CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE MAIN SEWER › Movie Miscellany › The CLINT EASTWOOD Appreciation Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The CLINT EASTWOOD Appreciation Thread

post #1 of 378
Thread Starter 

The CLINT EASTWOOD Appreciation Thread


I first became a fan of Clint Eastwood’s work many years ago. I can’t remember exactly how I became a fan but I think it had something to do with asking my mom who her favourite actor was. There was a period around ’96-’98 that I started renting Eastwood films like crazy, one or two a week or even three on a weekend. I came to love his work. I’m thankful I was able to find his work as I’m frightened as to what kinds of films I would have like had I not found his wonderfully directed, paced and acted films.

I have yet to see a few of his directed films but of the ones I’ve seen I rank them like this:


1.Unforgiven (1992) A+
2.Bird (1988) A+
3.The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976) A
4.High Plains Drifter (1973) A
5.The Bridges of Madison County (1995) A
6.Million Dollar Baby(2004) A
7.A Perfect World (1993) A-
8.True Crime (1999) A-
9.Mystic River (2003) B+
10.Play Misty for Me (1971) B+
11.Pale Rider (1985) B+
12.Bronco Billy (1980) B+
13.White Hunter, Black Heart (1990) B+
14.The Eiger Sanction (1975) B
15.Flags of Our Fathers (2006) B
16.The Gauntlet (1977) B
17.Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil (1997) B
18.Space Cowboys (2000) B-
19.Heartbreak Ridge (1986) B-
20.Absolute Power (1997) C+
21.Sudden Impact (1983) C+
22.Firefox (1982) C
23.Blood Work (2002) C
24.The Rookie (1990) C-



Clint Eastwood was born on May 30, 1930 to Clinton and Ruth Eastwood and spent many of his young years on the move. He became interested in jazz music (which would play a large role in some of his films later in his life) and learned the hardship of being put to work as a young fellow.

1950 – 1969

In 1951 he was drafted by the army and was to be sent to Korea but after a navy plane he was aboard had engine problems and was forced to make a water landing, Eastwood was given the job of a swimming instructor. He was discharged in 1953 and moved to Southern California where attended Los Angeles City College where he studied drama and business administration.

He received an acting contract with Universal but after a year they dropped him. He began to just look for any work at this point and would try out for almost any part. During this time he started getting minor gigs in such films as Revenge of the Creature, Tarantula and Francis in the Navy. He would guest star on “Maverick” with James Garner, whom he would work with again some forty years later). In 1959 he was spotted and offered the role of Rowdy Yates in the classic TV western “Rawhide”. “Rawhide” proved to be a wise choice for Eastwood and he’s thankful for having that job. During the shows run Eastwood was able to learn everything about making a show or film. He learned about the different jobs and learned about directing. Any chance he got he would watch the directors and learn from them. He also developed his trademark “coolness” during this time when he would see the directors yell “ACTION!” and the horses would take off everywhere. Eastwood just uses the terms, “ok, go.” “Go ahead.” “Begin.” He doesn’t yell action or anything to that effect.


Eastwood as Rowdy Yates in "Rawhide"


During his stint on “Rawhide” Eastwood was contacted by a man named Sergio Leone. Leone was an Italian director who wanted to make a low budget western remake of the classic Yojimbo. Clint was a huge fan of Yojimbo and was intrigued with the part so he accepted but under one condition… that he have full creative control over his character. This character would prove to be the smartest choice Eastwood had ever made.
The film was released overseas in 1964 under the title of Per un pugno di dollari . It wasn’t until around 1966 when Eastwood saw an article in a local newspaper that he realized that this film was getting attention. He decided to screen it for his friends and they were blown away.
The film was eventually released in the U.S. under the title of A Fistful of Dollars. It would be a success and make Eastwood a star. At this time Eastwood had already made two sequels to the film called: For a Few Dollars More (1965) and The Good, The Bad & The Ugly (1966).


Eastwood as The Man with No Name in The Good, The Bad & The Ugly (1966)

With these films being a huge success and Eastwood quickly rising to stardom he started his own production company called Malpaso Productions. Malpaso means “bad step” in Spanish. Eastwood’s first film under this companies name was Hang ‘Em High (1968). A decent western about a man who was falsely accused of cattle robbing and hung to death only to not die and come back for vengeance. His next film would be with director Don Siegel with whom he would strike up a great friendship.Coogan’s Bluff (1968) would still see Eastwood as a “cowboy” but this time in the urban setting of New York City. Eastwood’s next two films would be a war movie with Richard Burton entitled Where Eagles Dare (1968), which was nothing more then a straight forward shoot’em up movie, and the terrible musical-comedy Paint Your Wagon (1969). Apparently Paint Your Wagon went so over budget that this inspired Clint to keep an eye on his budgets which is another trademark of Eastwood.
post #2 of 378
Thread Starter 
1970-1979

The 1970’s opened with Clint becoming more popular. His movies were making money and he was getting offers everywhere. This is the time when he started to choose his projects more carefully. He would pick pieces that had interesting stories and interesting characters. He fell in love with flawed characters and anti-heroes. Between 1970 and 1971 Clint made five films: Two Mules for Sister Sara (1970), Kelly’s Heroes (1970), The Beguiled (1971) (another collaboration with Siegel), Play Misty For Me (1971) and Dirty Harry (1971).

