I'd argue that Benson was a better character on Soap than he was on his own show.
post #101 of 707
12/11/08 at 2:30pm
Be a part of the community.
It's free, join today!
|
i
82. James McNulty - Dominic West - The Wire While on the surface he may appear to be the lone wolf cop who does anything to solve the case, The Wire accurately shows why he's like this: he's a complete fuckup. Lone wolves often are that way because they cannot handle anything else in life but their job. He drinks too much, he sleeps around and he flicks the bird to authority at almost every turn. And yet, he's the (human) character the show always comes back to (granted that the entire city of Baltimore is the main character). He may be a complete screw up in real life, but that never means that his heart isn't in the right place. A straighter, truer cop there never was. |
|
Schwartz, and granted I haven't seen season 5 yet, I guess 'straighter and truer' is glossing over his more...irritable tendencies. What I was getting at is that, personally, if I were ever murdered, I'd want Jimmy McNulty on the case. Many of the cops on the show treat their job as just that, a job, but with McNulty, there's always this fire, this hunger in him that's yearning to do right by whoever. It never goes away. In other words, he takes his work home with home every single night. That's why he goes the extra mile to discover what really happened to D'Angelo, and why he tirelessly goes about investigating the floater in season 2. He treats it more like a calling, though he does it because, and I think Bunk said, he'd explode if he didn't.
Oh, this is a once a day per poster thing, right? |
|
I believe it's more that his mild retardation is what keeps from realizing that "Night Man" comes off as a song about childhood rape.
|
|
88. Marvin - Stephen Moore (Voice) - The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy (BBC)
One of the greatest characters out of one of the greatest novels of all times. And Marvin the paranoid android might very well be the most famous of Douglas Adams plenty creations. The manical robot with the brain the size of a planet yet rarely given the chance to display it is responsible for the most frequent and hilarious one-liners out of the sheer treasure of material. While never actually paranoid he remains sorrow and demeaning the entire series. Though he shows great stoicism and earnest to fulfill the burdens that are laid upon him by his fellow hitchhikers. Mostly he just waits for millions of years for his employees or to park space ship. And most of the time he doesn´t really enjoy it. Moores delivery of Marvins morose lines kills in the BBC version. Which gets most of the pivotal things about the adaption close to perfection where the movie failed. And not a small part of that feat does belong to the dispiction of Marvin and his monotone and depressed voice. Albeit the series has production values that would turn Ed Wood pale it works like a charm. |
|
1. Al Swearengen - Ian McShane - Deadwood
2. Lucy Ricardo - Lucille Ball - I Love Lucy 3. Killer Bob - Frank Silva - Twin Peaks 4. Basil Fawlty - John Cleese - Fawlty Towers 5. Louis DePalma - Danny DeVito - Taxi 6. Al Bundy - Ed O'Neill - Married...With Children 7. President Jed Bartlet - Martin Sheen - The West Wing 8. Gob Bluth - Will Arnett - Arrested Development 9. Vic Mackey - Michael Chiklis - The Shield 10. Hank Kingsley - Jeffery Tambor - The Larry Sanders Show 11. Adam Schiff - Steven Hill - Law and Order 12. Niles Crane - David Hyde Pierce - Frasier 13. Jack Tripper - John Ritter - Three's Company 14. Reginald Perrin - Leonard Rossiter - The Fall and Rise of Reginald Perrin 15. Captain James T. Kirk - William Shatner - Star Trek: TOS 16. Jack Bauer - Kiefer Sutherland - 24 17. Peter Dragon - Jay Mohr - ACTION! 18. Tony Soprano - James Gandolfini - The Sopranos 19. Number 6 - Patrick McGoohan - The Prisoner 20. David Brent - Ricky Gervasis - The Office (UK) 21. Deputy Chief of Staff Joshua Lyman - Bradley Whitford - The West Wing 22. Detective John Munch - Richard Belzer - Homicide: Life on the Street 23. President Laura Roslin - Mary McDonnell - Battlestar Galactica 24. Dr. Perry Cox - John C. McGinley - Scrubs 25. Lt. Columbo - Peter Falk - Columbo 26. Detective Frank Pembleton - Andre Braugher - Homicide: Life on the Street 27. Bender Bending Rodriguez - John DiMaggio (voice) - Futurama 28. George Costanza - Jason Alexander - Seinfeld 29. Omar Little - Michael K. Williams - The Wire 30. Homer Simpson - Dan Castanella (voice) - The Simpsons 31. Cliff Huxtable - Bill Cosby - The Cosby Show 32. Commander Ed Straker (S.H.A.D.O.) - Ed