CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE CHEWERS › The Chewers Catch-All › Alternative to killing reputation. Vote here.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Alternative to killing reputation. Vote here. - Page 2  

Poll Results: See the love and hate?

 
  • 67% (92)
    Yes, allow us to see who gives us rep points. It'll make it fair.
  • 32% (44)
    No, it must be shunned along with the whole concept.
136 Total Votes  
post #51 of 139
If we will eventually see names, will comments that people sent in the past reveal their moniker? That would be very interesting.
post #52 of 139
I don't care either way. I'll happily list the people I have given negative reps to.
post #53 of 139
My God that would be glorious.
post #54 of 139
Would it be retroactive? If so, that'd be awesome. I think it'd be fun to find out who referred to me as "Jew" and now "Heebie". I'm not personally offended (this is the fucking Internet) but it'd make my day.
post #55 of 139
Why, so you can sue them with your cloven-footed hoard of Jew lawyers?
post #56 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ben (formally Ned Fats)
Would it be retroactive? If so, that'd be awesome. I think it'd be fun to find out who referred to me as "Jew" and now "Heebie". I'm not personally offended (this is the fucking Internet) but it'd make my day.
You wanna make something of it, hymie? I'll bust your big jew nose up.
post #57 of 139
Based on my understanding, it would be retroactive. I think that's why we're seeing a few folks who are vehemently against the change -- they don't want their bullshit exposed. (Note: I don't think this is true of everyone who opposes the change).
post #58 of 139
Fuck! I can't find that "LOL Gas Chamber" animated .gif anywhere!
post #59 of 139
The fuck is "Mel Gibson" doing here?
post #60 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mel Gibson
You wanna make something of it, hymie? I'll bust your big jew nose up.
That's fucking funny.
post #61 of 139
Yeah, my fire was robbed!
post #62 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slater
What's the point? The only thing fun about the system is that the anonymity gives people free reign to write weird, random and sometimes awesome nonsense. Forcing everyone to sign their posts will kill all of that, leaving you with a bunch of people saying "Good job" or "I disagree" all day long.
I'm with Slater or Matchstick, leave it alone or dump it.
post #63 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adam Warren
Why, so you can sue them with your cloven-footed hoard of Jew lawyers?
And after I'm going to celebrate by eating a bunch of gentile babies....
post #64 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mel Gibson
You wanna make something of it, hymie? I'll bust your big jew nose up.
OH MY GOD YES
post #65 of 139
post #66 of 139
I must say, I'm a big fan of the fruit born of this thread.
post #67 of 139
It's almost as though we should close that account now just to preserve the awesome.
post #68 of 139
You don't see me asking to close your account to perserve the lame, now do you?
post #69 of 139
So when's the curtain gonna be yanked back? I'm fucking excited!
post #70 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mel Gibson
You wanna make something of it, hymie? I'll bust your big jew nose up.
Millette?
post #71 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ben (formally Ned Fats)
And after I'm going to celebrate by eating a bunch of gentile babies....
Not surprising! Better go sharpen your claws, Christ-killer.
post #72 of 139
Make it public.

Course I already know which three lame fucks are behind all of mine. They just don't know that I find it really cute. Like bunnies in springtime cute...
post #73 of 139
Poor Django, assuming that only three people here dislike you. Way to aim low, chief.

I do think it's a little weird that Nick complains that the rep points are making the boards more negative, but he also wants to make all the past comments public....which is just going to make new enemies and fights break out left and right. Seriously, there's no other possible outcome. Which is fine with me, since I enjoy hatred, but it seems like a weird way to keep the peace.
post #74 of 139
I'm still confused as to why people are expecting a reveal to erupt into some bizarre internet orgy of vitriol. Are we that incapable of forgiving people for petty stuff?
post #75 of 139
Hope you'll forgive me for the negative I sent you Almighty. Though I signed yours so who gives a shit.
post #76 of 139
Damn you, Molt! I'll kill you!
post #77 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by AlmightyShmun
I'm still confused as to why people are expecting a reveal to erupt into some bizarre internet orgy of vitriol. Are we that incapable of forgiving people for petty stuff?
Are you new to the internets?
post #78 of 139
Unless we will be able to see all comments, not just the last 5, a reveal of who left which comments won't really be all that earth-shattering for anyone. I think I'll be able to sit just fine in the morning.