Play Misty For Me was Eastwood’s directorial debut. The film was about a record D.J. who becomes stalked by a fan of his radio show. The film had a small budget and Eastwood even forfeited his director’s salary just to get the chance to direct it. He shot the film in what became his “hometown” of Carmel, California. The film even features a cameo by Don Siegel as a bartender.


Eastwood as "Dirty" Harry Callahan

That same year he made a film which would take Eastwood from stardom to superstardom. The film was called Dirty Harry. In a role that was originally slated for Frank Sinatra Eastwood made it his own and made ‘Dirty’ Harry Callahan one of the most popular and famous characters in movie history. The film would spawn four sequels but the consensus is that the first one is the best. The film also spawned the popular phrase, “Do you feel lucky punk?” The film would go onto to be a box office success and secure a place for Clint as a respectable actor and a bankable star.

He followed Dirty Harry with another western titled Joe Kidd (1972) and the magnificent High Plains Drifter (1973). High Plains Drifter proved to be a success for Eastwood and is considered by many to be one of his absolute best films and one of his best westerns. The film is about a mysterious man who wanders into a small town begins to take over. The sheriff of this town was murdered and the citizens did nothing to stop it. No one knows exactly who this “stranger” is and the answer is never given. Eastwood leaves it up to the viewer as to who the stranger is. Some think it is an avenging angel sent to clean the town up. Some believe it is the Sheriff’s brother while others think it is the sheriff reincarnated. Eastwood has said this about the identity of the Stranger:

Quote:
“It was originally written that the Drifter was the brother of the murdered sheriff, but I played it as if it could have been some apparition. You're not quite sure, but you know that he has a strong interest in making the town suffer for their sins and that it ties in with their complacency with the murder. But the only clue is when the Drifter lies down (later in the hotel) and has this dream of the sheriff being whipped to death, and you know from there that he's tied in some way, but you're not sure how. That way you keep the mystique and the whole atmosphere is mysterious. To me, if the Drifter comes to town and immediately says, "I'm the brother of the murdered sheriff," right away you draw the conclusions. Instead, once he takes the town and humiliates them through his own methods, you're asking, "Who is he? Why is he doing this?” - Clint Eastwood in an interview with Ric Gentry published in Millimeter (December 1980), pp. 127-33, reprinted in Clint Eastwood: Interviews, p. 68
And:

Quote:
“You could recognize him as the ghost or some avenging spirit or you could recognize him as a brother. I played him more as an apparition. To just play it out simply as a relative coming back is really not very interesting. It's gotta be like the audience never really knows.” - Clint Eastwood Audio Clip: High Plains Drifter from the Clint Eastwood Website

Eastwood as The Stranger in 1973's High Plains Drifter

It’s a remarkable film and is a bright spot in Eastwood’s career for the 70’s. He followed Drifter with a directed only film called Breezy (1973) and the first sequel to Dirty Harry Magnum Force (1973).

In 1974 Eastwood team with then unknown writer/director Michael Cimino for a film called Thunderbolt & Lightfoot. Cimino would later go on to direct The Deer Hunter. Eastwood and Cimino worked together on Magnum Force which Cimino wrote. Eastwood liked his work so much that he agreed to be in this film. Jeff Bridges was brought on as the co-star and the two proved to be quite a good team. The chemistry was so good between the two that Bridges was nominated for a Best Supporting Actor Oscar.

In 1975 Eastwood made the spy thriller The Eiger Sanction. It’s a nice little film and definitely departs from Eastwood’s usual films up to that point. The cinematography is astounding the performances are marvelous.

After The Eiger Sanction Eastwood went back to his roots for another western entitled: The Outlaw Josey Wales. Some consider this to be his finest western and one of the greatest westerns ever made. It’s definitely a great piece of work and its one film Eastwood is really proud of making. The film failed to garner any Academy Award support despite its box office and critical success. However not earning Academy Award nominations was something Eastwood was too by this point.


Eastwood as The Outlaw Josey Wales

Eastwood rounded out the 70’s with a third sequel to Dirty Harry called The Enforcer (1976), a cop thriller called The Gauntlet (1977), and a film called Every Which Way But Loose (1978) which featured Clint teamed up with an orangutan. This film happened to be the second highest grossing film of 1978 behind Superman. It’s also Eastwood’s highest grossing film ever.

Eastwood’s last film for the 70’s was the true story of the men who escaped from Alcatraz prison. Escape From Alcatraz teamed Eastwood with Don Siegel for a fifth and final time. By this time they had become such great friends and knew what each other wanted that Clint was able to sit in on the editing of the film and make final decisions without Don’s consent.

