CHUD.com Community › Forums › CREATURE CORNER › Creature Corner Main › Film Review: Saw III
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Film Review: Saw III

post #1 of 26
Thread Starter 
http://creature-corner.com/?type=reviews&id=1825

I'm not ashamed to admit I really enjoyed the new one. Hopefully someone agrees, feel more than free to disagree or call me an idiot as some tend to do but I'm really interested to know what'd you guys think?
post #2 of 26
It sounds like you really liked it. Why not just go for the 8.0, rather than the ho-hum 7.8?

The first Saw was a cheap thrill, and the second was a pretty needless exercise. If the third one can redeem the second, I'll give it a shot.
post #3 of 26
Thread Starter 
im pretty new to the site, and i think we need to work out the kinks in the ratings. i was giving it an 8 and i guess I was just like, was it really an 8? i liked it, but 8 seemed pretty high. but if its a school grade type score, i'd give it an 8.5 out of ten because it was definately a b in my opinion....oh and the wire is awesome.
post #4 of 26
I agree with a lot of the things said in the review. It did make the first two better in my opinion. I am looking forward to finding out, with pieces already in place from 3, how part 4 turns out.
Fun movie.
post #5 of 26
Hostel is not the best horror film of the year.
post #6 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Dark Shape
Hostel is not the best horror film of the year.
Dittoed. The Hills Have Eyes is still in my top 10 favorite movies of the year period.
post #7 of 26
Gotta say: Saw 3 was the best horror film I've seen in the month of October in a long time.
post #8 of 26
I really didn't like it. But then I really didn't like the first 2 either. I went because my cousin drags me along every year and I make him go to watch stuff he doesn't really love either so it's only fair. But even as big a Saw fan as he is (he will watch Saw on the big screen but not summer blockbusters?) he kept checking his watch. The traps were pretty cool and suitably nasty but much of the film felt like it had nowhere to go between the kills and was just padding it out. The main plot, was decent enough, although the ending was telegraphed at least halfway through, but the flashbacks and the other crap.. felt like they only served to help the movie run longer than 60 minutes because thats all the kills/plot they had. Any suspense that could have been injected into the twist of needing to keep Jigsaw alive was just thrown away. Maybe, I'm missing something as coming out people seemed to like it. Or maybe I'm confusing them talking about the blood with them thinking it was a good movie.
post #9 of 26
There was some fucking GREAT laughs in this. The frozen woman was ace, as were the judge's self-cleaning clothes. And the magic videotape in Dina Meyer's bedroom, can't forget that. The five hundred or so flashbacks got grating though.
post #10 of 26
Abysmal. Terrible gore, acting, direction, and editing. There's way too much nihilism for its own good. The first 3rd consists of useless traps, though I guess that was the film's "point." Oh and a 10-minute impromptu brain surgery sequence which is wholly unnecessary stretches the film to an unwieldy 100 minutes. I can think of no series whose quality has dropped so significantly after the first film. Sure, I’m not expecting art, but I am expecting to be entertained. All this showed me was that they ran out of ideas for traps and twists, so they had to resort to gore to pad out the story. Ugh.
post #11 of 26
I'm not going to see it, but spoil me- does it finally set the stage for SAW IV: IN SPACE?
post #12 of 26
No, it sets the stage for SAW IV: ALL THE VILLAINS ARE DEAD, BUT YOU'LL SHOW UP ANYWAY YOU MORONS.
post #13 of 26
Thread Starter 
no i understand your reasons for not liking it. for some reason it didn't rub me that way, maybe I was in the mood an abysmal gorefest. Which sometimes isn't that bad of a thing in my opinion. but look, the fourth one WILL be in space. That's just how its going to be. It doesn't matter if the stage is set or not, but between you and me...it is.
post #14 of 26
couldn't really stand the first one, so for the second one i just ended up reading the synopsis on wikipedia. after reading it i felt glad i didn't spend a dollar on the movie. just read the synopsis for the third film and once again, i'm glad i didn't spend a dollar on the film.
post #15 of 26
Good review. I really didn't care for a the first one, the second one I didn't even see, but I may rent this one when it hits DVD.
post #16 of 26
I almost fell asleep during Saw I's first five minutes.
post #17 of 26
Well what I love about SAW movies is not the fact the movie is terrible, or what not, but the audience reactions and more the overall experience of the whole crowd. That and it got my gf to jump.

edit: I'm loven this built in spell check in Firefox 2.0
post #18 of 26
I decided to give in to the hype for once regarding this franchise (I haven't seen the first two), and saw the film yesterday. It sucked. It sucked majorly. I've seen my last Saw.
post #19 of 26
Eat some fuck, SAW!
post #20 of 26
Just saw it moments ago....




Jesus wept....

I've seen my last Saw too. What a pile of backdoor jam....honestly. The Fountain wont make a fifth of the profit from this either - eat some fuck indeed.
post #21 of 26
Part 4 is on the way. To all of you who made this shit possible, I hope you all die in a house fire.
post #22 of 26
there is a bright side though. These 'films' (i do use that in the lightest sense possible) - are at least providing Lions Gate with big pockets. Lets hope they put it to good use.

Part four is going to be written by someone else for a change. So it could go either way to be fair. Could be shit or fucking disgraceful.
post #23 of 26
I've had no respect for Swa ever since I realised it was stealing from The Abominable Doctor Phibes
post #24 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by detonathor
I almost fell asleep during Saw I's first five minutes.

I was laughing my ass during SAW I's final thirty minutes. He laid on the floor without moving for 12 hours? Seriously, fuck this movie!
post #25 of 26
But didn't you see ! Of course, he injected himself with a drug to slow his heartrate for the exact length of time to the second that he'd been able to predict Whannel and Elwes would get to the whole 'sawing' thing. Didn't you see!!!...

An entire picture predicated on the off-chance your unpredictable disciple is going to go off the rails at the exact moment your new victim breaks free ? A new victim, by the way, who you must have been able to keep awesomely close tabs on from your hospital bed and labyrinthine lair while your entire life was spent setting up massive iron-wrought contraptions ?

Kudos to Bouseman for duping some hefty dough out of the cinema-going public, but I hope beyond hope this doesn't get him some rep as a 'good' horror director. Nothing that works in the picture (which is very little) is anything to do with the direction.

Hostel may be a grim, if lightweight, romp, but it has leagues more style, wit, verve, pace and heart than this awful, pointlesly nihilistic series which started pretty good and went downhill faster than Police Academy: Assignment Miami Beach.

There's a Kevin Smith-circa-1994-style observational skit in there somewhere about the skilled iron-monger population of the West coast that has assisted Jigsaw since whenever-it-was-his-plan-started (and whatever length hair Shawnee SMith had at the time):

"You want what? A 3 ton crucifix with a rack attachment for twisting limbs? What's this for now?"

Thank you, youth of America. Thank you and you annoying capacity for lapping gratingly edited, hideously reductive gore-porn.

At least I went in on a comp ticket.
post #26 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Straxboy - An Anthony Hickox Film
There's a Kevin Smith-circa-1994-style observational skit in there somewhere about the skilled iron-monger population of the West coast that has assisted Jigsaw since whenever-it-was-his-plan-started (and whatever length hair Shawnee SMith had at the time):

"You want what? A 3 ton crucifix with a rack attachment for twisting limbs? What's this for now?"
Well, he probably went to the same place that made the bladed dildo for John Doe.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Creature Corner Main
CHUD.com Community › Forums › CREATURE CORNER › Creature Corner Main › Film Review: Saw III