Oops. I just checked my User CP and the last 15 comments are displayed now. This should be fun.
post #79 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonvoight's car
Unless we will be able to see all comments, not just the last 5, a reveal of who left which comments won't really be all that earth-shattering for anyone. I think I'll be able to sit just fine in the morning.
We can already see more than the last 5 now. Nick must have tweaked that part of it already.

EDIT: You editing bastard.
post #80 of 139
If you've been here long enough you'll know that whether all hell breaks loose is irrelevent because this place is a madhouse anyway. Nick should just enable the option just to observe what happens, its like an academic study. He can always get rid of the rep system afterwards anyway.
post #81 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hewlett
We can already see more than the last 5 now. Nick must have tweaked that part of it already.

EDIT: You editing bastard.
Ha! At least you quoted me, so everyone knows what an editing bastard I am.
post #82 of 139
I don't know what this is supposed to achieve. The ones who would have said something negative will say nothing at all, and the ones who would say positive things will become even more sycophantic knowing that their devotion has been duly noted -- thereby increasing the circle jerk aspects of the board.

If this was about more than getting to watch "some sore asses in the morning", you would wipe clean the comments that have already been posted.
post #83 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by amadeus
I don't know what this is supposed to achieve. The ones who would have said something negative will say nothing at all, and the ones who would say positive things will become even more sycophantic knowing that their devotion has been duly noted -- thereby increasing the circle jerk aspects of the board.

If this was about more than getting to watch "some sore asses in the morning", you would wipe clean the comments that have already been posted.
This board hasn't been about anything other than circle jerkin' for years. Why do you think most of those who made it interesting fled to other parts?

At least this way we'd know who's hands are where...
post #84 of 139
Half the fun with the anonymous comments is figuring out who wrote them.

"Hmmm... the guy who called me 'Devin kiss-ass' might have been Baba, but it may have been Shmun too... Oh well, I'll just de-rep them both."
post #85 of 139
I spent a night playing Leland Gaunt with the rep feature trying to turn you all against one another and now it'll al be for nothing. My master plan destroyed before it even began.
post #86 of 139
So when's the big reveal?

The suspense is terrible...I hope it lasts...
post #87 of 139
I always sign my rep points, but I don't mind recieving anonymous ones. It's kind of funny seeing an unsigned "My god you are so unfunny" rep note.
post #88 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Striding Cloud Django
This board hasn't been about anything other than circle jerkin' for years. Why do you think most of those who made it interesting fled to other parts?
Yet you're still here.

That sounds more sarcastic than I meant it. I suck at being a sychophant.
post #89 of 139
The vote looks pretty decisive.
post #90 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by kingcujoI
The vote looks pretty decisive.
The Chewers!
United!
Will never be defeated!
post #91 of 139
Hell, I just want to see who the other TMBG fan on this board is (besides myself and MrMushnik).
post #92 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Joe LeFors
The Chewers!
United!
Will never be defeated!
One Chewer!
One struggle!
Stand united!
Stand spiteful!
post #93 of 139
Doesn't really work well at the beginning, but: http://chewers.youaremighty.com/
post #94 of 139
I'm not really for or against displaying user ids (since it's not all that productive a system anyway) but if you do that, won't people who get negative rep points just retaliate by giving their critic negative rep points back?

Like if I give Brad negative rep points for being an asshole (pick a post), then he's going to bring that big rep hammer of his down on me, I'll betya!

Seeing as how it proves very little about the poster, what's all the fuss about either way? It's not like I'm going to take Devin more seriously because he has 5 little green .gifs.

What we need is a 3rd poll on the subject...
post #95 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by whiskaz

What we need is a 3rd poll on the subject...
Maybe we should have a poll about the poll first.
Who thinks we should have a 3rd Poll?
-Yes! I love Polls!
-No, let's keep non-polling the status quo!
post #96 of 139
Democracy is great!
post #97 of 139
I don't think Nunz should cut them completely. At least not until I retake my position as most hated Chewer back from Kueller.

Come on, people. Get off your dead asses...
post #98 of 139
I think that if the rep points were to start having ID's, then we should at the same time wipe the points back to 0.

Do a big old F5.
post #99 of 139
Fuck you, lowbie.
post #100 of 139
Does that make you a highbie?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Chewers Catch-All
This thread is locked  
CHUD.com Community › Forums › THE CHEWERS › The Chewers Catch-All › Alternative to killing reputation. Vote here.