CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE CHEWERS › Reader Reviews › The Wicker Man
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Wicker Man

post #1 of 33
Thread Starter 
http://spikemarshall.blogspot.com/20...icker-man.html

Oh God! Oh Jesus Christ!

When Sergeant Howie, a mainland police officer, receives a letter detailing the disappearance of a young girl on the isolated Scottish island of Summerisle he launches an investigation to find young Rowan by himself. However upon arrival the righteous police officer finds himself dealing with obstructive locals and practices which shake his Christian core.

Made in the winter of 1973 The Wicker Man still stands as one of the finest British films ever made. Mixing a stunning script and tight plot by Anthony Shaffer, stunning direction by Robin Hardy and two central performances which have yet to be topped by either Edward Woodward (Sgt. Howie) or Christopher Lee (Lord Summerisle), it is an ingenious and peculiarly British film.

What is the central crux of the film is Howie’s rigid clash with the pagan ways of the islanders. From the moment he arrives on the Ireland Howie views himself as a bastion of moral and ethical superiority, his religious convictions putting him squarely at odds with the locals who flaunt their old ways with reckless abandon.

Howie finds himself in a world of pagan song and dance from which he is completely isolated. Saving himself for marriage he encounters a community who use sexuality as their way of worship, girls jump naked over fires, the maypole is declared a sign of fertility, boys are ritually matured, couples engage in romps below the stars, and the denizens of the pub break into rapturous verse about the Landlord’s daughter, Willow (a truly stunning performance by Britt Ekland).

Taking its practices from St James George Frazer’s ‘The Golden Bough’ and incorporating the works of Robert Burns into its 13 songs the Wicker Man is a wondrously energetic and spirited glimpse at a neo-pagan community left to its own devices. Created by Lord Summerisle’s grandfather as part of an experiment in artificial crop production the practices of the island were assimilated from the very real mythology of ancient Britain, albeit a hodge podge of different customs.

However despite the initial frivolity it soon becomes clear that Howie has landed himself in a trap of epic proportions, a fatal game devised by Lord Summerisle and played by the entire island leading Howie, seemingly by his own freewill, to his brutal appointment with the Wicker Man.

The Wicker Man is a masterful horror movie largely because it mixes a general sense of unease with a vibrancy and playfulness that lures the viewer into a false sense of security. Sgt. Howie is not much of a sympathetic character and his reactionary response to the pagan practices does little to endear him to the audience. Standing against the rigid, pious and narrow minded police officer is an ensemble of characters that seem to bear the officer no ill will on the surface.

That the conclusion, despite being the only natural end to the story, is tragic and upsetting is down to Woodward’s performance who gives Howie an innocence that offsets his less than friendly reaction to the islanders. For all the possible accusations of anti-Christianity levelled against the film the last minutes, when Howie accepts his fate it can be seen as a powerful depiction of Christian martyrdom.

If I have not mentioned the finale in any great detail it is because I wish not to surprise the sheer cataclysmic horror of the initial reveal and subsequent end.

The Wicker Man is a movie that has been with me for 10 years now and despite the horror elements it is a film that I find to be constantly uplifting and enrapturing. Aided by a wondrous folk score, provided by Paul Giovanni, and beautiful location shooting it is by far one of my all time favourite movies.

It is a great crime that the original negatives of the film have been lost, seemingly forever, but as it stands this is one of the great British movies and without a doubt the pinnacle of Christopher Lee’s career.

This film is an iconic masterpiece which should be essentially viewing for any person interested in movies.

10/10
post #2 of 33
This is one I've always wanted to see but never have. Good review.
post #3 of 33
Thread Starter 
It's an absolutley incredible movie. I tried to not spoil too much in the review, you pretty much know something nasty is going to happen to Howie from the off, but if you are going to watch it, avoid as much info about the end as possible
post #4 of 33
Unfortunately, I know exactly how it ends. But I'm still itching to see it.
post #5 of 33
Yeah, unfortunately movie sites had spoiled the ending to me as well, but I still thought it was a great movie. I generally don't like stick-up-the-ass religious guys, but damned if I didn't feel sorry for poor sgt. Howie by the end. I thought some of the more, uh, folksy aspects of the film did a lot to lull you into a false sense of security indeed.
post #6 of 33
I think I'm one of the few people who was severely underwhelmed by this movie. It had this 70s softcore porn vibe that really didn't appeal to me, and the ending was pretty much telegraphed from the beginning (at least for today's audiences, it might have been more surprising when it was first shown).

