Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sacrilicious Supersucker
I agree. I've never understood the Beach Boys reverence or why this album always shows up between 1 and 3 on critics greatest albums ever lists. It's a more mature Beach Boys, but it's still the Beach Boys. Nothing in the lyrics or the music moves me in the least bit. It's always seemed like a lot of people love this album because they have to say they love it.
I respect DaveB's musical taste's and opinions, so I'd like to hear him explain this album to me. I'd really love to understand why this is genius, but I just don't get it.
|
It's all in the melodies and arrangements. The lyrics, in all their youthful naivete, wouldn't work with any other music. In fact, they would sound utterly ridiculous. But combined with those harmonies, they speak to some universal feelings on happiness, sadness, the loss of innocence, and the yearning for love.
Its greatest strength is the detail work. I don't mean this in any sort of "you need to be a music major" to get what Wilson was attempting, but rather that there's a ton of emotional nuance going on under those simple melodies and lyrics. For instance, "Wouldn't It Be Nice," which contains a fairly simple (and even happy and optimistic) sentiment on its face, has these quick moments in which the music expresses a weird trepidation and almost a melancholy.
"Caroline, No" does almost the opposite. It's probably the most downbeat song on Pet Sounds, lyrically and musically. Yet there are these sublime moments where the music climbs despite the lyric. It's one of music's most impressive moments of wallowing in sorrow - it's the way you wallow in sorrow when you're a teenager and
everything is dramatic.
As for "God Only Knows," I don't really know how to explain it if you don't get it. The appeal just seems sort of obvious to me, and I'm an atheist, at that.
Sure, "Sloop John B." and some of the other more straightforward moments like "I Know There's a Reason/Hang on to Your Ego" - they're palate cleansers on Pet Sounds, but tuneful enough that, on any other album, they'd probably be highlights.
I get not liking the Beach Boys of "Surfin' Safari" or the Beach Boys of
Smile (though I know some who consider it the equal to Pet Sounds, the lyrics are just too flakey, the music too cutesy for me to put it on that level). I
certainly get not liking the Beach Boys of "Kokomo." But I've always thought of Pet Sounds as the single great undeniable moment in their history - something not just nostalgists, music snobs, advertising execs (does anyone else's first Beach Boys memory involve Sunkist?), or John Stamos and his fabulous bongo playing, but
anyone who's been a teenager in the 20th century West, should be able to appreciate on some level.