hepburn was so off-key to me, and the ending pretty bad.
post #4 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by El Topo
All good films, two other favourite Bogeys are The Big Sleep (love the atmosphere) and Key Largo (probably more down to Ed G Robinson than Bogey).

African Queen I could never stand. The dynamic between Bogart and Hepburn was so off-key to me, and the ending pretty bad.
African Queen is a shameful movie and to think, the AFI had it in the Top 20 of All-Time.
post #5 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lady Snowblood
African Queen is a shameful movie and to think, the AFI had it in the Top 20 of All-Time.
Top 20? I'll have some of what they were smoking...

Clint Eastwood's White Hunter, Black Heart is inspired by the shooting of African Queen, and it is a minor masterpiece. I always recommend it to everyone.
post #6 of 7

Now this was badass.

 

Beautiful movie, shot on location and it shows. I gave sharp credit to Citizen Kane a few weeks ago for being ahead of its time in terms of cinematography, but this is quite impressive as well. In particular when Dobbs and Curtin enter a bar and the shot focuses on the mirror over the bar so we see the bartender as they approach, and a scene towards the end when Dobbs's head is dunked in a puddle and bandits approach from behind in the reflection.

 

The action, for 1947, is very well choreographed (kudos to the brutal three-way bar fight) and has weight to it (bullets ricochet off the ground, rifles fire with a loud BANG, characters actually bleed when shot) and is exciting.

 

The acting is top notch. I'd seen Bogie in a few classics before, namely The Maltese Falcon and Casablanca, but this must be his best role. I love that we don't know anything about Dobbs before we first see him. A poster above was right, most of the acting was done with silent stares. When a cigarette is dropped to the ground, Dobbs eyes it desperately before a Mexican kid nabs it and runs off. It's easy to sympathize with this character at first, and even though it's clear that he's a flawed individual that can easily be pushed over the edge it's awesome to see it happen.

 

This works well as a morality tale, and at times I got an EC Comics vibe in how Dobbs gets his comeuppance. I figured the end to be incredibly fatalistic, with everyone punished with the gold dust blown away and Howard and Curtin laughing maniacally, but it went on two minutes longer and gave them a bit of a happy ending. I'm not sure if I liked that, I would have been satisfied with the movie cutting off right as their laughter built to crescendo, but I'll take it this way.

post #7 of 7

My faverite is The Maltese Falcon, but The Big Sleep, Tresure of The Sierra Madre  and Key Largo are great films. I don't really like African Queen myself, but it got a lot of talent behind it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

If you're a Bogart fan and haven't seen WE are NO Angels(1955) you should.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Films in Release or On Video
CHUD.com Community › Forums › SPECIFIC FILMS › Films in Release or On Video › Treasure of the Sierra Madre!