1980-1989

The 80’s proved to be a great decade for Eastwood. By this time Eastwood had secured himself as a bankable star and as a proven director. He was able to pick projects only he wanted to do and get financing for them. He started off the 80’s with his “Capra” film called Bronco Billy (1980) and followed that with a sequel to Every Which Way But Loose entitled Any Which Way You Can. He starred in the espionage thriller Firefox (1982) and followed that with a personal project titled Honkytonk Man (1982).

1983 saw Eastwood return to what made him star as he dusted off the .44 Magnum and brought Dirty Harry Callahan back for a fourth time in Sudden Impact. This film entered movie history with the famous line: “Go ahead, make my day.” He followed this with the cop thriller Tightrope (1984) and the misfire City Heat (1984). In 1985 he returned to the western genre with Pale Rider.


Eastwood uttering the famous "Go ahead, make my day!" line

It was also around this time that Eastwood was becoming upset with the way his town was being run. Residents had spoken up and were shot down. So Eastwood decided to take matters into his own hands and run for Mayor of Carmel, California. On April 8, 1986 Eastwood was elected to the Mayor’s Office. He served a two year term and declined to run for re-election. During his term in office he made a military film called Heartbreak Ridge. The film was backed by the U.S. Marines until they saw a cut and declined further involvement. They were upset with the way the Marines were portrayed and even came out against the film. The film takes place during the troubled event in Grenada and although it was the Army that liberated the students however Eastwood plays it as the Marines.

Unfortunately Eastwood finished the 80’s on a low note with a fifth and final sequel to Dirty Harry called The Dead Pool (1988) and the comedy Pink Cadillac (1989). The only exception was Bird (1988) a movie about the life of Charlie “Bird” Parker a famous jazz musician. The film received critical praise everywhere and even won Clint the Golden Globe for Best Director and a Golden Palm nomination at the Cannes Film Festival. It won an Oscar for Best Sound.
post #3 of 378
Thread Starter 
1990-1999

The 90’s opened on very quiet note with under the radar film White Hunter, Black Heart and the terrible buddy cop comedy The Rookie.


The poster for Eastwood's masterpiece Unforgiven

Eastwood took a year off to make a film that would turn out to be the greatest film he has ever made and one of the greatest pieces of cinema ever. That film is Unforgiven (1992). Eastwood had been holding onto the script for about 10-12 years just waiting for the right time to make it.
At a time when the western genre was dieing Eastwood resurrected it with a fresh take on the genre. The film starred Eastwood as en ex-outlaw who has reformed his ways. After a whore is cut up he comes out of retirement for the money to help support his kids. Morgan Freeman co-starred as Eastwood’s former gun slinging friend and Gene Hackman stars as the town’s hard nosed sheriff.

The film received massive critical praise, box office success and many awards and nominations including: nine Academy Awards nominations with four wins (Best Picture, Best Director, Best Supporting Actor [Hackman] and Best Editing), a DGA award for outstanding directorial achievement, and four Golden Globe nominations with two wins for Best Director and Best Supporting Actor. The film still remains one of the most important films of the 90’s and one of the greatest westerns ever made.


Eastwood holds his Oscars for Unforgiven

Eastwood followed this with the Wolfgang Peterson directed CIA thriller In the Line of Fire (1993) and the self directed drama A Perfect World (1993). In the Line of Fire was a huge hit and showed that Eastwood still had what it took to be an action star. A Perfect World teamed Eastwood with Kevin Costner in what turned out to be a wonderful little film that has hardly been seen.

In 1995 Eastwood returned with a complete and utter change in pace from what audiences were used to… a romance movie. Eastwood teamed with Meryl Streep for the film The Bridges of Madison County. It was a popular film and did well at the box office and has become a favourite among Eastwood fans. Eastwood was praised for taking such a risk and was also praised for his performance which remains one of his finest ever.


Eastwood and Streep embrace in The Bridges of Madison County

After Bridges he took a year off and then returned in 1997 with two film Absolute Power and the directed only Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil. Both proved to be weak and weren’t that successful at the box office. Midnight had a great ensemble cast and has become an under appreciated gem in Eastwood’s career.

Eastwood took another year off and then in 1999 returned the thriller True Crime which featured an innocent man on death row. Eastwood played a brunt reporter who believes the man is innocent and races against the clock to prove it. The film tanked at the box office and Eastwood was furious with Warner Brothers (his home for over 30 years) for not marketing it properly. It remains one of Eastwood’s best films and also features some of the strongest supporting performances in any Eastwood film.

2000’s

In 2000 Eastwood decided to star in another comedy but this time he did so with some fellow friends. He re-teamed with James Garner and Donald Sutherland (Kelly’s Heroes) and brought in Tommy Lee Jones for the old timer comedy Space Cowboys. The film was loved by audiences and made close to $100 million at the box office.

