The Enforcer has some excellent moments of violence, but it's almost ruined by that lame-ass ending.
I would own it just because it's cheap and it's Clint and for the line, "That's my bike, Charley. This is my gun, Clyde."
The Rookie as I recall is awful although I havent seen it since the one time in the theater. The scene that pissed me off was where Clint gets raped by Raul Julia's slutty girlfriend, not really a rape per say, just a force fuck. Creepy. I would definitely call this film pedestrian. Especially for Clint, not so much for Sheen.
If you have one Dirty Harry, you have to have them all. I own the box set and it's a nice watch. If you find them cheap, nab'em. Your evil Wal-Mart should have them in the cheap bin for $5.50 or even less.
Sudden Impact is vastly overrated, it has some of the worst music of the five films too, although Clint does get some great one-liners off at the scumbag's expense, especially Audrey Neenan as the lezzie rapist.
Moli, do watch Dead Pool again, I dig that flick just for the fact that Callahan is a cantankerous old bastard and he doesn't care who knows it. The remote control car sequence is as fun as it is absurd. It has some nifty violence and as always, great one-liners. My favorite scene out of ALL of the Harry flicks is the prison scene when Clint tells a mafia stooge about being the mailman, priceless!
Plus a great cameo from Jim Carrey and a nasty turn by Liam Neeson. Flawed, but tons of fun.
Let me know your thoughts on Pool.