Don't talk over each other as much, be more horrible to each other (I perked up quite a bit when you were railing on AmericanVoice no.3 for picking Ronin as an unknown film, the fool), have more obvious sections (I don't believe the disjointed rambling is particularly cute) and come to the specific-movie discussion bits more prepared as I really didn't get much insight or content out of those bits.
Ideas for bits:
commentaries for films, so we can play along at home.
phonecalls to dead people.
musical guests. For example: me.
I'll give this another go. Make me happy.
Also: you seem to fear the balls, Nick. Why do you fear the balls?