Eastwood then took two years off only to return with the clunky and formulaic thriller Blood Work in 2002. The film didn’t do much at the box office and annoyed fans with its lazy writing and mediocre directing.

Eastwood more then made up for that film a year later with Mystic River in 2003. The film starred Sean Penn, Tim Robbins, Kevin Bacon, Laurence Fishburne, Marcia Gay Harden and Laura Linney. It received wide spread critical praise and received Academy Award nominations for: Best Actor (Penn), Best Supporting Actor (Robbins), Best Supporting Actress (Gay Harden), Best Director, Best Picture and Best Adapted Screenplay. It won the Best Actor and Best Supporting Actor awards. It also received Golden Globe nominations for: Best Actor (Penn), Best Supporting Actor (Robbins), Best Director, Best Picture and Best Adapted Screenplay winning two: Best Actor and Supporting Actor.

Some felt Eastwood deserved the Best Director Oscar but was robbed since Peter Jackson won for all three Lord of the Rings films. And also because in his whole career he was only nominated once before; 11 years earlier.


Eastwood and Swank in Million Dollar Baby

That following year Eastwood stuck Oscar gold again with the drama Million Dollar Baby (2004). The film re-teamed Eastwood with Morgan Freeman and let him work with Hilary Swank. The film, like Mystic River the year before, received massive critical praise and had a big box office success. The film received Academy Award nominations for: Best Actor (Eastwood), Best Supporting Actor (Freeman), Best Actress (Swank), Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Director and Best Picture and Best Editing. It won: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Supporting Actor and Best Actress. It also took home Golden Globes for: Best Director and Best Actress and a DGA award for Best Directorial Achievement.

In 2005 it was announced that Eastwood would be directing a World War II film based on the famous flag raising on Iwo Jima. The film was based off the book "Flags of our Fathers" and the book recounted how the men raised the flag and how they became heroes for it. The film took the same name as the book. Shortly into 2006 it was announced that Eastwood would also make a film to coincide with Flags of our Fathers. It would be from the Japanese point of view and would be released around the same time as Flags. This was an ambitious assignment for Eastwood as he had never dabled in World War II (not from a directing stand point) and his films never seemed to be overly heavy on action. Also not to mention he was making two films at once. Flags was released in October 2006 to good reviews but it failed to capture everyone like his previous two films (Mystic River & Million Dollar Baby) did. Critics praised the film for it's look and feel and the performances but felt the narrative was weak. Letters From Iwo Jima, the companion film shot entirely in the Japanese language, is scheduled for release in January 2007.


The men raise the American flag on Iwo Jima in Flags of our Fathers

Eastwood’s career has been alive and well for over 50 years and shows no signs of slowing down. He has many projects lined up and he has even dabled in TV directing with Steven Spielberg's 80's TV Show "Amazing Stories". Clint directed the episode entitled: Vanessa in the Garden. In 2003 he also directed a mini-documentary for pal Martin Scorsese’s mini-series called “The Blues”. His episode was entitled: “Piano Blues”.


Eastwood holds his Oscars for Million Dollar Baby

Eastwood has become known for his fast and efficient production schedule (he shot and completed Million Dollar Baby in less then a year) and his ability to work with and get great performances out of his actors. He’s also never afraid to take risks and try something new. His calm, cool manner on set has won him over with many actors and crew members which is why everyone loves to work with him. Clint Eastwood will definitely go down in cinema history as one of the greatest actor/directors of all time.


Eastwood directs a scene from Million Dollar Baby

Info:

IMDb.com – Clint Eastwood
ClintEastwood.net – A fan site
Wikipedia.com – Clint Eastwood

*I apologize for any and all spelling/grammar mistake*
post #4 of 378
Great thread, Brenden.

I too love Clint and grew up watching a lot of his flicks. I love everything from his westerns, the first three Dirty Harry's, his Every Which Way...orangutaun films, to his acclaimed directorial work.

I guess I'd agree with you're ratings for the selected films but I only watched parts of True Crime when it came out on video and wasn't impressed. I should give it another shot.
post #5 of 378
That's the most exhaustively complete opening to an appreciation thread I've ever seen. Nice work, and there are few filmmakers who deserve it more.

As someone who was around and already a movie enthusiast in the 70's, I remember people being a little incredulous about the idea of Eastwood directing. Dirty Harry hadn't exactly made him the toast of intellectual culture. But the man has more than proven himself. There's little more exciting to a true film buff these days than the prospect of another Clint Eastwood film coming up.

Until recently, (as I've extensively documented around here), I had little exposure to westerns, and I've spent the last couple of years playing catch-up. I knew his contributions to film were many, but until I saw work like The Outlaw Josey Wales and High Plains Drifter, I had no clue. I feel retroactively stupid for having missed them all these years.
post #6 of 378
Great rundown of the guy's career.

Lately I've been watching a lot of the films, both that he starred in and directed, that had passed me by. Really dug THE EIGER SANCTION as a cool mixture of Dirty Harry in a James Bond setting.

