Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Slater
I keep seeing people speculate that Regret's ship is the Ark, and that's obviously wrong. (If they could have detonated the rings at any time, what's Regret waiting for? Why fuck with Earth in the first place?) The Ark either is Earth itself or is hidden somewhere on Earth. Period. That's why the Covies show up there in the beginning of the game, and that's why they're baffled to find human living on Earth.
Going by the biblical analogy, the Ark is the one place that keeps you protected from the great flood (The Flood), right? That's the reason that humans are descendents ("Reclaimers") of the Forerunners...because Earth is the only spot in the galaxy that's safe once the Halos are detonated. That's how humankind survived the first "Great Journey" that wiped out the Forerunners. That's why the prophets have decreed that the humans must be completely wiped out rather than offering them sanctuary as part of the Covenant; humankind is a direct threat to the prophet's rule (because who would everybody follow, the race that found the Forerunner technology or the race that's directly related to the Forerunners?).
It actually makes a lot of sense, but you have to do some deductive reasoning.
|
I agree that it's also possible that the Ark is either Earth or something on Earth (possibly in New Mombassa) - that's why I said "might very well be" rather than "is". In either case, neither answer is
obviously wrong, because there's evidence to support both.
See, in my theory, it works out like this. Regret could have detonated the Halos at any time from the Forerunner cruiser.
If (and this is a big if) he knew how. And had already inserted an index into a control room console, and subsequently removed it before the ring fired. See the thing about the Covenant (which is mentioned a couple of times in the games) is that they use Forerunner tech all the time, but they don't really understand how it works, so they have a bunch of mystical and religious symbolism built up around it to explain what they can't. Remember that the monitor tells them that inserting the Index and then removing it before the ring fires puts all the rings in standby mode. Why would you want to do that, unless it was so you could go hop in your ship, and remote-detonate after you removed yourself to a safe distance (I believe someone said between two and three galactic radii)?
It also seems that, as a safety measure, the Forerunners set the Halos up so that they could only be fired by a Forerunner. And through either a coincidence of paralell evolution or actual descendance, humans are close enough to being Forerunners as to make no difference to the Forerunner AI constructs. Which is why they needed Miranda Keyes (and Sergeant Johnson as a backup) to fire the Delta Halo - it wasn't just that they didn't understand how it worked, and couldn't have it explained to them because they had too much mental religious baggage to make sense of what the Monitors were telling them, they physically could not do it - if they put the index into the control room console, nothing would happen. They probably tried it that way in the first place.
As for why the Covenant showed up on Earth... well, there was the small matter of the beacon that was set off in the whole
I Love Bees radio play. Perhaps the Covenant thought there would be a Halo where Earth was. Perhaps the artifact was moved to New Mombassa after the whole debacle at Chawla base. Perhaps that's why
I Love Bees was such a pain in the Halo fans' collective asses to unlock... it was backstory that would otherwise have left some very confusing questions unanswered.
Or maybe I'm just talking to hear my head rattle. It wouldn't be the first time.