Caught a few minutes of The Little Girl Who Lives Down the Lane on one of those secondary digital channels (thistv, I think). I'd never heard of the movie, and it actually looked interesting from the 5 minutes I saw of Martin Sheen chewing scenery at a young Jodie Foster. But there was another guy there, I knew I recognized him. Then it hit me, "Jon Bernthal! Shane from the Walking Dead. He's aged well...wait...how can he be THAT old? No way is he older than Jodie Foster."
Turns out it was Scott Jacoby, and Jon Bernthal was born after the movie in question was released.