All in all I just didn't dig it when I first saw it, which was about 5 months ago, and even turned off the climax to watch South Park.
post #7 of 33
If you aren’t seriously spooked when the masked faces appear after Edward Woodworm fails to get his plane started, you probably are a pagan wicker-worshipper.
post #8 of 33
Great film.
Too bad the remake looks like a real piece of shit.
I like a lot of the actors in the remake, but God, the film looks dire.
post #9 of 33
Same here. Once the original ending has been spoiled for me, I'm just mildly curious about its remake.

Oh, and let's play the coincidences game. Guess what other Nic Cage movie has him as an investigator with somewhat firm family & moral values investigating the disappearance of a girl in a seedy underworld that will eventually shake it all up for him?

Hmmm, maybe with Neil Labute at the helm he'll manage to kill himself by crashing his car against a wall.
post #10 of 33
Thread Starter 
Apparently Robin Hardy and Christopher Lee are working on an unofficial thematic sequel called Cowboys for Jesus to be released at the same time as the, awful in concept, remake.
post #11 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Quarant
I think I'm one of the few people who was severely underwhelmed by this movie. It had this 70s softcore porn vibe that really didn't appeal to me, and the ending was pretty much telegraphed from the beginning (at least for today's audiences, it might have been more surprising when it was first shown).

All in all I just didn't dig it when I first saw it, which was about 5 months ago, and even turned off the climax to watch South Park.
For Halloween we tried getting through this and The Howling and couldn't get halfway through either [Which was disappointing as I had rented all these classic horror films for halloween]. Still haven't watched it all the way through but that vibe put off my friends from settling down and watching it...
post #12 of 33
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth Chocula
For Halloween we tried getting through this and The Howling and couldn't get halfway through either [Which was disappointing as I had rented all these classic horror films for halloween]. Still haven't watched it all the way through but that vibe put off my friends from settling down and watching it...
I can dig that, in fact I feel that its a pretty valid criticism due to the general sexual undercurrent of the film. I think the people who love the Wicker Man are people who either saw it when they were less, cynicals the wrong word but it'll have to do (no offence should be taken), or ,like me, watched it when they were younger and effectively grew up with the film, its been my new years film for the last 6 years.

The problem with the Wicker Man is that its not a horror film in the traditional sense, its more of a thriller with a few horrific elements which has an uplifting end.
post #13 of 33
But I wouldn't call it a thriller, either. It's more a ... folk musical police mystery film. If you can get by that - and I think the first song is a litmus test, if you haven't thrown things at the TV when 'Corn rigs are bonnie' starts up, then chances are you'll love it.

I don't know about having to be younger or less cynical to enjoy it - I was neither, but you definitely need to come to it with an open mind and a lot of patience.

I was lucky enough to see it for the first time on TV, bereft of any foreknowledge or clue-giving packaging (it's tough remaining spoiler-free when the DVD menu itself gives the big 'shock' away) whatsoever - so I guess I was coming to it as it was truly intended, give or take a cinema screen.

Excellent film, one I try to convince everyone I know to watch.
post #14 of 33
King of the Wicker People

Sorry, I couldn't resist. Carry on.
post #15 of 33
Thread Starter 
This is playing at the Pictureville in Bradford i Robin Hardy is going to be holding attending and answering questions after the film.
post #16 of 33
Thread Starter 
Optimum are releasing a new 3-Disc Wicker Man set, complete with the OST and the Mark Kermode Burnt Offerings Documentary.

http://dvdtimes.co.uk/content.php?contentid=62351

I'll probably double dip for the OST, and the documentary is a nice extra. The box design does irritate me somewhat. At first I thought it was really nice, now it's lack of spacial coordination really bugs me.

post #17 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spike Marshall
I think the people who love the Wicker Man are people who either saw it when they were less, cynicals the wrong word but it'll have to do (no offence should be taken), or ,like me, watched it when they were younger and effectively grew up with the film, its been my new years film for the last 6 years.
It's even simpler than that. People who love The Wicker Man are people who appreciate really fucking great cinema. Whether or not a movie goes down well at a Halloween party is not an accurate measure of its quality.
post #18 of 33
I... could never get into it. I tried and tried.

Does this make me a bad man?
post #19 of 33
No real motivation to watch this film (unless it airs on TV) because I have also being spoiled to hell. I blame Devin.

No particular reason, he's just easy to blame in situations like this.
post #20 of 33
The movie has been out for over thirty years - it should be assumed that spoilers will be involved in any discussion of it.

