Moderating a forum is a lose-lose game - there's rarely a "right" decision - unless you have a well-defined set of rules and make it a full time job to keep the forum all blonde-haired and blue eyed (like TWOP). This doesn't seem like a fitting place for such rules - it's not all that chaotic and the post count, while high isn't out of control (until 5 minutes ago). Frankly, it doesn't seem like the CHUD-mod team really respect each other which pretty much sums up the forum as a whole. This really seems more fitting for that Eagles thread in catch-all.
Anyway, back to legitimate discussion on enemas, people!