I too am a bit puzzled by the TRUE CRIME praise. It seemed fairly generic. I'll take ABSOLUTE POWER over that one. It's far from perfect but it has a great cast doing their best to make an entertaining film out of an absurd plot.

I might actually go with A PERFECT WORLD as my favorite film he has directed. A real underrated flick with a great performance by Costner.

The one I need to watch is WHITE HUNTER, BLACK HEART.
post #7 of 378
I remember seeing True Crime in a theater and loving it. Course I had just come from seeing The Matrix on the same day, so anything would have been wonderful at that point.

High Plains Drifter and Heartbreak Ridge. Those are my favs...
post #8 of 378
I was wondering about how high True Crime was ranked, as well. I've never seen it. For the exhaustive effort you've put into this, I'm putting it on my Netflix queue.

I do know, in my opinion, High Plains Drifter is maybe the best western ever made and definitely my favorite. I'm glad that it's been getting the recognition it deserves over the past few years.
post #9 of 378
High Plains Drifter is the best telling of the undead badass seeks vengence plot that doesn't feature Charlie Sheen and a concept car ever made.

And it's got midgets. Gotta love midgets...
post #10 of 378
Oh yes. So many people don't want to get this idea. I don't think the spirit idea ends with High Plains Drifter, either. I think The Good, The Bad and The Ugly is a theological discussion played out as a western as well.
post #11 of 378
Hey, I actually really like Where Eagles Dare! Sure, it's a bit of a no-brainer, but it's heaps of fun.
post #12 of 378
The man is a cinematic icon, he's up there with John Wayne, Humphrey Bogart and Steve McQueen.

That's a great bio Brendan, High Plains Drifter is one of the best westerns ever made, one of the pioneering films of horror westerns, that image of Clint with a whip with flames raging behind him is such a great image. The opening and closing credits are just so eerie.

I think Eastwood was influenced by Don Siegel than Sergio Leone, I think Leone once referred to Eastwood's acting as if it was a 'block of marble' but you can't deny Eastwood created such an Iconic character such as 'The Man with no name'

Although Eastwood is known as the perennial badass, he also took lighter roles, sometimes successful sometimes not.
post #13 of 378
Thread Starter 
Leone mentioned that Eastwood was like a block marble because he was constantly changing and chipping away at the block and creating something new.

As for True Crime, yeah it is a little high and I might change that but I still feel it's a wonderful Eastwood film. The performances is what makes it and the chemistry between James Woods, Eastwood and Denis Leary (in one his best performances) is astounding. Lisa Gay Hamilton as the wife of the prisoner is just wonderful to watch and Isaiah Washington is great too. It's all in the performances that make the film for me.
post #14 of 378
You really need to see The Beguiled.
post #15 of 378
As someone noted, Clint has also been great in lighter stuff like "Two Mules for Sister Sarah." My personal fave movie featuring Clint will probably always be "A Fistful of Dollars." Ladies and gentlemen, I give you The Antihero.
post #16 of 378
The Good The Bad and The Ugly is my fave of the trilogy, though Fistful is close behind and almost as good.

I feel Any Which Way You Can is better than the original. Less romance with Locke and more focus on Clint and Clyde. The final fight with William Smith is great.
post #17 of 378
Thread Starter 
A little less Clint love then I though when I typed this up.

No thoughts on Bridges? His performance? No thoughts on Bird? Or the comic masterpiece The Rookie?
post #18 of 378
No thoughts on BRIDGES, but THE ROOKIE was real disappointing. I know it was just one of those seemingly sure fire bets that he did for Warner so he could make films like WHITE HUNTER but that aside he should have been able to come up with something better than that.
post #19 of 378
Easily one of my all time favorite actors, and he's evolved into one of our very best directors.

Absolutely love "Unforgiven", the Leone westerns, most of the "Dirty Harry" films, and "White Hunter Black Heart" is his most underrated performance. "Million Dollar Baby" is a devastating performance, and suitable capper to a storied career.

I was impressed by how far he's been willing to push it at times, be it "Dirty Harry" or a really edgy turn in "Tightrope", which I think is pretty underrated. And I'll somewhat disagree with Moltisanti, I enjoyed "The Rookie". There's that one shot of them in the car mid-air as the building explodes behind them that is badass.

Oh, and "In the Line of Fire" is near the very top of his filmography. "You have a rendezvous with my ass motherfucker!"
post #20 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brendan
A little less Clint love then I though when I typed this up.

No thoughts on Bridges? His performance? No thoughts on Bird? Or the comic masterpiece The Rookie?
I feel ya. I've started several threads trying to show appreciation for something, and they get almost no traffic. Start a thread about a movie everybody hates, and you'll get plenty of hits. Better yet, start yet another thread about how you don't like Star Wars anymore. That'll go for days.