Also, there's more to this movie than just the ending. If you're just avoiding it because you know what happens, that's really dumb.
post #21 of 33
Can anyone remind me why the elaborate trap was necessary? If they're so fanatical about it, couldn't they just have burned one of their own and regain the crop-gods' favour much, much sooner?
post #22 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dan Whitehead
The movie has been out for over thirty years - it should be assumed that spoilers will be involved in any discussion of it.
Well in my defence its not like I was in a thread called "Wicker Man discussion" when I was spoiled, it just happens randomly, and repeatedly, cant be helped.

Quote:
Also, there's more to this movie than just the ending. If you're just avoiding it because you know what happens, that's really dumb.
Of course, but no I've read alot about the film (once you know the ending, you figure it cant hurt to read essays and articles on it, then after a while you begin to wonder if you've already seen it or not) and I cant be arsed to spend money on it, I'd rather wait for whenever its on TV. The 'impact' of the story has been robbed from me though, which is a factor in my lack of motivation to run out and see it. I'm well aware its one of, if not the most definitive films of Christopher Lee's career, knowing the ending does not make me suddenly lose interest in the film. I guess I'm just not that a fan of the storyline, but I'll give it a shot if it ever airs.
post #23 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by ServantOfDagon
Can anyone remind me why the elaborate trap was necessary? If they're so fanatical about it, couldn't they just have burned one of their own and regain the crop-gods' favour much, much sooner?
It basically goes like this:
  • They need a virgin - Sgt Howie is a virgin, at at the age of (about) mid/late 30's he's a well aged virgin whose obviously choosen to keep himself pure...
  • They need someone to offer themselves of their own free will - Sgt Howie came to the island of his own free will, albeit he was looking for Rowan Morrisson...
  • As a member of the police, Sgt Howie also represented the queen

All of these factors together made him a particular fine sacrifice.

Plus, he was The Equaliser.
post #24 of 33
Thread Starter 
Also Lord Summerisle knows that a big sacrifice is going to be needed. The only suitable person on the Island is himself, so he lures in an outsider to take his place.
post #25 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spike Marshall
Also Lord Summerisle knows that a big sacrifice is going to be needed. The only suitable person on the Island is himself, so he lures in an outsider to take his place.
Plus he's Saruman and Count Dooku.
post #26 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Graham
Plus he's Saruman and Count Dooku.
...and Dracula too.

...if anyone in the 80s ever told me that The Equaliser will fight a vampire, wizard and sith lord I would have blurted in my pants and had a teenage heart attack.

...I'd have never thought he would have walked into their trap and have his ass kicked though...

...Lord Summerisle would have backed down if he had Robert McCall pointing his little finger at him!
post #27 of 33
Thread Starter 
Even if you don't believe in Paganism I think sacrificing Christopher Lee to the gods would yield bountiful results.
post #28 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Charlie Brigden
I... could never get into it. I tried and tried.

Does this make me a bad man?

Nope. No like from me either. It's not nearly as good as it thinks it is.


What the hell is up with that musical interlude? Reminded me of if Billy Jack were to go to broadway.
post #29 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth Chocula
For Halloween we tried getting through this and The Howling and couldn't get halfway through either [Which was disappointing as I had rented all these classic horror films for halloween]. Still haven't watched it all the way through but that vibe put off my friends from settling down and watching it...

Get some new friends because there is nothing wrong with The Howling!
post #30 of 33
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by General Zod
What the hell is up with that musical interlude? Reminded me of if Billy Jack were to go to broadway.
Which one? There are like half a dozen moments which could be classed as a muscial interlude.
post #31 of 33
Not sure exactly, it looked like a hippie carnival or something.
post #32 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by General Zod
Not sure exactly, it looked like a hippie carnival or something.
Ah... must have been the Maypole Song...

In the woods there grew a tree
And a fine fine tree was he

And on that tree there was a limb
And on that limb there was a branch
And on that branch there was a nest
And in that nest there was an egg
And in that egg there was a bird
And from that bird a feather came
And of that feather was
A bed

And on that bed there was a girl
And on that girl there was a man
And from that man there was a seed
And from that seed there was a boy
And from that boy there was a man
And for that man there was a grave
From that grave there grew
A tree

In the Summerisle,
Summerisle, Summerisle, Summerisle wood
Summerisle wood.


...don't write them like that anymore...
post #33 of 33
Thread Starter 
I like the song and dance routines. And Maypole is a great piece of music. Seriously the songs tell you all you need to know about the community from how close knit they are to what they believe in.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Reader Reviews
CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE CHEWERS › Reader Reviews › The Wicker Man