Its not a statement, its a question.
You see, I got round to seeing War of the Worlds on wednesday and the next day, a guy at work asked, "So, is it the greatest sci-fi film of all time?", paraphrasing a review that has been run on the ads on TV. "No," was the answer he got, but it got me to thinking, what is? And how could you possibly classify it? There are so many sub-genres within sci-fi, that to name one would be to ignore 100 others.
Some would say Star Wars, but that to me isn't even pure sci-fi. I mean, technically it is, but its more just fantasy and this is where the problem comes in. I still wouldn't put Star Wars tops.
To me the greatest sci-fi films are the ones that are sci-fi in concept only. Stuff like Seconds or Brazil or Primer. All absolutely classic. I'd throw in Blade Runner too, though that's little more than "gumshoe in the future", just for its design and its ruminations on memory and existence.
So come on, give me some good ones and let the arguing commence.
(Fifty bucks/pounds/euros to the person who can make a legitimate argument for Event Horizon over all others...)
You see, I got round to seeing War of the Worlds on wednesday and the next day, a guy at work asked, "So, is it the greatest sci-fi film of all time?", paraphrasing a review that has been run on the ads on TV. "No," was the answer he got, but it got me to thinking, what is? And how could you possibly classify it? There are so many sub-genres within sci-fi, that to name one would be to ignore 100 others.
Some would say Star Wars, but that to me isn't even pure sci-fi. I mean, technically it is, but its more just fantasy and this is where the problem comes in. I still wouldn't put Star Wars tops.
To me the greatest sci-fi films are the ones that are sci-fi in concept only. Stuff like Seconds or Brazil or Primer. All absolutely classic. I'd throw in Blade Runner too, though that's little more than "gumshoe in the future", just for its design and its ruminations on memory and existence.
So come on, give me some good ones and let the arguing commence.
(Fifty bucks/pounds/euros to the person who can make a legitimate argument for Event Horizon over all others...)





I've been following this one for almost 9 years now? maybe a little less..