Positivity doesn't sell.
post #21 of 378
Great work, Brendan. I think I've said this before, but I think you should talk to George Merchan about submitting these to the main page as Chewer Columns (or maybe even their own thing).

What's so great and unique about Eastwood is you could have separate threads like this for his acting and directing careers, and both would be perfectly legitimate.

Have to agree with Molt that A PERFECT WORLD is maybe his most underrated movie. It's probably Costner's best work. I'm also a big fan of ESCAPE FROM ALCATRAZ. (And of course DIRTY HARRY, the Westerns, etc.)
post #22 of 378
Great thread. I've seen a lot of the man's films, but my personal favorite of the ones he's just acted in is probally IN THE LINE OF FIRE.

But then again, UNFORGIVEN is in my top ten films of all time, and I could talk about this movie forever. The new DVD has a lot of interesting insights about Eastwood, including a documentary narrated by John Cusack.

Actually, Brendan, I'd like to read YOUR thoughts on Bird. You spent a lot of time detailing the others, I'd like to hear why you thought Bird was an A+ film for Eastwood.

I was a fan of Mystic River, but I thought Eastwood didn't quite match Lehane's prose. The performances were all excellent, especially the cop team of Bacon and Fishburne, but there were a couple of times where I found myself missing Lehane. Also, there's a scene in the book--one where Jimmy comes to the realization that he's "evil"--that I found myself waiting for in the film, and it only would have taken a second or two, and I was quite disappointed that he left that introspective moment out. I know that's an odd criticism to make of a film, but yeah, book was better.
post #23 of 378
A Perfect World came up around here a few months back (I think it was brought up when someone said Costner couldn't act), and it seems to have quite a following around here. I was incredibly impressed with it, and it's unbelievable to me how many people I talk to who've never even heard of it. And Costner really is great in it.
post #24 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stew
I was impressed by how far he's been willing to push it at times, be it "Dirty Harry" or a really edgy turn in "Tightrope", which I think is pretty underrated. And I'll somewhat disagree with Moltisanti, I enjoyed "The Rookie". There's that one shot of them in the car mid-air as the building explodes behind them that is badass.
I will agree that TIGHTROPE is underrated. But THE ROOKIE just felt like Eastwood was trying for a LETHAL WEAPON vibe and, car flying through explosion aside, there weren't enough money moments to keep it on par with the similar movies of that era. To me the first few DIRTY HARRY flicks weren't great because of the action but because it was a cool character and that element was missing from THE ROOKIE. I would rank it higher than BLOOD WORK though.
post #25 of 378
I didn't care for The Rookie much, either. Though, I will agree with Stew that that one part where they fly through the explosion is cool. Aside from that, the film felt a bit bland and forgettable to me. And yeah, White Hunter Black Heart is a very good film with one of Clint's most overlooked performances. I love the part when he starts shit with the British rugby player and ends up getting his ass kicked.

Escape From Alcatraz is a great film. So many great moments and the ending where they all sneak out is superb.

As for the Dirty Harry franchise,the original remains the best. It has a great villain in Andy Robinson's Scorpio and many great Clint lines. I kinda like Magnum Force and Hal Holbrook is great. Enforcer has some fun moments. The other two are pretty much forgettable, save for the odd highlight of Jim Carrey lip synching to GN'R in The Dead Pool.
post #26 of 378
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by RathBandu
Actually, Brendan, I'd like to read YOUR thoughts on Bird. You spent a lot of time detailing the others, I'd like to hear why you thought Bird was an A+ film for Eastwood.
Actually I haven't seen Bird in YEARS! But I do remember loving the style, tone and performances. And just the story. I'll have to watch it again.
post #27 of 378
I'm gonna take MAGNUM FORCE by a nose over DIRTY HARRY. I liked that the first film presented you with the most extreme cop that many found reprehensible at the time and then the second go-around he's taking on cops far worse than he could ever be.

Plus most people love "Feel lucky Punk" and "Go ahead, make my day" but I've always been partial to "A man's got to know his limitations."
post #28 of 378
Given that I was bored half to death by Absolute Power, are True Crime and Blood Work worth seeing?
post #29 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris Wood
Given that I was bored half to death by Absolute Power, are True Crimeand Blood Work worth seeing?
Even if you loved ABSOLUTE POWER, neither of those movies is worth seeing.
post #30 of 378
Thread Starter 
I'd say True Crime is worth seeing. It seems to be a hit and miss with general audiences but the performances are worth it alone. Blood Work is trash and my belief is that he did it to do Mystic River.
post #31 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brendan
A little less Clint love then I though when I typed this up.

No thoughts on Bridges? His performance? No thoughts on Bird? Or the comic masterpiece The Rookie?
Eastwood is my favorite director at the moment, so sorry for not contributing until now, but my problem is I've only seen five of his films as director: Heartbreak Ridge, Unforgiven, Space Cowboys, Mystic River, and Million Dollar Baby. I'm dying to see more of his work, but I've been holding out on the DVDs hoping that WB will reissue them in a new box. They've already confirmed that Bridges will be getting a new anamorphic release; that coupled with Eastwood's resurgence in popularity and the slew of Warners boxsets hitting the market make me think a Clint box is a lock.