Bishop - UFO 33. The Doctor - (deep breath) William Hartnell, Patrick Troughton, Jon Pertwee, Tom Baker, Peter Davison, Colin Baker, Sylvester McCoy, Christopher Eccleston, and David Tennant - Doctor Who 34. Det. Lennie Briscoe - Jerry Orbach - Law and Order 35. Londo Mollari - Peter Jurasik - Babylon 5 36. Winnie Cooper - Danica McKeller - The Wonder Years 37. Elizabeth Anne "Buffy" Summers - Sarah Michelle Gellar - Buffy The Vampire Slayer 38. Arthur Herbert Fonzarelli - Henry Winkler - Happy Days 39. Tiberius Claudius Caesar Augustus Germanicus - Derek Jacobi - I, Claudius (BBC) 40. Archie Bunker - Carol O'Connor - All In The Family 41. Eric Cartman - Trey Parker (Voice) - South Park 42. Dr. Doug Ross - George Clooney - ER 43. Barnabas Collins - Jonathn Frid - Dark Shadows 44. Maude Findlay - Bea Arthur - Maude 45. Larry David - Curb Your Enthusiasm 46. Beavis and Butthead - Mike Judge (voice) - Beavis and Butthead 48. William "Bill" Haverchuck - Martin Starr - Freaks and Geeks 47. Samuel "Mayday" Malone - Ted Danson - Cheers 48. Eddie Haskel - Ken Osmond - Leave it to Beaver 49. Barney Fife - Don Knotts - The Andy Griffith Show 50. Edmund Blackadder - Rowan Atkinson - Blackadder 51. Dr. Sam Beckett - Scott Bakula - Quantum Leap 52. Dexter - Michael C. Hall - DEXTER 53. Angus MacGyver - Richard Dean Anderson - MacGyver 54. Michael Scott - Steve Carrell - The Office 55. Sgt. Phil Esterhaus - Michael Conrad - Hill Street Blues 56. Mary Richards - Mary Tyler Moore - The Mary Tyler Moore Show 57. Edith Bunker - Jean Stapleton - All in the Family 58. Hilary Norman "Norm" Peterson - George Wendt - Cheers 59. Zapp Brannigan - Billy West - Futurama 60. Benjamin Linus - Michael Emerson - Lost 61. Carl Kolchak - Darren McGavin - Kolchak: The Night Stalker 62. Don Draper - Jon Hamm - Mad Men 63. Liz Lemon - Tina Fey - 30 Rock 64. Special Agent Dale Cooper - Kyle MacLachlan - Twin Peaks 65. Shane Vendrell - Walton Goggins - The Shield 66. David Addison - Bruce Willis - Moonlighting 67. Kermit the Frog - Jim Henson - The Muppet Show 68. Spock - Leonard Nimoy - Star Trek 69. District Attorney Jack McCoy - Sam Waterson - Law and Order 70. Ralph Wiggum - Nancy Cartwright - The Simpsons 71. Benson - Robert Guillaume - Benson 72. Bill McNeil - Phil Hartman - Newsradio 73. Alan Shore - James Spader - Boston Legal 74. Cheryl West - Robyn Malcolm - Outrageous Fortune 75. Ari Gold - Jeremy Piven - Entourage 76. Arnold Judas Rimmer - Chris Barrie - Red Dwarf 77. Malcolm Reynolds - Nathan Fillion - Firefly 78. J.R. Ewing - Larry Hagman - Dallas 79. Barney Stinson - Neil Patrick Harris - How I Met your Mother 80. The Monarch - voiced by Christopher McCulloch - The Venture Brothers. 81. Dr. Eddie "Fitz" Fitzgerald - Robbie Coltrane - Cracker 82. James McNulty - Dominic West - The Wire 83. Dr. Gaius Baltar - James Callis - Battlestar Galactica 84. Carmela Soprano - Edie Falco - The Sopranos 85. Reinhold Fielding Elmore BKA Daniel R. Fielding - John Larroquette - Night Court 86. DCI Gene Hunt - Phillip Glenister - Life On Mars (UK) 87. Reginald "Bubbles" Cousins - Andre Royo - The Wire 88. Charlie Kelly - Charlie Day - It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia 89. Marvin - Stephen Moore (Voice) - The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy (BBC) 90. Sun Hwa Kwon - Yunjin Kim - Lost 91. Chandler Bing - Matthew Perry - Friends 92. Jaye Tyler - Caroline Dhavernas - Wonderfalls 93. First Spear Centurion Lucius Vorenus - Kevin McKidd - Rome 94. Michael Westen - Jeffrey Donovan - Burn Notice 95. Shawn Spencer - James Roday - Psych James Roday brings an unmatched level of manic energy to the role of Shawn Spencer. And even more amazing, it's not a one-note performance, as it could easily have been. Spencer appears to be a man-child, but it is as much a performance as his "psychic powers". But really, essentially it's all about the crazy dances. |
|
I'd argue that Benson was a better character on Soap than he was on his own show.
|
|
You need to see 5 like now. A lot of this is addressed, and even echoed in your exact words, but he also takes things farther than ever before. And its never been some holy quest for him to clean up the streets. Sure, the constant "misdemeanor murders" in the ghetto piss him off, but that's not what drives him. It's intellectual vanity, umbrage at the thought that these mopes could get one over on him, Jimmy McNulty, the smartest guy in the room. There's a scene early in 5 where he's arguing for pursuing Marlo more aggressively and he shouts "He does not get to win! We get to win!" That's it in a nutshell.
This only makes him a better character, imo. |