Thoughts on the few films I have seen? Hmmm... Although Unforgiven and Million Dollar Baby affected me profoundly, I must say I don't care for Mystic River. Many critics were quite impressed with what the film had to say about violence, but whatever they saw, I couldn't find. The film doesn't allow proper time to explore the ramifications of violence and retribution in any satisfactory way, devoting most of its running time to the ho-hum mystery plotline instead. Moreover, Penn and Robbins are not that good in it. Bacon overshadowed them both. Probelm is, his character was burdened with a paper-thin subplot about his estranged wife. I actually thought the actor who played Penn's daughter's boyfriend gave the best performance in the film. He conveyed the most genuine sense of grief and anger, whereas Penn and Robbins merely riffed on personas created earlier in their careers. That said, I haven't given up totally on the film. I'll revisit it now and again, and may very well come around to loving it.

Last but not least, does anyone know if Red Sun, Black Sand will actually be in Japanese? I recall reading that it would, but I'm still skeptical.

EDITED TO ADD: I'd also say that Unforgiven and Million Dollar Baby are the only films from the last fifteen years to deserve their Best Picture wins. I'd like to go so far as Annie Hall, but my knowledge of film history isn't comprehensive enough to know if Amadeus, Platoon, and The Last Emperor earned their wins or not.
post #32 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Highway 61
Last but not least, does anyone know if Red Sun, Black Sand will actually be in Japanese? I recall reading that it would, but I'm still skeptical.
We'll see how Mel's foreign language experiment goes.
post #33 of 378
If it gets released anytime soon. The Mel Gibson "I Hate Jews" Comedy Hour may have imperiled that little plan.
post #34 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Highway 61
Thoughts on the few films I have seen? Hmmm... Although Unforgiven and Million Dollar Baby affected me profoundly, I must say I don't care for Mystic River. Many critics were quite impressed with what the film had to say about violence, but whatever they saw, I couldn't find. The film doesn't allow proper time to explore the ramifications of violence and retribution in any satisfactory way, devoting most of its running time to the ho-hum mystery plotline instead. Moreover, Penn and Robbins are not that good in it. Bacon overshadowed them both. Probelm is, his character was burdened with a paper-thin subplot about his estranged wife. I actually thought the actor who played Penn's daughter's boyfriend gave the best performance in the film. He conveyed the most genuine sense of grief and anger, whereas Penn and Robbins merely riffed on personas created earlier in their careers. That said, I haven't given up totally on the film. I'll revisit it now and again, and may very well come around to loving it.
I totally agree. I thought it was a movie-of-the-week made better by some good performances, but not a great movie.
post #35 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Greg David
If it gets released anytime soon. The Mel Gibson "I Hate Jews" Comedy Hour may have imperiled that little plan.
Is that the latest word? I'd think since he isn't actually visible in the film it wouldn't be hurt that badly by the scandal. Also the last time people called him an anti-semite he set the box office on fire.
post #36 of 378
I really wish he'd stop working with Paul Haggis.
post #37 of 378
I think I missed something in Blood Work, because in each of the other movies that Eastwood directs (I think the only ones I've missed are Mystic River and True Crime), he brings an interesting and unusual point of view to whatever western/war/space movie he is telling.

For example, I have a theory that the cartoonish machismo and (barely) veiled homophobia/homoeroticism in Heartbreak Ridge were intended to add a layer of "this is my rifle, this is my gun" social commentary to this otherwise trite war movie. And friends with whom I share this theory generally have a theory that I am delusional.
post #38 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris Wood
Is that the latest word? I'd think since he isn't actually visible in the film it wouldn't be hurt that badly by the scandal. Also the last time people called him an anti-semite he set the box office on fire.
I actually haven't heard any official word, but the advertising thus far has emblazoned his name all over it. That's only natural if they want to ride the success of The Passion, but this will at least cause them to think about altering their marketing strategy. Putting off the release until the heat dies down doesn't seem completely out of line though.

And of course, the last time he was accused of anti-semitism, he hotly denied it, and there really wasn't any proving it. This time, there really is no getting around it.
post #39 of 378
I actually was disappointed in "Magnum Force" for the reasons Moltisanti liked it. If you watch the "DH" documentary, they sort of hint that it was their answer to the critics and audience members who thought "Dirty Harry" was too reactionary. So they sort of threw them a bone by making the cops the villains the second time out. Given that the first is so strong and in-your-face, it sort of feels like they pussed out. It's a fine cop film, but a lot of the bite is gone.

And I have much love for his last two flicks as a director despite the predictable backlash the accompanies them being successful.

Hate "Firefox" though, bored me to tears.
post #40 of 378
They might have been throwing the critics a bone with MAGNUM FORCE but I welcomed that dynamic of the rogue cops. The villains in those movies got pretty generic after the first 2, obviously there was Robinson in the original and a good crop of (at the time) young actors in FORCE.

Also, if you don’t fight back tears when Felton Perry opens that mailbox then it’s time to check your pulse.
post #41 of 378
Great Thread.

Favorite for me is The Outlaw Josie Wales. But also much love for the Dirty Harry's (Dead Pool included) The Gauntlet, Unforgiven, Absolute Power, In the Line of Fire, Kelly's Heroes, and Space Cowboys.

The ending of Mystic River just ruins it for me.
post #42 of 378
Thread Starter 
Hey hey, this ain't a Mel Gibson anti-semitism Appreciation Thread.

Anyways, I liked Magnum Force (Dirty Harry is my fav of the Harry movies) and I did like the bad guys. The bad guys just got more and more ridiculous after that. Espicially the guy in Sudden Impact who has to be THE WORST villian in any Clint film. "Get the bitch!" Ugh. And the crazy guy in Dead Pool who wanted to be Liam Neeson or some shit.
post #43 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Moltisanti
They might have been throwing the critics a bone with MAGNUM FORCE but I welcomed that dynamic of the rogue cops. The villains in those movies got pretty generic after the first 2, obviously there was Robinson in the original and a good crop of (at the time) young actors in FORCE.

Also, if you don’t fight back tears when Felton Perry opens that mailbox then it’s time to check your pulse.
It's a good movie, don't get me wrong, but it sort of sacrificed its bite. "Dirty Harry" will always be notable as a product of its time with a real, edgy point of view. And it made no apologies. "Magnum Force" basically did, which just disappointed me a little bit.

And I don't know which part of the "Mystic River" ruined it for Paul, but I just loved the little knowing look between Bacon and Penn, which made it all worth it.
post #44 of 378
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brendan
Hey hey, this ain't a Mel Gibson anti-semitism Appreciation Thread.

Anyways, I liked Magnum Force (Dirty Harry is my fav of the Harry movies) and I did like the bad guys. The bad guys just got more and more ridiculous after that. Espicially the guy in Sudden Impact who has to be THE WORST villian in any Clint film. "Get the bitch!" Ugh. And the crazy guy in Dead Pool who wanted to be Liam Neeson or some shit.
I actually liked "The Dead Pool" a lot more than "Sudden Impact", which is the lightest on plot of the five. The villains definitely begin to suck, but Clint gets some great moments.
post #45 of 378
In the Dead Pool, I liked the parts when Harry crashes the mobster's wedding, running from the bomb-rigged remote controlled car and the end when Clint harpoons the villain. Yeah, I'd also agree that it was better than the completely forgettable Sudden Impact.
post #46 of 378
I'm a little surprised to see this much discussion dedicated to the Dirty Harry movies. To me, those are pretty minor touchstones in his career. They paid the bills between interesting projects. Until recently, it was his self-directed westerns that really showed his strengths, and his willingness to deconstruct his own past.

I really hope he's not forever done with westerns. If anybody could make that genre work again, it's Eastwood.
post #47 of 378
I think HARRY's impact is a little more than just paying the bills. The last couple were probably done more to get funding for his passion projects. But the original, along with THE FRENCH CONNECTION, pretty much reinvented the cop film. I always wished he could have done one last good cop movie that could have deconstructed the whole genre like UNFORGIVEN did for westerns.
post #48 of 378
I'd certainly agree that the first film had a huge impact, not just on movies, but on the popular culture. It could almost be seen as the end of moral ambiguity for 70's cinema. Callahan was going to punish an evil man, and the law wasn't going to stand in his way. For a variety of reasons, it was something the public needed to see at the time.

I really don't think that any of the sequels were particularly memorable, though, outside of some one-liners that became national catch-phrases. It's hard to believe that "Go ahead...make my day" has hung on this long. I sometimes wonder if people use it without knowing what it's from.

Basically, I feel that the first film had a definite point of view, and something to offer the culture that it hadn't seen before. The sequels were just action movies.

edit:
Not to offend Moltisanti's worldview, or anything. I know the phrase "JUST an action movie" probably seems heretical to you.
post #49 of 378
It's definitely one of those lines, sort of like "I coulda been a contender," that people will do an impression of but most will not know quite what movie it's from.

I saw KELLY'S HEROES for the first time a few months back. I wasn't all that impressed. It wasn't really exciting enough to be a good "men on a mission" movie and none of the humorous elements worked well either. Disappointing considering the cast.
post #50 of 378
I was just trying to remember, apropos of nothing, the last time Clint acted in someone else's movie. I had to look it up. It was In The Line Of Fire, in 1993. So I guess he's past the point where he feels the need to pay bills. While looking that up, I noticed that he's doing voicework for a Dirty Harry videogame. I don't know how I feel about that.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Movie Miscellany
CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE MAIN SEWER › Movie Miscellany › The CLINT EASTWOOD Appreciation Thread